Declining interest in Japanese politics and the lack of novelty in this field of academia has caused scholarship on Japanese democracy to be somewhat dormant over the past few years. Students in the field have had to refer to a handful of decades-old literature to discuss, or sometimes even, simply assume certain characteristics about Japanese democracy, qualities often involving stereotypical terms such as ‘illiberal’, ‘undemocratic’, ‘pseudo’, ‘dysfunctional’, or ‘incomplete’ (pp. 8, 182). Mary Alice Haddad's recent book, Building Democracy in Japan, thus comes as a long-awaited, welcome piece. In this empirically rich and theoretically challenging work, Haddad tells us attention-grabbing stories about the Japanese people and civil society organizations that have contributed towards Japan's greater democratization along with the gradual changes in generations and social environment.
Haddad posits that Japan's democracy was not simply inherited from or imposed on Japan by the West, but that it was made ‘real’ through long interaction between the state and society. Japan's citizenry contributed towards this gradual transformation through changes in traditional values, institutions, and practices into more liberal democratic alternatives. The contemporary Japanese democracy, the author argues, is an ‘amalgamation of the indigenous political culture as well as Western-influenced democracy . . . designed to address contemporary social and political challenges’ (p. 13). The indigenous political system was transformed by the introduction of liberal democratic values to address new problems, which resulted in a new set of institutions that would disseminate these values through society. New generations of citizens infused with the liberal democratic values modified the traditional value system while developing pro-democratic practices, progressively leading to democratic transformation of institutions and practices. ‘Japanese democracy is real’, Haddad notes, because it ‘has grown and is growing from Japanese society and reflects Japanese culture’ to become ‘fully democratic’ and ‘fully Japanese’ (p. 27). As the author builds on the approach that sees democratization as a ‘collective response to immediate political problems’, this book relies on in-depth narratives on government institutions, civil society organizations, political elites, and rank-and-file citizens, who all have been ‘building democracy in Japan’ together by continuously adjusting their traditional value systems, creating new institutions, and developing democratic practices.
Rejecting a ‘uniform’ or ‘static’ concept of democracy, this book asserts that the ‘local manifestations of that concept are specific to time and place and are dynamic’ (p. 4), which is the gist of its theoretical manifestation. For this, the author takes on a ‘process-oriented approach’, building on Migdal's state-in-society framework, defining democracy as a long process that ‘involves the mutual transformation of state and societal institutions, values, and practices’ (p. 11). With over 200 interviews of politicians, bureaucrats, civil society group activists and members, and a meticulous description of the organizational history of the government and civil society groups, Haddad depicts a dynamic picture of democratization in Japanese politics and society. Considering that current literature on Japanese democracy is mostly dominated by either institutional or cultural-historical approaches, there is little doubt that this comprehensive approach entitles this book to a seat in the list of must-reads for Japanese politics.
Theoretically, the book seeks to explain Japan's ‘extraordinary accomplishment’ of having achieved ‘their own type of democracy’ (p. 195). Instead of using a single-variable explanation, Haddad presents a profusion of historical details, demographic data and personal experiences, skipping between macro-level social change and micro-level institutional transformation. While her work does provide ample information regarding the origins of democratic transformation in Japanese society, readers may regard ‘generational change’ as the decisive variable since the author repeatedly underscores its importance as a ‘tipping point’. To demonstrate, the critical moment of democratization came when the ‘new generation that has received a democratic education becomes a majority of the voting population and a majority of the leadership in the country’ (p. 45).
This teleological view on Japanese political development might puzzle readers who have followed political changes in the past few years, especially during the period after the 3.11 Earthquake and the subsequent resurgence of the Liberal Democratic Party. The author states and implies that ‘Japanese politics has become more democratic in the last decade as democratically educated generations have come to power and are reshaping Japan's political system’ (p. 101). While we may accept that the decision-making structure and everyday behaviors of Japanese civil society organizations have been democratized, it however does not necessarily translate into the argument that the Japanese government has become ‘more diverse, involved, and accountable’ because more ‘democratically educated people have come to power’ (pp. 98, 185). In other words, while admitting that voluntary firefighters and welfare commissioners mentioned in the book could enjoy Japan's more democratic organizational culture, I am still cautious to ascertain if the quality of democracy in Japan has discernibly improved along with the generational change. Haddad's argument could have benefitted from a more detailed analysis on the contents and impacts of democratic socialization.
At the core of this book's problem sits the lack of a clear and coherent definition of democracy. In fact, this book suggests multiple murky definitions on democracy and democratization through the text. Democracy is about decentralization and a transparent governance structure when the author discusses the democratization of government, but it is more about diversity and gender equality when referring to civil society organizations. The cases of female politicians are viewed from the angle of gender roles and political opportunity. In some cases, the terms ‘democracy’ and ‘gender equality’ in the book are used almost interchangeably because the author seems to regard gender equality as the yardstick for democracy, noting that ‘gender norms have been perhaps the most difficult to reconcile in Japan’ (p. 185). Greater gender equality, however, does not necessarily bring about stronger democracy as the ‘paradoxical’ (p. 180) cases of female politicians (Chapter 7) suggest. The ‘new approach to democratization theory’ (p. 183) that the author envisions may require more theoretical refining and sophistication.
More fundamentally, Haddad's approach to address the success story of Japanese democratization by drawing out pro-democratic ‘political values [that] have persisted from a pre-democratic era’ as the ‘important foundations for Japanese democracy’ (p. 26) may be susceptible to criticism that the author selectively and arbitrarily interprets Japanese traditional values. A number of values referred to in the book such as ‘respect for all people’, ‘commitment to self-cultivation’, ‘civic participation’, and ‘individual responsibility’, do not exclusively belong to Japanese traditional values. Thus, for instance, the Japanese YMCA's basic principles that the author claims reflect its ‘commitment to both liberal democratic and traditional Japanese values’ (p. 148) do not quite differ from those of YMCAs in other countries. This reverse-teleological interpretation of traditional values goes as far as to explain the post-modern aspects of Japanese democracy (p. 153). With respect to the relations between Japanese traditional values and democracy, it seems more appropriate to ask why, or what elements of Japanese politics and society, have hampered Japan from building a better democracy earlier despite its innate pro-democratic values.
Haddad begins the book stating that it is about ‘how democracy is made real’, and ‘how the ideas of democracy are transformed into the practice of democracy, how the practice of democracy transforms the idea of democracy, and how both practices and ideas shape and are shaped by institutions’ (p. 3). Reading this book will certainly leave readers enlightened about how government institutions, state-NPO relations, and the organizational practices of civil society groups and citizens have changed in more liberal and democratic ways over the past decades. It however falls short of offering a bigger picture of Japanese democracy and civil society largely due to the ambiguous definitions of democracy and Japanese tradition, as well as the ‘unusual’ and ‘not typical’ (p. 168) cases of her research subjects, which makes it difficult to make a generalized claim. Weak causal links between macro-level social changes and micro-level democratization of values, institutions and practices also leave the author's initial question insufficiently answered.
All in all, Haddad's statement that ‘Japan's current democracy is characterized by an amalgamation of multiple political values, institutions, and practices’ (p. 84) accompanied by her rich empirical details of the government, civil society organizations, and Japanese citizens, without doubt, provides great insight and calls for academic attention. The book will rejuvenate the debate on Japanese democracy with its challenging arguments and widely open theoretical applicability. It is a valuable asset in the discipline of Japanese politics and deserves wide readership.
