For Performing Animality: Animals in Performance Practices, editors Lourdes Orozco and Jennifer Parker-Starbuck gather essays by many of the most prominent scholars working at the intersection of performance studies and animal studies while also including welcome newer voices. The essays, all written specifically for this collection, highlight the vital participation of nonhuman animal species in human performance practices as well as the impact of this shared participation on human–animal relations. Orozco and Parker-Starbuck nicely articulate the material and ethical concerns that organize and unify the volume: “what is the animal actually doing in performance?” and “what is the animal even doing in performance?” (6).
Following the editors’ introduction, Part I comprises a single essay by Laura Cull, who lays out central issues at stake in the discourse surrounding animal performance. After tracing some early attempts within performance studies to accommodate animal participation within human-centered conceptual schemes, Cull's essay “From Homo Performans to Interspecies Collaboration” argues for expanding not only the definition of performance but also research methodologies. She proposes investigating “performance as a lived, embodied process of coming into contact with the ways in which animals are differently conscious from themselves and one another, regardless of whether or not it culminates in the production of ‘performances’ for a human audience,” and suggests that “practitioners’ insights into the animals they work with or alongside might produce a counter-knowledge to the dominant scientific accounts of animal life” (25). Brief case studies indicate the exciting potential of this approach, ranging from the practices that Lisa Jevbratt assigns in a course on interspecies art to clarinetist David Rothenberg's music making with birds and whales and Sami Sälpäkivi's Contact Improvisation with horses.
Each essay in Part II situates performance by living animals within a specific cultural context. Garry Marvin's ethnography of Spanish bullfighting, “The Art of Fierceness,” elaborates the ways in which humans who engage with bullfighting culture—whether as participants or spectators—celebrate the animal participant's culturally created bravura. I applaud the editors for including work on subject matter that is likely to be both ethically and emotionally challenging for many readers. In “‘Genus Porcus Sophisticus,’” Monica Mattfeld analyzes the refusal of star acrobats and dancers to perform at Sadler's Wells in 1785 because the manager had also engaged a learned pig, threatening their sense of human superiority. Given this London theatrical conflict's resonance with the eighteenth-century construction of national identity and anxieties surrounding challenges to categories and hierarchy, the essay will interest scholars of the historical period regardless of their engagement with animals. Catherine Young's intensively researched “‘A Very Good Act for an Unimportant Place’: Animals, Ambivalence and Abuse in Big-Time Vaudeville” holds similar interest for theatre and cultural historians. Examining the ambivalence of audiences as well as management with respect to animal acts, Young argues that “an ‘anti-cruelty’ stance in vaudeville was more of an aesthetic than an ethic” (92). Peta Tait turns to eighteenth- and nineteenth-century equine performance for “Acrobatic Circus Horses,” focusing on Philip Astley's training methods and Andrew Ducrow's spectacular rides strapped to the back of a seemingly wild horse. Tait analyzes their performance of “emotive animality” and its paradoxical foundation in “military discipline and emotional impassiveness” (98).
Tait's essay pairs very well with Kim Marra's “Massive Bodies in Mortal Performance.” Linking Astley's equine spectaculars to the contemporary puppet spectacular War Horse, this opening of Part III provides a smooth transition into analyzing performances that represent animals by means other than their living presence. Una Chaudhuri also includes an appreciation of War Horse in “Embattled Animals in a Theatre of Species,” arguing that its puppet horses and the eponymous tiger played by a human actor in Bengal Tiger in the Baghdad Zoo break away from anthropomorphic traditions to take animals seriously and imagine their views of this violent world. The essay's coda touches upon a graphic novel and a memoir to underline the possibilities available for what Chaudhuri terms a theatre of species. Parker-Starbuck brings us back to the animal's body, but a body no longer alive; her essay “Animal Pasts and Presents” examines humans’ relation to time and memory as taxidermied animals’ mortal remains perform within museum displays, in an experimental film from the 1960s, in a novel set in a taxidermy shop, and then finally in live performances with dead animals—frozen rats in Sheila Ghelani's Rat, Rose, Bird and taxidermied fox heads in Franko B's Because of Love, Volume 1. Carrie Rohman's “Effacing the Human” closes this section, touching upon Rachel Rosenthal's performance work but focusing on the profound blurring of species boundaries in her less-studied illustrations for Tatti Wattles: A Love Story. Rohman suggests that these drawings perform the book's subtext, positioning animality as a central feature of Rosenthal's prodigious creativity.
The volume closes by considering in Part IV the ways humans might best look at animals performing in theatres and in our daily lives. Orozco's “There and Not There” examines the visual appeal of animals onstage in work by Zingaro, the popular equestrian theatre, as well as Socìetas Raffaello Sanzio and Rodrigo García. In “It's Hard to Spot the Queerness in this Image,” Holly Hughes writes about how her loving relationship with dogs, which includes agility competition and dog shows as well as more quotidian reciprocity, has transformed both her mundane life and her solo performance work.
This timely collection provides essential reading for scholars in animal studies as well as in theatre and performance studies, and would work well for a course at the disciplinary intersection of the two, with many of the individual essays or sections also being relevant to other instructional contexts.
