Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T10:49:45.460Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Estimating lift from wake velocity data in flapping flight

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  15 April 2019

Shizhao Wang
Affiliation:
LNM, Institute of Mechanics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, ChinaSchool of Engineering Sciences, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China
Guowei He
Affiliation:
LNM, Institute of Mechanics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, ChinaSchool of Engineering Sciences, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, China
Tianshu Liu*
Affiliation:
LNM, Institute of Mechanics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, ChinaMechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Western Michigan University, Kalamazoo, MI 49008, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: tianshu.liu@wmich.edu

Abstract

The application of the Kutta–Joukowski (KJ) theorem to estimating the lift of a flying animal based on wake velocity fields often leads to significant underprediction of the lift, which is known as the wake momentum paradox. This work attempts to answer the puzzling question on whether the KJ theorem is legitimate in its use for complex viscous unsteady wakes generated by flapping wings. The limitations in applying the KJ theorem to flapping wings are quantitatively examined through numerical simulations of viscous incompressible flows over three flapping wing models. The three flapping wing models studied in this work are a flapping wing with a fixed wingspan, a flapping wing with a dynamically changing wingspan and a dihedral flapping wing. The KJ theorem fails to give a satisfactory prediction of the time-averaged lift unless an effective span length is correctly computed. We propose a wake-sectional Kutta–Joukowski (WS-KJ) model to predict the time-averaged lift, where the effective span length is computed based on the time-averaged distance between the streamwise vorticity centroids in the right and left half sides of the Trefftz plane. The WS-KJ model incorporates the spatial evolutionary effects of the complex vortex structures in the wake and significantly improves the prediction of the time-averaged lift. The physical foundation for such improvement is explored. In addition, the time-dependent amplitude and phase changes of the unsteady lift are discussed as the fluid acceleration effect.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© 2019 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematics of the coordinate system and the integral domains in the Trefftz planes: (a) the flapping rectangular wing in a uniform upstream flow; (b) side view of the wake structures coloured by the spanwise vorticity from $-2$ (blue) to 2 (red); (c) streamwise vorticity fields in the Trefftz plane at $x/c=3.0$; and (d) streamwise vorticity fields in the Trefftz plane at $x/c=15.0$.

Figure 1

Figure 2.The time-dependent lift coefficients predicted by using the KJ theorem in different Trefftz planes for the flapping wing with a fixed wingspan. The wingspan is taken as the effective span length in computing the KJ lift.

Figure 2

Figure 3.(a) Time-averaged lift coefficients predicted by using the KJ theorem with different effective span lengths; (b) time-averaged circulation and moment of the vorticity in different Trefftz planes; and (c) time-averaged wake widths computed by different methods for a flapping rectangular wing with a fixed wingspan.

Figure 3

Figure 4.(a) The decomposition of the lift coefficient by using the (2.7); and (b) the KJ lift, added-mass lift and their comparisons with the decomposed lift for the flapping rectangular wing with a fixed wingspan.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Wake structures of the flapping rectangular wing with a fixed wingspan: (a) perspective view with $Q=0.5$, coloured by the normalized spanwise vorticity from $-10$ (blue) to 10 (red); and (b) top view with $Q=0.02$, coloured by the normalized spanwise vorticity from $-1$ (blue) to 1 (red).

Figure 5

Figure 6.Time-averaged vortex deformation parameter for the flapping rectangular wing with a fixed wingspan.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Flow structures and wake width of the flapping rectangular wing with a fixed wingspan: (a) top view of the isosurfaces of $Q=0.2$, coloured by the normalized spanwise vorticity from $-1$ (blue) to 1 (red); (b) the DPV in 31 different Trefftz planes; and (c–f) streamwise vorticity fields at $x/c=3.5$, $x/c=4.5$, $x/c=6.0$ and $x/c=14.0$, respectively.

Figure 7

Figure 8.The induced motion of vortices in the wake at different streamwise positions, where the (purple) solid arrows show the direction of induced motion: (a) the mutually induced motion caused by the tip vortices, $x/c=1.65$; (b) the self-induced motion caused by the deformation of vortex ring, $x/c=2.75$; (c) the combination of the mutually and self-induced motions, $x/c=4.0$; and (d) the positions of the slices interacting with the vortex structures at $x/c=1.65$, 2.75 and 4.0, respectively.

Figure 8

Figure 9.The time-dependent lift coefficients predicted by using the KJ theorem in different Trefftz planes for the flapping wing with a dynamically changing wingspan. The wingspan is taken as the effective span length in computing the KJ lift.

Figure 9

Figure 10.(a) Time-averaged lift coefficients based on the KJ theorem with different effective span lengths; (b) time-averaged circulation and moment of the vorticity in different Trefftz planes; and (c) time-averaged wake width computed by different methods for the flapping wing with a dynamically changing wingspan.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Time-averaged vortex deformation parameter computed by different methods for the flapping rectangular wing with a dynamically changing wingspan.

