The opening of Shakespeare's Globe in 1997 engendered an abundance of new scholarly works that investigated the cultural meanings produced in and by a historically oriented performance space, the theatrical effects that could be achieved in an Elizabethan-style playhouse, and what practice-based research might reveal about the historical performance practices of the early modern theatre. This cycle began anew with the 2014 opening of the Globe's Sam Wanamaker Playhouse (SWP), a “self-styled ‘archetype’ of the indoor playhouses of Elizabethan, Jacobean and Caroline London” (xviii). Will Tosh's Playing Indoors: Staging Early Modern Drama in the Sam Wanamaker Playhouse examines the creation, reception, and performance practices of this “new” candlelit theatre. It is among the first wave of monographs to ask of the Wanamaker some of the same important and generative questions that were initially posed about Shakespeare's Globe.
The Prologue and first chapter lay out the historical and critical landscape for the book. Tosh details the institutional and scholarly impetuses for the Globe's long-held plan to build an indoor counterpart to their outdoor playhouse. The SWP is framed as both the product of historical research (and debate) about the architecture of sixteenth- and seventeenth-century indoor playhouses and—through practice-based research in the theatre—the site of further studies that potentially can shed new light on early modern performance practices.
Chapter 2 explores cultural attitudes toward the performance of Jacobean drama in the SWP during the theatre's first two seasons. Tosh argues that, in addition to the modes of promotion used for productions like The Duchess of Malfi (dir. Dominic Dromgoole, 2014), the SWP's candlelit and sable-painted materiality did little to dislodge popular and academic perceptions of Jacobean drama as being “sensational” (31) and “dark” (33), or what Tosh terms “Jacobean noir” (28). Furthermore, the contrasting responses of the press to the Globe and the SWP are read as the product of a shift in cultural attitudes toward Shakespeare in general, and Shakespeare's Globe in particular, over the seventeen years that separate the theatres’ inaugural performances. Whereas the Globe was charged with promoting a populist and commodified cultural image of Shakespeare, Tosh finds that by the time the Wanamaker opened in 2014, such accusations were rendered moot in a cultural industry in the throes of a “craze for heritage” (40).
It is at this point that Tosh's monograph takes on “the contours of an archival investigation” (48). The subsequent four chapters leverage interviews conducted with practitioners and audience members during the SWP's first three seasons in order to conduct an extensive and often persuasive assessment of how performance practices were developed in response to particular aspects of the Wanamaker's materiality. Critical reflections on how contemporary performance might be suggestive of early modern theatrical practices are woven into each chapter, and these reflections are supported with references to seventeenth-century texts as well as works by scholars of early modern drama such as Farah Karim-Cooper, Jeremy Lopez, and Penelope Woods.
Chapter 3 concerns initial responses of practitioners and audiences to the jewellike candlelit space and includes a particularly insightful discussion of the affects produced for some audience members by the “bijou splendour of the playhouse” (57). Chapter 4 considers the vocal, physical, and gestural techniques adopted by actors in response to the material conditions of performance in the Wanamaker, such as some actors feeling compelled by the limited physical dimensions of the space to “experiment with more contained styles of performance” (90). In Chapter 5, Tosh deals with the artistic and practical considerations of working with wax candles and their sometimes-temperamental naked flames. Chapter 6 examines the “non-unitary” (139) spectatorial experiences produced within the Wanamaker's intimate confines. Tosh convincingly argues that even actors “accustomed to Globe-style interactivity” (129) found the SWP's smaller, horseshoe-shaped auditorium—with its densely packed spectators, who sometimes had better views of each other than of the stage—created a different actor–audience relationship than the larger Globe space. Throughout the book, Tosh takes seriously the perspectives offered by practitioners and audience members. Their insights are carefully deployed in support of arguments about how meaning is produced in the Sam Wanamaker Playhouse even as Tosh also successfully allows the voices of interviewees to form a nascent cultural history of this theatre.
The concluding two chapters document how the Globe's Research in Action workshops in the summers of 2014 and 2015 sought to examine, through practice-based research, specific unresolved issues related to performance in a Jacobean-era indoor theatre. The documented workshops, many of which were coordinated by the author, consider specific problems of stagecraft (Chapter 7) as well as the performance of music and use of lighting (Chapter 8). How might an aside work on a crowded stage that “lacks the expansive breadth of the Globe's” (147)? How does the SWP's architecture, with its “insistent interiority” (53), nevertheless facilitate the presentation of outdoor scenes in a way that is consonant with early modern conceptions of interpersonal privacy? Can audience members determine the different locations in the theatre from which musical and sound effects are produced?
Taken together, the assemblage of evidence gathered by Tosh demonstrates the book's central claim: that performance in the SWP is “characterized by a multiplicity of spectator and performer responses, a variety with implications for the ways in which the early modern dramas staged in it are understood” (45). The adoption of a broad-sweeping archival investigation into performance in the SWP does sometimes preclude the author from a more sustained examination of some recurring tensions in practitioner testimonies. For example, only in brief instances does the book begin to tease out the theatrical consequences of what Tosh aptly identifies as the conflict between the “contemporary requirements of dramatic naturalism” and the “performance demands” of the SWP's historically informed material conditions of performance (61). Nonetheless, the thematic collating of an impressive array of practitioner, audience, press, and academic testimonies responding to the SWP's unique materiality will no doubt be of use both to practitioners seeking a workable understanding of this performance space and to academics, who will base their own arguments about the Wanamaker upon the primary materials that have been so judiciously gathered, organized, and analyzed in this volume.
