The story of Cuba's maquinistas is in many ways the story of migrant workers the world over. Drawn to Cuba to work primarily in the expanding sugar industry, they arrived to find a society in the midst of vast economic, political and social transformations. The expansion of steam technology in the late eighteenth century and early nineteenth century meant that Cubans were especially eager to capitalise on the skilled labour that the migrants could offer in the production of sugar as well as in other industries. It did not, however, mean that maquinistas were readily accepted or integrated into the larger milieu, or that they even held any desire to integrate into Cuban society. Instead, the lives of maquinistas reveal the polarising debates over slavery, sugar and independence that were taking place in Cuba, as well as the larger, global struggles and political processes shaping the mid-nineteenth-century island.
The ‘maquinista’ title given to the skilled workers described men employed in various aspects of the engineering trade, from ‘locomotive drivers and simple machine operators, to highly skilled engineers engaged in design and construction’ (p. xii). Many of them hailed from the industrial centres of the United States and Europe and brought with them more than just the skills acquired in distant and not-so-distant places. They brought with them political views that radically altered their new society, relationships forged through old-world connections, and even the machines necessary for technological expansion on the island. Despite Jonathan Curry-Machado's emphasis on the lives of the maquinistas, however, the title of his book reveals that sugar production and the processes it engendered are the central focus of the study. Changing economies in Cuba and abroad, affected by technological change, created many of the transnational networks that brought maquinistas to Cuba. It is precisely through the relationships that emerged between engineering workers and colonial officials, sugar planters, slaves and technology that the author explores an industry of singular importance. This approach to the study of the Cuban sugar industry led Curry-Machado to seek out archival sources in Madrid, London, Glasgow, Matanzas, Havana and Cienfuegos, to name but a few of the places listed in his bibliography, and his narrative has left no angle of the mid-nineteenth-century relationships surrounding maquinistas unanalysed. The book moves seamlessly from global history to a history of technology and into a discussion that contextualises the economic and social dimensions of sugar production in Cuba. The author then invites a dialogue with cultural studies scholars and labour historians through his analyses of the relationships that maquinistas forged with Cubans (or conversely, the relationships that they did not seek out). Selected chapters in the latter half of the book are dedicated to a discussion of identity production and its purposes, and reveal the potential array of relationships available to foreign maquinistas.
Jonathan Curry-Machado's study reveals that the relationships and networks in which maquinistas chose to participate are central to understanding the nuances of the society emerging by the middle of the nineteenth century. Engineering workers in Cuba, for example, often worked alongside slaves, sharing aspects of the trade with them, even as they rebuffed criollo efforts to learn the skills necessary to acquire the title of maquinista. Because of the abolitionist sentiments that engineering workers often arrived with, they were frequently (and wrongly, according to Curry-Machado) implicated in the nationalist and anti-slavery conflicts of the period. Their failure to develop the solidarities necessary to integrate into Cuban society might have been, as the author notes, the result of repeated and multiple migrations and their adoption of a transnational identity that further excluded them from their new society. Adding yet another layer to this argument, Curry-Machado contends that the early migrants arrived in Cuba not just with a predisposition towards abolition, but also with an acute awareness of the similarities between their own plight as ‘wage slaves’ (in their home countries) and the plight of enslaved Africans, something that would certainly and immediately have set them apart from larger Cuban society. He attributes this early ‘racial solidarity’ to the working-class origins of maquinistas and the ambiguity of their own racial identity in their countries of origin (p. 111). While the relationship between race and class in Europe, and more specifically working-class exclusion from discourses of whiteness, should be duly noted in migrants’ construction of self, to say that maquinistas could have been reasonably expected to forge relationships with slaves and free coloured workers on the basis of a shared class identity is, I believe, radically to underestimate the power of whiteness in the nineteenth century. To be sure, as Curry-Machado notes, the fact that maquinistas were collectively viewed as both ‘foreign’ and ‘white’ by Cubans must have played a decisive role in very quickly convincing the foreign workers to adopt hegemonic ideas on race. But their skilled and coveted occupations would have set them apart from ‘other’, unskilled migrants arriving in Cuba, and certainly from those arriving in bondage. Still, Curry-Machado's discussion invites much-needed dialogue and debate on the multiplicity of factors, both internal and external, and the extent to which they shaped individual identities and social relations in Cuba.
This study succeeds in positioning maquinistas within the ‘interstices’ of global and transnational networks (p. 195). It illustrates that mid-nineteenth-century Cuba existed not in isolation but rather within a complicated network of relationships that had important repercussions within the island. He convincingly portrays the influence of the maquinistas as ‘catalytic’ for Cuban society (p. 197). Their lives reveal just as much about Cuban politics, the expansion of technology and the demise of slavery on the island as they do about the insular workshops in which they laboured.