Figure 11

Figure 12.(a) The decomposition of the lift coefficient by using (2.7); and (b) the KJ lift, added-mass lift and their comparisons with the decomposed lift in the flow over the flapping rectangular wing with a dynamically changing wingspan.

Figure 12

Figure 13.Wake structures of the flapping rectangular wing with a dynamically changing wingspan at the middle of the upstroke: (a) top view and (b) side view. The vortex structures are identified by using the isosurfaces of $Q=0.2$ and coloured by the normalized spanwise vorticity from $-5$ (blue) to 5 (red).

Figure 13

Figure 14.Flow structures and wake width of the flapping rectangular wing with a dynamically changing wingspan at the middle of the downstroke: (a) top view of the isosurfaces of $Q=0.2$ coloured by the streamwise vorticity from $-1$ (blue) to 1 (red); (b) the DPV in 31 different Trefftz planes; and (c–f) streamwise vorticity fields at $x/c=2.0$, $x/c=5.0$, $x/c=6.5$ and $x/c=14.0$, respectively.

Figure 14

Figure 15.Schematic of the dihedral flapping wing.

Figure 15

Figure 16.The time-dependent lift coefficients predicted by using the KJ theorem in different Trefftz planes for the dihedral flapping wing. The maximum wingspan is taken as the effective span length in computing the KJ lift.

Figure 16

Figure 17.(a) The decomposition of the lift coefficients by using (2.7); and (b) the KJ lift at different Trefftz planes and their comparisons with the vortex lift in the flow over the dihedral flapping wing.

Figure 17

Figure 18.(a) Time-averaged lift coefficient based on the KJ theorem with different effective span lengths; (b) time-averaged circulation and moment of the vorticity in different Trefftz planes; and (c) time-averaged wake width computed by different methods for the dihedral flapping wing.

Figure 18

Figure 19.Time-averaged vortex deformation parameter for the dihedral flapping wing.

Figure 19

Figure 20.Typical vortex structures generated by the dihedral flapping wing at the middle of the downstroke: (a) top view and (b) side view, where the isosurfaces of $Q=1.0$ are shown. The colour shows the spanwise vorticity from $-5$ (blue) to 5 (red).

Figure 20

Figure 21.Flow structures and wake width of the dihedral flapping wing: (a) top view of the isosurfaces of $Q=0.2$ coloured by the streamwise vorticity from $-1$ (blue) to 1 (red); (b) the DPV in 31 different Trefftz planes; and (c–f) streamwise vorticity fields at $x/c=2.0$, $x/c=6.0$, $x/c=8.5$ and $x/c=14.0$, respectively.

Figure 21

Figure 22.Schematic of the integral domain for the vortex force.

Figure 22

Figure 23.Contributions from (A 6) to (A 10), denoted by $L1$ and $L2$, respectively, for the flapping rectangular wing with a fixed wingspan in different Trefftz planes: (a–c) time-dependent lift at $x/c=3.0$, $x/c=5.0$ and $x/c=10.0$, respectively; and (d) time-averaged lift. The $L1$ and $L2$ are normalized by $\unicode[STIX]{x1D70C}U^{2}c^{2}$.

Figure 23

Figure 24.The computational domain with local mesh refinement: (a) boundaries of the six levels of refinement, top view; and (b) unstructured Cartesian mesh with hanging node, top view.

Figure 24

Figure 25.The time-dependent lift coefficients computed on different meshes in the case of the flapping wing with a fixed wingspan.

Figure 25

Figure 26.Typical wake structures of the flapping rectangular wing with a dynamically changing wingspan at three Strouhal numbers, (a) $St=0.3$, (b) $St=0.6$ and (c) $St=0.9$. The left and right columns show top and side views, respectively. The isosurfaces of $Q=0.2$ are shown. The colour shows the normalized spanwise vorticity from $-1$ (blue) to 1 (red).

Figure 26

Table 1.Boundaries and grid size of each level of refinement, normalized by using the chord length of the wing, $c$.

Figure 27

Figure 27.The time-averaged lift coefficients at three Strouhal numbers, (a) $St=0.3$, (b) $St=0.6$ and (c) $St=0.9$ based on simulations over 10 flapping periods, and (d) $St=0.9$ based on simulation simulations over 18 flapping periods.

Figure 28

Figure 28.The time-averaged lift coefficients estimated by using different models with different (a) Strouhal numbers, (b) time-averaged aspect ratios, (c) flapping amplitudes and (d) mean angles of attack. The solid symbols show the values estimated at three different Trefftz planes at $x/c=1.0$, $x/c=1.5$ and $x/c=2.0$.

Figure 29

Figure 29.The time-averaged vorticity-weighted wake width (VWW) as a function of the time-averaged circulation for the flapping wing with a dynamically changing wingspan at different parameters: (a) Strouhal numbers, (b) time-averaged aspect ratios, (c) flapping amplitudes, and (d) time-averaged angles of attack.

Figure 30

Table 2.Dimensionless parameters of the flapping wing with a dynamically changing wingspan.