This is the most important book on middle-period Chinese history to have been published in the past decade, for both the impact of its findings and the innovativeness of its methodology. In The Destruction of the Medieval Chinese Aristocracy, Nicolas Tackett has put Tang-dynasty history back on the map, using new digital tools to solve a problem in social history that has been neglected in Western-language scholarship since the late 1970s. In the intervening years, Song specialists have exhaustively documented the emergence of the scholar-official elite in the eleventh century, as a product of the expansion of civil service examinations, yet the scale and timing of the Tang aristocracy's decline remains a matter of controversy.
Until now. One of the many virtues of this book is Tackett's reconceptualization of this social transformation as a short, sharp shock, “a single socioeconomic trajectory whereby the great clans of the Tang were displaced by a new elite,” rather than a gradual transition, as was previously assumed (p. 9). Twentieth-century scholars like Denis Twitchett and Tonami Mamoru had posited that the Tang aristocracy began its downward slide in the mid-eighth century. It was generally assumed that after the An Lushan Rebellion (755–63), as the central government's fiscal and regulatory authority was dispersed out to provincial governors and bureaucracies, these new institutions were colonized by a newly risen bureaucratic elite that crowded out the old aristocratic clans.
Overturning collective wisdom, Tackett persuasively affirms that these great families evinced astonishing persistence and adaptability, continuing to dominate the central administration of the Tang Empire well into the late ninth century. Tackett demonstrates that two networks of elite families, based in the capitals of Chang'an and Luoyang and their connecting corridor, monopolized positions within the central government and provincial commissions until the 880s. Through rigorous quantitative analysis, he buttresses recent revisionist Chinese scholarship, showing how twentieth-century Japanese and Western scholars' “portrayals of near total disintegration of central authority in the post-An Lushan period are greatly exaggerated” (p. 116). To the contrary, Tackett asserts that under Emperors Dezong (r. 779–805) and Xianzong (r. 805–20), the imperial bureaucracy reasserted firm administrative and fiscal control over once-autonomous provinces, which were “essentially no more antagonistic to central rule than were the provinces of later dynasties” (p. 158). So self-replicating was the Tang aristocracy that it took an extinction-level event to break their monopoly on political power and social status. The Huang Chao Rebellion of the early 880s was a horrifically destructive moment of punctuated equilibrium, which, Tackett affirms, “physically eliminated a large percentage of the political elite” from the capital region, and “brought about their near immediate demise” (pp. 25–26).
Equally significant, this book validates the potential of digital techniques to revolutionize the kinds of questions that Chinese historians will be able to ask and answer. Surpassing earlier Tang specialists, who were working from a limited corpus of published texts, Tackett mines a broad tranche of data from thousands of recently discovered tomb inscriptions. Geographically scattered across the Tang Empire, these epigraphic sources provide a deeper and more representative cross-section of elite society, from powerful bureaucrats at the capital down to less-wealthy provincial landowners. Breaking with Chinese scholars who performed stratigraphic analyses of the Tang aristocracy, with varying sets of categories and terminologies, Tackett's working definition of an aristocrat is simple: someone whose family commissioned a tomb inscription for them. While aristocrats still relied on choronyms (e.g., “the Qinghe Cuis”) to associate themselves with their distant ancestors' pre-Tang native places, their burial places had been dispersed to other locations across the empire by the mid-Tang. Members of this “bureaucratic aristocracy” drew their status from “descent from officeholders” rather than from owning estates, as a landed aristocracy would have done (p. 68). Overwhelmingly concentrated in the capital corridor with almost no provincial-level footprint, the Tang political elite formed two marriage networks, one centered upon the imperial clan, and the other by branches of eminent clans banned from marrying the imperial clan. To single out just one masterful piece of data visualization (even within the limitations of black-and-white printing), Tackett uses a social network diagram (figure 3.6, p. 123) to illuminate the affinal connections of these two cliques, demonstrating how geographic proximity reinforced this entrenched bureaucratic aristocracy for many generations. Better yet, unlike past large-scale quantification projects, Tackett's data analysis is fully transparent to readers, who can download his open-source databases and run their own queries.
So successful is the quantitative analysis in the book's first four chapters that when Tackett employs more conventional sinological sources and methods in the fifth and final chapter, they seem impressionistic and anecdotal, if only by comparison with what preceded them. After stitching together citations from the Zizhi tongjian and poetic lamentations about the devastating consequences of the Huang Chao Rebellion, he ultimately acknowledges that a full analysis “of the fragmentation of the old capital social network is beyond the scope of the present study” (p. 233). I hope that Tackett's projected follow-up book, on the transformation of the cultural orientations of the Chinese elite from aristocracy to bureaucracy, from Tang to Song, will be just as grounded in big data, and just as visually elegant and precisely argued as his first.
