Mark Golden, an authority on ancient Greek and Roman sport, contributes further to the literature with his third book on this topic, Greek Sport and Social Status. As he states in the preface, this book is a continuation of his Sport and Society in Ancient Greece (1998), a well-coordinated collection of essays on the topic. This book, which is written in plain English with limited use of jargon but many intriguing comparisons with familiar modern sports, will benefit a wide range of readers, from experts to undergraduates to the general public, all those who are interested in the politics of sport. Each main chapter can be inserted into the syllabus of undergraduate (or even advanced high school) courses on Greek and Roman society and politics. Of course, readers who are familiar with ancient Greek and Roman history, classics, and geography will benefit from it more.
Golden weaves together four different but loosely connected topics to illustrate how ancient Greek sport has been used to achieve and maintain social status in both ancient Greece and modern times. The first chapter details how the elite Greek competitors ignored the indispensable contributions of their jockeys, charioteers, and trainers to their glorious victories in athletic competition. They did not share the fruits of athletic victory—their improved social status—with those ignorable underlings. “The victor in the horse race was said to win ‘with a horse,’ hippōi, and not with a jockey” (12). “The contributions of trainers and coaches to athletic success were ignored or downgraded much like those of jockeys and charioteers” (26) owing to the athletic competition's elitist or aristocratic nature. In particular, Golden points out that the elites favored equestrian events over athletic events because of the restricted pool of rivals, illustrating the importance of social status as an element in Greek sport.
Chapter 2 shows that sport was one of the means by which Greeks separated themselves from barbarians and free citizens from slaves—even though slaves were heavily involved in training, managing gymnasia, and many other tasks in sport. Sport was a deadly serious business for the Greeks, who shared little with the American (and other) slave owners who allowed their slaves to participate in and enjoy sports to some extent. The Greek view was that slaves should not take part in sports competitions lest they taint the elites' achievement. In an identical vein, Golden rightly points out the strategy of “exclusion” to settle “the inconvenient reality” of physical superiority of some slaves over free persons and especially the elites in the hierarchical and competitive Greek society. Golden connects this strategy to the shrewd aristocratic idea of the “amateur,” utilized by a modern elitist, Pierre de Coubertin, the founder of modern IOC Olympics (chap. 4).
Golden's most ambitious argument comes in chapter 3. He denies the typical contrast between Greek athletic competition (agōn) and the Roman gladiatorial show, instead locating gladiators in the realm of athletes in the Greek world. He skillfully demonstrates that the Greeks, who enjoyed heavy sports such as boxing, wrestling, and pankration (a mixture of boxing and wrestling), were unexpectedly bloodthirsty; and the gladiators in the Greek east yearned for the status of athletes. He goes further, making a seemingly too ambitious contention that “gladiatorial spectacles have as much right to be considered ‘sport’ as do the events of the standard athletic program of Greek festivals”(89). His use of accidental death in modern sports as evidence to equate the deaths of gladiators would not, however, be convincing to most readers. Despite some exceptions excavated by Golden, most gladiators did not want to participate in an activity that likely ended in their death. It is hard to see how the typical gladiatorial combat has many things in common with athletic competition—sport.
Rather, Golden might want to focus more on the briefly mentioned “entertainment” aspect of gladiatorial and athletic competitions not only in the Greek and Roman world but also modern times. It is because modern athletes embrace, if not promote, the entertaining (and marketable) aspect of their performances that these performances can be equated with those of gladiators. Many professional athletes, such as a NBA star Kevin Garnett, identify themselves as “gladiators” or “warriors” (mainly for marketing purposes); and many American sports commentators scream during the live broadcasts, “The gladiators are gladiating it out!” Modern athletes are “entertainers” as much as the Greek gladiators. The modern Olympic Games are also the venue for an entertaining show of “gladiators' gladiating” to give spectators fun and excitement. The modern gladiating athletes gain high social status (and wealth), but without risking their lives (almost all the time).
The last chapter brings the story of how Greek sport continues to be used to enhance status up to the present day, stressing the role of the International Olympic Committee (IOC). Golden's detailed illustration of twelve differences between the Greek Olympics and the IOC Olympics, the dubious origins of modern Olympics, and the farfetched use of mythical Olympic truce for the present, all give us some useful information. These examples warn of the hazards of misuse of “the history of the past to shape the present, to the detriment of both” (136) in the politics of sport. Unfortunately, Golden's criticism is still not clear. He could have problematized these simple illustrations of differences between the Greek and modern Olympics in regularity, location, program, categories, facilities, nationalism, and so forth, to help us ponder the political role of sport in modern times, rather than simply debunking the blind juxtaposition of the Greek and modern IOC Olympics.
Nevertheless, Golden's criticism of “amateurism” in early modern Olympics should draw the attention of political theorists. He says it is “an invention of the mid-nineteenth century … to preserve high-status competition (and its benefits) for the elite” (136). He could have added, however, that this strategy of “amateurism” to exclude the poor from elite athletic competition has not been very successful in modern sport, including the IOC Olympics. Many, if not most, successful modern athletes are from poor rather than rich backgrounds, owing to the worldwide progress toward a slavery-free, class-mobile, and equal society. We all know that sport has become highly popularized in the contemporary world, making it harder for elites to manipulate sport to enforce and protect their social status by direct participation. In this context, Golden's criticism does not go beyond the initial stage of modern sports. This is partly because this type of simple comparison does not “control” for other social, economic, and political factors which also significantly influence the subject.
This book surely helps students of politics ponder the role of sport in both ancient and modern politics. Even though some of the author's arguments might be problematic and not fully developed from the perspective of a political theorist (not a historian), the provocative arguments, evidence, and bibliography are definitely valuable. Reading Greek Sport and Social Status is a good starting point to pursue the topic of the politics of sport.
