The contemporary transnational turn in US historiography has many manifestations, and one of the most common over the last two decades has been the embrace of the study of the nation's borderlands. Attention to the interaction and movement of peoples across borders took precedence at first, and the study of Mexican–American contacts gained particular prominence in that work. More recently, the creation of borders themselves and interest in how the tightening national border controls circumscribed or changed trans-bordered relations have entered the agenda. Benjamin H. Johnson and Andrew R. Graybill's Bridging National Borders in North America is a product of the second phase of modern transnational scholarship, in which the reality of borders is treated as a central concern. It brings together some of the best new scholarship in this field. The transnational spaces of the Mexican–US border and the US border with Canada have been studied in the past, but systematic comparisons of the two borderlands have rarely, if ever, been made before. The book originated in a conference at Simon Fraser University, Vancouver, and the editors have made good use of the networks developed there. A striking feature of this collection is the strong editorial leadership exhibited in the effort to integrate these studies. The editors, and other contributors, refer frequently to each other's work, lending to the book a greater coherence as a research project than is often the case with collected essays.
The book has an excellent introduction that explores the history, historiography and methodology of transnational studies concerning North American border regions in Canadian, Mexican and US scholarship. Graybill and Johnson stress that border procedures are coercive, but that they are also negotiated and modified by various groups. They note regional and local particularities along the borders, not just broad borderlands.
It would be invidious to single out the individual essays too much, as all have value. Some stress cross-border contacts. In his study of the Texas–Mexico border from 1840 to 1880, Miguel Angel González Quiroga states that, driven by the search for markets, labour and, in the case of missionaries, souls, Mexicans and US citizens sought cooperation as much as they engaged in conflict over borders. Influential Texas merchants provided ‘men, money, and arms to Porfirio Díaz in his struggle to gain power during the Tuxtepec Revolt of 1876’ because they wanted ‘border violence to cease’ (p. 38). Michael Hogue examines anomalies presented by the Métis people of Canada and the United States, who did not fit neatly into the boxes of ‘either’ white or ‘Indian’ and yet were often forced to choose between the two by the solidification of borders and the racial categorisations that accompanied it.
Other essays deal with the mechanism of border control. Andrea Geiger shows how minorities who were discriminated against at the point of entry tried to use the transit-between-states privilege to gain access, but were sometimes confounded by the fact that different and incompatible laws in Canada and the United States left would-be transit passengers in legal limbo. S. Deborah Kang's essay, ‘Crossing the Line: The INS and the Federal Regulation of the Mexican Border’, is especially enlightening because it focuses on the intricate operation of border policies and how these diverged from superficial national top-down pressures.
Still others treat the conceptualisation of borders in popular culture. This book does not deal with contemporary representations in novels such as No Country for Old Men, but the work of Dominique Brégent-Heald looks at film representations of borders from the open borders of the early twentieth century to the era of stronger enforcement by 1940, showing, for example, representations of cooperation between Canadians and Americans and positive portrayals of Canadian officials in media as evidence. Her contribution, ‘Projecting the In-Between: Cinematic Representations of National Borders in North America, 1908–1940’, is even-handed in its treatment of the Canadian and Mexican borders. From a different angle, Catherine Cocks studies ‘racial Romanticism’ in the image of the ‘old Mexico’ that drew tourists to a mythic ‘Southland’ encompassing California and, she claims, the contiguous Mexican territory. Still on the theme of representations, Bethel Saler and Carolyn Podruchny examine the treatment of the fur trade in historical practice and historiography, emphasising how both professional and applied history have reinforced national boundaries. In contrast, for indigenous peoples, values of kinship networks and material activities constituted ‘aboriginal geographies’ (p. 298) and, together with the transnational and local complexities of the fur trade, cut across simple nationalist conceptions of space.
Environmental concerns are necessarily important in transnational history. Here they are directly dealt with by Lissa Wadewitz, in her essay ‘The Scales of Salmon: Diplomacy and Conservation in the Western Canada–U.S. Borderlands’, and by Jennifer Seltz, who notes the role of epidemic disease in efforts to construct more effective borders in the nineteenth-century Pacific Northwest. In a polished and analytically impressive piece on the transnational ranching of the Slaughter family in Arizona, Rachel St. John treats the cross-border movement of livestock and its effects as ranchers both shaped and responded to changes in border control in order to maintain their transnational operations.
As a whole, this book is a valuable contribution to transnational history because of its analytical focus on border-making and the responses of people to this process. Because of its basis in original research and coverage of both Canadian and Mexican borders, it advances well beyond such works as Sterling Evans' edited collection, The Borderlands of the American and Canadian Wests (Lincoln, NE: University of Nebraska Press, 2006). For Latin Americanists, the book provides many insights into the southern borderlands of the United States while not privileging Mexico's US border. This volume does not directly engage contemporary border controversies or post-Second World War border relations, but it does allow a historical perspective on current trends. The essays reward attention through their empirical contributions to transnational history and their emphasis on complexity, rather than any large-scale generalisations.
