The question presents itself often for feminist theorists living in Eastern Europe: how to deal with the politicization of domestic violence—and with many other forms of gender discrimination and inequality—in postcommunist societies where second-wave feminism was missing. By addressing the role of domestic and international actors in politicizing violence against women and thus achieving an important goal of second-wave feminism, this book represents an important answer.
The essays included in the volume, edited by Katalin Fábián, are written from many disciplinary perspectives: history, economics, politics, sociology, cultural anthropology, public policy, and gender analysis. An impressive bibliographic resource for scholars belonging to these fields, the essays are also highly relevant for political scientists. In my view, the book is an enlightening demonstration of the relevance of a particular policy area, in this case domestic violence (DV), to the difficulties of the transition in postcommunist states from an electoral, show-room democracy to a fully consolidated liberal democracy. The domestic political actors (governments, parliaments, and political parties) have proved that they have almost nothing to do with any initiative concerning women's rights qua women, apart from a demonstration of formal conformity to the demands of international actors. In Olga Avdeyeva's words: “[P]articipating in human rights treaties can serve as a socializing strategy for newly independent states waiting to demonstrate to others in the international community that they share the principles and norms embedded in international treaties” (p. 332). The only active actors that were playing a significant role in settling the necessary laws and institutions against domestic violence were local activists linked to nongovernmental organizations, the academic world, and other international actors such as the United Nations Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women, Amnesty International, the European Union, Minnesota Advocates for Human Rights, or the George Soros–funded Open Society Institutes.
As certain issues rose to the center of discussion in the new emergent democracies, other concepts and policies were unknown and even considered exotic, inadequate Western imports. As Janet Johnson and Gulmara Zaynullina clearly assess: “Only a decade ago, if Russians were asked about ‘domestic violence’ the overwhelming response would have been: ‘what do you mean?’” (p. 78). In a similar vein, Fábián could generalize about the taboo character of domestic violence as a public issue in communism. The only exception to this general rule was former Yugoslavia and its tradition of association (as Sonja Robnik describes in her essay on Slovenia).
The global feminist consensus and its international representatives interfered with the internal resistance and conservatism present in each state, but in different degrees. Although the authors do not analyze all of the former communist states, even the European ones (for example, Albania is not mentioned and Bulgaria, Macedonia, and Moldavia are treated only statistically), in their detailed focus on some of them they offer broader insights related to the main topic: how it was possible or impossible to make room for laws, institutions, and practices against domestic violence in the former communist states?
In the cases of Ukraine (see Alexandra Hrycak) and the candidate states under pressure of the aquis communitaire (see Celeste Montoya), the volume shows that if the agenda of the local state actors was to please the EU, the governments accepted certain laws. Even in the states that became EU members, such as Poland (analyzed by Thomas Chivens), the resistance was tough; in difficult economic situations it was considered hard to “spend public money on battered women” (p. 185). Other states, like Romania, Bulgaria, and Macedonia, adopted domestic violence laws without significant resistance, but they never allocated any budget to enforce those laws. What happened when the EU pressure to be accepted “in the club” was not present? As the authors make clear, navigating between a global feminist consensus and local contexts and concerns was and remains a constant challenge. Janet Elsie Johnson and Gulnara Zaynullina, studying Russia, notice the need for a reconceptualization of domestic violence to include economic violence (prohibition against finding a job, the deprivation of financial resources). As they observe, “[H]ard working women's salaries were regularly taken away by force for alcohol for their husbands, even food dedicated primarily to children was taken also,” even though “[w]omen are working extra and many times they are the only bread-winners” (p. 92).
The case of Kazakhstan offers impressive proof of the potential of grassroots movements, and Edward Snadjr describes how the emergence of a kitchen resistance among friends (podrugi) who formed a basement shelter was transformed into a public NGO called Podrugi, which helped to create many official shelters. Here, the government was an important supporter of NGOs' actions against domestic violence, but the Muslim women's organizations were not. As in other situations, the Eastern experience forces us to think about who are, in fact, women's rights allies—which varies greatly depending on the situation.
The most disturbing case of violence against women is Tajikistan (see the essay by Muborak Sharipova and Fábián), which had faced a civil war (1992–97) in which women were forced to submit to extensive sexual humiliation and violence from a broad range of “racketeers, militia, criminals and drivers” (p. 136). Factoring in the renaissance of fundamentalist Islam and the practice of “honor killing” and polygamous marriage, the reader can be left with a picture of extreme exposure to violence. Again, as in other cases, politicians in power were eager to please the international donors and became supporters of the legal provisions against domestic violence, even if this did not often translate into effective enforcement of these provisions.
The section on the influence of international organizations reveals many common experiences. The most frequent ones relate to the terminology used and the rejection of an explicit accent on women as victims of domestic violence. For most of the governments and political parties of postcommunist Europe, women are not interesting as specific victims. For Eastern European scholars this is not surprising (see, e.g., Vladimir Pasti, Ultima inegalitate, 2002). This is why the legal terminology used in those states that have submitted to international pressure is “violence in the family,” rather than “violence against women.” For NGOs active in this region, it is difficult even to openly recognize international donors, especially if they are women's rights networks, as the pieces by Laura Brunell and Janet Elsie Johnson and by Fábián make clear.
Under international pressure, the adoption of laws against domestic violence (irrespective of legal terminology) in many states, mostly EU new members, is an accomplished mission. But what are the consequences of such legal change for daily life? Numerous authors observe a “boomerang effect” after the passing of a law (p. 252), whereby the limited autonomy and professionalization of domestic violence, a focus on children and elderly people, and also a dependence on international donors became obstacles to real challenges to domestic violence against women. (Olga Avdeyeva offers a very concise synthesis of the lessons that can be learned from a comparative analysis of the 15 postcommunist states on pages 333–34.)
This book makes an important contribution to understanding the positive effects as well as the limits of globalization. Regarding these limits, Avderyeva's question starkly identifies the logic of self-interest that governs the interstate system: “If the cost of changing discriminatory practices is higher than the rewards for compliance, why would violating states pursue the changes?” (p. 324). Avderyeva maintains that such change makes sense if states are considered “not only [as] rational actors, but as social actors driven by the will for membership in a large group of states that they deem to be legitimate” (p. 325). But of course, as the volume makes clear, the tension between these logics is powerful.
Some of the contributors mention only in passing the weakness of community building and of collective action at the local level. This is one of the most frequent and compelling obstacles to the creation of a substantial democracy, and it deserves more profound analysis. Also deserving more attention is the instability of public servants and the politicization of administration as a cause of the merely formal character of political responses to domestic violence. Without substantial state financial support for crisis centers and law enforcement, and without a professional bureaucracy free of nepotism, “old boys' networks,” and other forms of corruption, laws against domestic violence, and the rights of women more generally, will remain mere pieces of paper in the international showroom of democracy and human rights.
