In European Human Rights and Family Law, Shazia Choudhry and Jonathan Herring provide a detailed discussion of the actual and potential application of human rights law to family law in the UK. The book draws on around 350 cases from the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) and over 400 UK domestic cases in detailing the relevance of the European Convention on the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (ECHR) and the Human Rights Act 1998 (HRA) to family law in the UK.
Although the book is not separated into parts, there are two distinct sections. In the first, which has three chapters occupying 140 pages, the authors set out general principles of human rights law which are important for understanding the remainder of the book. In the second part, which has seven main chapters, specific areas of family law are considered from a human rights perspective.
The first three chapters are, at first sight, rather lengthy, but the authors have taken the sensible precaution of assuming no detailed knowledge on the part of the reader about the functioning of the European human rights jurisprudence. Moreover, as they point out, ‘[i]t is, rather embarrassingly, difficult to define a human right’ (p. 106), and therefore some time is spent discussing that issue.
In Chapter 1, the authors look at the ECHR itself and set out the structure and working of the relevant articles within it. They also provide a full explanation of the relationship between the margin of appreciation and proportionality, which they see as being roughly inverse: in other words, ‘the wider the margin [of appreciation], the less strict the standard of review’ which the ECtHR will bring to the issue (p. 26). Chapter 2 is focused on the UK adoption of the ECHR into domestic law through the HRA. There is relevance beyond the family law arena to much of this chapter, such as the definition of a public authority under Section 6 HRA, or the difference between deference, discretionary areas of judgment, and the margin of appreciation. As the authors point out, this distinction has often been rather glossed over by the UK courts, and it was helpful to have the boundaries of each doctrine set out clearly. Chapter 3 then draws these themes together as they apply specifically to family law, though much of the material here too is more general in nature. We see, for instance, discussion about what rights are, and how our conception of human rights fits within broader understandings – and, perhaps, misunderstandings – of what rights are.
It would be fair to say that these three chapters are not intended to say anything terribly novel. Indeed, the authors say of the second chapter that it has ‘not sought to present or argue for a particular interpretation of the HRA’, but has, rather, ‘sought to fully set out the relevant debates’ (p. 96). Moreover, while readers might agree with the authors that some of this material can appear ‘abstract and overly technical’ (p. 138), there is an extent to which one simply needs to know it.
From there, European Human Rights and Family Law proceeds with seven substantive chapters on particular aspects of family law as they might be addressed from a human rights perspective. Chapter 4 looks at marriage, and specifically rights under Articles 8, 12 and 14. As is perhaps unsurprising, the focus here is on transgendered persons and same-sex marriage, though there are other, less obvious possibilities which could have been addressed, like the limitations on domestic restrictions on the right to marry, or even what marriage means at all. Does the French pacte civil de solidarité (PACS) fall within Article 12? Is there any relevance in the fact that UK law translates a same-sex PACS couple into civil partners if the union is registered in the UK, but that an opposite-sex PACS couple has no relationship recognised by the UK?
Chapter 5 addresses parenthood and the rights of parents in respect of their family life, and Chapter 6 looks at children's rights. As the authors note, there are few cases in the ECtHR which address children's rights entirely separately from adults' rights, since ‘[f]ew children will have the stamina, money, or time to bring a case to the ECtHR’ (p. 221). However, that does not mean that there is not much to say on the issue, and the authors set out to show how the courts ‘could develop an approach more focused on children's rights’ (p. 241).
In Chapter 7, the authors turn to private law children's cases, addressing contact with non-resident parents, relationships with grandparents, disputes over religious upbringing and over relocation. Chapter 8 then looks at public law from a human rights perspective. Here, the authors start with the right to be protected from abuse, which creates a number of both positive and negative obligations on the state. The authors also cover procedural requirements, the process of taking a child into care, the obligations to promote contact and reunion with the child's family once a child has been taken into state care, and issues around adoption in child protection cases.
Domestic violence is the topic of Chapter 9, which looks briefly at the present UK law before turning to focus in detail on the possible impact of the ECHR. Finally, in Chapter 10 the authors turn to an issue to which ‘[r]elatively little attention has been paid by family lawyers’ (p. 396), namely the possible effects of the HRA on the financial aspects of family law. The chapter addresses ancillary relief, child support, and the property rights of unmarried cohabitants. The book closes with a short chapter of concluding thoughts, where Choudhry and Herring reiterate the importance of human rights, and look forward to future possibilities, such as the possible implementation of a British Bill of Rights.
The issues involved here are complex, and the book, to some extent inevitably, involves dense material which requires the reader's full attention. Indeed, in part because of this underlying complexity, the book is not an easy read, and may be too difficult for some students to absorb in its entirety. However, it is not clear that the authors would intend such a use for their book, and the issues are neatly separated out so as to enable readers to pick particular issues and obtain a detailed discussion of them.
Although there has been much written on the subject of human rights in UK law in recent years – not least by Choudhry and Herring themselves – this book shows that there is still more to be said. As John Eekelaar puts it in his foreword to European Human Rights and Family Law, a detailed examination of human rights is a good way to assist in ‘dispelling the kind of myths and misunderstandings which build up an impetus of derision about “rights”’ (p. v), and this book contributes to this important task.
