In the last two years, the Darfur region in western Sudan has moved from relative international obscurity to become a symbol of humanitarian crisis and mass violence. Political scientists who research genocide, ethnic conflict, civil war, humanitarianism, and African politics all have taken interest in the region, and Darfur is likely to command scholarly attention in years to come. Yet the academic literature on the region remains thin. To date, scholars have relied primarily on journalistic accounts and human rights reports, which detail the violence but, by their nature, provide only cursory historical background. With the publication of these two short but informative books, Darfur's political history and the path to mass violence are substantially clearer. That said, the books are not designed to build theories of ethnic violence or genocide, nor do the authors explicitly engage in hypotheses testing. The books are useful primarily as detailed, lucid case histories from two sets of well-informed observers.
On the whole, the two books tell a similar story about the origins of the conflict. That story, however, is a complex one, with interlocking local, national, and regional factors. Both books stress a history of political manipulation of ethnicity by local and national actors; both highlight a central dimension of competition for scarce resources, recently exacerbated by drought and desertification; both trace how the government funded and supported local militias, who in turn unleashed large-scale violence; both posit a connection between the war in Darfur and the decades-long but recently ended war between Northerners and Southerners in Sudan; and both attribute a critical role to regional factors, in particular the involvement of Chad and Libya. Whether the recent violence in Darfur should be called “genocide”—a focal point of public discussion—is not central in either book.
The major differences concern style and emphasis. Darfur: The Ambiguous Genocide is written by Gérard Prunier, a French researcher on African politics who wrote an influential book on the Rwandan genocide a decade ago. Darfur: A Short History of a Long War is a collaboration by Julie Flint and Alex de Waal. Flint is a journalist and researcher for Human Rights Watch; de Waal is a long-standing analyst of Sudanese politics, and he wrote one of the few English-language books on the Darfur region before the latest crisis (Famine That Kills, rev. ed. 2004). Prunier takes more opinionated license in his prose than do Flint and de Waal, and, given Prunier's prior research on Rwanda, that conflict serves as an occasional reference point. Flint and de Waal explicitly seek to narrate Darfur's history on its own terms (rather than in reference to Rwanda or the North–South war in Sudan), and their account is especially strong on the local dynamics of the conflict. They provide a wealth of information about Darfuri politics and history, including biographical accounts of rebel and militia leaders, as well as nuanced discussions of political lineages and movements in the region. Prunier focuses more on the national and international dimensions of the conflict.
Roughly the size of Texas, Darfur is home to some six million people and as many as 90 different ethnic subgroups, according to Flint and de Waal. The region's political history is distinct from the rest of Sudan. An independent sultanate, Darfur was incorporated into colonial Sudan in the 1910s, later than the rest of the country. Both authors describe how Darfur was largely neglected under colonialism. Flint and de Waal claim that Darfur was a “backwater” (p. 16). The marginalization of Darfur continued into the postcolonial era, and indeed a near century of neglect vis-à-vis Sudan's center is a running theme in both books. Darfur's demography is also distinct from much of the rest of Sudan. While Sudan is characterized by crosscutting cleavages between North and South, Arab and black, and Christian and Muslim, Darfur's population is Muslim. That said, there is an important cleavage between Arabs and Africans in the region, and that cleavage shapes the contours of the recent violence.
Conflict between Arabs and Africans in Darfur became especially pronounced in the 1980s. A series of intense droughts in the region intensified competition for water and arable land, leading to violence. Civil war in neighboring Chad also was significant. To unseat the Chadian government in the 1980s, Libyan leader Muammer Gaddafi funded and supplied Chadian rebels, whose base was located inside of Darfur. Gaddafi's involvement prompted an influx of weaponry to Darfur, but, as Flint and de Waal recount, Libya's entanglement also led to the promulgation of Arab supremacist ideology in the region. The authors focus attention on the “Arab Gathering,” a group that promoted Arab domination. Another source of conflict in Darfur was the North–South war in Sudan. To combat southern rebels, who at one point sought to make incursions into Darfur, government leaders backed Darfuri Arabs. The net effect of these various factors was to harden Arab and African identities in the region and to intensify tension between the two groups. Prunier claims that since the mid-1980s, “Darfur had been a time-bomb waiting for a fuse” (p. 86).
A major change came in 2002 and 2003 when Africans in Darfur launched a rebellion, seeking an end to Arab favoritism. Initially, government forces did not take the rebels seriously. But as Flint and de Waal recount in detail, the rebels won a string of military victories, prompting a hard-line response from the government, whose officials were worried, in part, about what successful armed resistance in Darfur would signal to other restive groups in Sudan. According to all the authors, the government's strategy became to crush the rebellion by arming militias and supporting them with military, in particular air, power. Militias and soldiers in turn launched waves of attacks on African civilians. Prunier (citing an article by de Waal) calls this “counterinsurgency on the cheap” (p. 99). The outcome was devastating: Joint militia and military forces destroyed villages, killed, raped, and looted. Flint and de Waal quote a document from a Darfuri militia leader claiming that the purpose of the violence was to “change the demography of Darfur and empty it of African tribes” (p. 39). Both books provide considerable detail about the violence, which ultimately led to the displacement of more than two million civilians and the deaths of several hundred thousand.
Is the violence “genocide”? That question was a focus of debate in the United States and ultimately led Congress, Colin Powell, and President George W. Bush to declare that genocide was happening. Prunier claims that Darfur is an “ambiguous” case of genocide. Under the United Nations Genocide Convention, it would be, he argues. Under his definition, which sees genocide as destruction of a group in its entirety (rather than in substantial part), Darfur would not be genocide. Prunier is skeptical of the genocide debate, claiming that it is motivated by the media's need for a “big story” (p. 156) and labels. His assertion goes too far: Because of the UN Genocide Convention, a genocide designation is significant. He also provides little evidence to support his claim that Powell “had practically been ordered” (p. 140) to use the term. Rather, Powell had commissioned a comprehensive and innovative study from an independent organization so that he could make a determination, and he studied those results before reaching a conclusion.
Prunier criticizes the American administration for being “confused” on Darfur, but his criticism is not limited to the Americans. He excoriates European Union leaders for “complete lack of resolve and coordination,” the British for “blindly” following Washington, and the French for being concerned only with Chad (p. 140). UN leaders also come in for criticism. As for the African Union, which deployed troops but only with a weak mandate, Prunier argues that Darfur was its first major crisis but one that was a “mission impossible” (p. 145), given the limited number of troops and their restrictions. Flint and de Waal have a similar assessment of the African Union. As for other international actors, they fault Western leaders for not backing up strong words with strong actions. The authors also highlight how China and Russia, which are allies of Sudan, were obstacles to sanctions and other measures at the United Nations.
Both books include damning commentaries on Sudan's national leaders. Flint and de Waal compare them to a “cancer” (p. 129), fault their “withered” humanity (p. 129), and assert that there are “serial war criminals at the heart of Sudan's present government” (p. 134). Prunier finds that Sudan's policy “has kept verging on genocide” (p. 105) since the current leadership came to power in 1989. These are not value-neutral claims, but nor are the events described in these pages. However readers respond to the characterizations, the books are excellent introductions to a conflict that will continue to interest policymakers, students, and scholars working in a variety of political science subfields.
