Ch. 1 one claims that contrary to philosophical teachings the elegiac lover cannot escape love, but embraces it, gaining relief by writing about it or fantasizing about a happier life. Ch. 2 handles poets' criticisms of excessive jealousy (in women), of the failure to suppress it, and of the neglect to show it (by husbands). In ch. 3 what is seen and heard most often arouses jealousy, and females are slow to put things together and believe there has been infidelity, while the expert and naturally suspicious male is a ready believer. In ch. 4 jealous women consistently resort to violence, whereas the jealous poet tries to restrict himself to verbal abuse (a refined and morally superior reaction). Ch. 5 concerns readers — internal (Propertius is actually sympathetic in his addresses to rivals who are love poets) and external (we are given a better understanding of jealousy and question jealous elegists' credibility). In ch. 6 Propertius is said to connect the loss of fides in love with its absence in other (public) spheres too in a degenerate Rome.
Jealousy represents a stimulating new direction for criticism of elegy, and Caston handles some important issues in a wide-ranging discussion. She provides a useful examination of the triggers of jealousy (77ff.) and its manifestations (49ff.). She is sound on the concept of fides and on contrasting approaches to love in philosophy and elegy (underlining the significance of the former for appreciation of the latter). She is also au fait with relevant scholarship, and her inclusion of the views of modern psychologists and philosophers on jealousy makes for a welcome extra dimension.
However, in general C.'s treatment lacks rigour. I was interested by her allusions to jealousy in post-Classical writers like Proust and Robbe-Grillet, but her field for analysis in Roman elegy itself is too narrow. She omits some instances of jealousy in Tibullus, Propertius and Ovid (e.g. Tibullus 2.6.51ff.), and she largely ignores the Corpus Tibullianum (including 3.4 and 3.6) and Catullus 68 and 76. In her discussion there is a bias towards Propertius, and she tends to lump all the elegists together, not allowing for their differences, and failing to pick out one who does not fit her argument (for example, Ovid in connection with the two therapeutic courses in ch. 1). The presence of translation of the Latin is a good idea, but there are several errors in her versions (e.g. on pp. 28, 101, 103, 104 and 118), and quite frequently a word in a line is not rendered. Sometimes, in her serious pursuit of her topic, C. is not fully attuned to the humour of the poetry (for example, in the case of Amores 2.7 and 2.8 and A.A. 2.169ff.). Sometimes she stretches things a bit (as when on p. 72 she claims that stultus was Stoic terminology and was adapted as such by the elegists) or comes out with notions that seem fanciful (on p. 55 Propertius in 1.3 supposedly sees himself and his rival (in Cynthia's dream) as alike, almost as if he were the rival, and so puts across the idea of stealing Cynthia from himself; and on p. 88 the mistress is said to stand for elegy and so her infidelity is a sign of the poetry's success). There are too many contentious assertions made without support (for instance, that Marathus is having an affair with the wife of the rival in Tibullus 1.9 as well as with the rival himself). When support is offered, it is not always strong. There is a general absence of facts and figures, and often C. does not cite enough examples to back up her case. So at pp. 79ff. she bases her claim that elegiac females are slow to give way to jealousy on just three examples, and they are two heroines and a wife (in Heroides 5 and 6 and Propertius 4.3). But Oenone after seeing Paris with Helen in one couplet assumes that she is his mistress in the next (5.68–70); and Propertius' Arethusa is so far from scepticism as to indulge in jealous fantasy without any grounds; and one can immediately think of three cases in which (much more pertinent) elegiac mistresses are readily jealous (Propertius 1.3, 3.15 and Amores 2.7).
Despite these reservations, C. has highlighted the importance of jealousy in elegy, has raised many interesting and pertinent questions in connection with it, and has made a useful start in analysis of it.
