Stephen Haynes' The Last Segregated Hour: The Memphis Kneel-Ins and the Campaign for Southern Church Desegregation is a fascinating look at a facet of the civil rights movement—kneel-ins—that has received scant attention from historians. If scholars have primarily focused on challenges to racial segregation and discrimination in civic spaces such as schools, public accommodations, and workplaces, Haynes demonstrates how challenges to segregation in churches expanded debates about the legitimacy and morality of segregation to ecclesiastical spaces that were largely beyond the purview of the Fourteenth Amendment and state intervention. In a thoughtful volume that attends to the complex theological and institutional structure of churches, Haynes demonstrates how pointed direct action campaigns and broad cultural and ideological transformations in postwar America shaped the trajectory of reform and reaction in houses of worship.
In the early 1960s, interracial groups of religiously devout activists set their sights on one of the most profoundly segregated institutions in the Jim Crow South: the church. Dressed in their Sunday best, they visited churches throughout the region. In many cases, white churches welcomed activists in ways that ranged from open arms to conditional expressions of Christian courtesy, and channeled—if sometimes reluctantly—“Christ's reconciling love.” The kneel-ins sparked, in Haynes's judgment, “moral spectacles par excellence” when obstinate church officers and parishioners, bent on preserving their sanctuaries as racially exclusive religious spaces, blocked church doors, or forcefully removed interlopers from pews. In denying entry to worshippers, worshippers performed “spectacles of exclusion” by subsuming the proclamation of the gospel to regional custom (15). In this way, the author provides a compelling means for exploring the complicated ways in which Southern whites attempted to balance their religiosity with the time-honored, white Southern tradition of white supremacy, racial segregation, and exclusion.
After a regional survey of kneel-in activities, Haynes focuses his attention on a parish drama in the Second Presbyterian Church (SPC), which faced an acute dilemma after a group of student-worshipers, affiliated with the Non-Violent Committee of the Intercollegiate Chapter of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP), initiated a campaign of “church testings” across Memphis (55). Interracial groups of college students, many of whom were associated with Southwestern Presbyterian University, visited area churches and were met with general tolerance, that is, until African American activist Joe Purdy and his white colleague Jim Bullock sought entrée to SPC on March 22, 1964. Accurately sensing an attempt to undercut the racial sanctity of their church, church leaders stationed guards at the door to thwart groups of interracial worshippers. For 8 successive weeks, well-dressed students met a phalanx of churchmen stationed at the sanctuary entrance. Rebuffed, they held a series of vigils on the church steps that resounded through the local press.
The succession of kneel-ins exposed a rift in the Presbyterian Church between traditionalists and reformers and precipitated a debate about the role of the church's primary mission in society. Although traditionalists sensed the eroding theological foundations for segregation, they argued that segregation was instrumental in maintaining order in the region, and contended that the church should focus on “winning People to faith in Jesus Christ and nurturing them in the faith” and maintain the distinction between church and state (89). Reformers, on the other hand, argued that the church could not withstand the rising tide of civil rights and should revise its relationship with civil society and increasingly concern itself with social issues such as racial discrimination and segregation. The push for ecclesiastical integration also exposed a growing rift between the local church and the more liberal Presbyterian Church (PCUS), which was reconsidering the decision to allow the SPC to host the national meeting of the PCUS General Assembly later that year.
After much soul searching and great debate, the congregation voted in a new church leadership in February 1965 and ushered in an era in which blacks were welcomed in the church (even if the open invitation did not result in an influx of black congregants). In assessing the legacy of the activists' work and the broader transformation wrought by the civil rights movement, Haynes demonstrates how the congregational vote set the stage for the SPC to rethink its relationship with the broader community and provide much-needed social services to needy Memphis communities. The church also explored partnerships with area (especially African American) ministries, conducted global missionary work, and attempted to atone for its past positions and reconcile with aggrieved African Americans. The 1965 vote also provided the impetus for a secessionist movement and the creation of a less repentant and more conservative Independent Presbyterian Church (IPC).
One part social movement history, one part oral history, and one part institutional church history, this reviewer was hoping for a more artful interweaving of the narrative, context, and memories that structure the book. Still, The Last Segregated Hour is a most thoughtful consideration of an underexplored aspect of the Civil Rights Movement that prompted a great debate about race, rights, and responsibilities, and blurred the lines between the secular and sacred.
