Historians and critics of antebellum literary economics will hail the arrival of The Grand Chorus of Complaint: Authors and the Business Ethics of American Publishing by Michael Everton. The book expands and enriches a recent wave of studies on the intersection of literature and the business contexts of gift economies, copyright, real estate, and insurance. This chronicle of ethical conflict between authors and publishers ranges from Thomas Paine's Common Sense to Gail Hamilton's 1873 A Battle of Books, with a special emphasis on the two decades prior to the Civil War. Beginning with a history of the “character of the trade,” case studies detail disputes with publishers in the careers of Paine, Hannah Adams, Herman Melville, and Fanny Fern. At the heart of the book, flanked by these author–publisher debates, is a probing inquiry into international copyright. In a readable and spirited prose style saturated with historical specificity, Everton provides a broad and deep appreciation of the diverse voices of “the grand chorus of complaint” at this crucial phase in the development of American publishing, a period remarkable for its lack of codified law governing business practice in a culture obsessed with morality.
The leitmotif of Everton's book is trade courtesy among publishers, a code of ethics regulating prior claims to international authors. Its invocation by analogy among American publishers in their dealings with lucrative domestic authors, such as Fanny Fern, might have been fruitfully pursued. Everton makes the case quite convincingly that pressure mounted on trade courtesy – signaled by the futility of the Boston Association of Booksellers’ short-lived code of ethics – in the absence of international copyright law. The code inadvertently unleashed a business culture of retribution in place of clear guidelines for penalizing infractions (46). In the Fern chapter, however, the analysis overlooks that Fern's fictionalization of her own publisher, editor, and friend, Robert Bonner – who receives scant attention in the book despite being significantly connected to James Parton and a host of others in this book – emerges as Mr. Walter in her autobiographical novel Ruth Hall. Bonner, the most notorious of literary capitalists of the entire century, struck a pious pose by recruiting statesmen and ministers to write for his New-York Ledger. He also kept his authors the happiest, with few exceptions. His link to the book trade, further, was unmistakable, as his three main contributors of fiction – Southworth, Fern, and Cobb – routinely published their serial stories as best-selling novels under his imprint.
In asserting a critical blindness in “prevailing ways of envisioning authorship,” Everton credits himself for pioneering the reading of American fiction and nonfiction “as sites of ethical struggle insofar as these texts explain, allegorize, critique, and in some cases,” like Fern's, “reform, if hypothetically, the morality of the trade” (11). Earlier work by Michael T. Gilmore, Susan Coultrap-McQuinn, and R. J. Wilson has been followed by more recent work by Leon Jackson, David Dowling, and Ronald J. Zboray precisely to this effect. Further, Everton's treatment of fictional texts is much stronger in areas where his argument is fresh and his retreading of old critical tracks does not grate upon his otherwise stunning research. The Fern and Melville chapters, with the exception of his application of Adam Smith to Ruth Hall, are laborious in their efforts to find unclaimed territory, and do not convince with the power and novelty of his work on Adams, Paine, and Hamilton.
Readers will appreciate Everton's careful selection of primary source materials discussing the morality of the publishing trade, perhaps the most potent of which is Evert Duyckinck's 1847 “The Morality of Publishers,” reprinted in its entirety in the book. The document is packed with significance, which Everton effectively parses, making valid inroads into establishing a clear historical trajectory on publishing ethics. Unpacking the broad categories of “morality” and “courtesy” goes far toward establishing ethical definitions of the trade's character (69). Whereas Everton may not be enmeshed in the intricacies of the trade's business practice, his focus on the rhetorical development of its abstract definition as an ethical vocation at the height of the market revolution is quite effective. In some cases, however, relevant data is not supplied. William Gilmore Simms was a victim of the cutthroat publishing industry, but the darker moral truth is that he was a hard-driving self-promoter intent on capitalizing on his former association with Washington Irving as co-author of Salmagundi, and resolved to write a sequel that Irving refused to join. The book failed and Simms gravitated toward southern topics, settling with a pro-slavery racial ideology. This seems relevant to an ethical history of the trade. As for Emerson, his mentoring and marketing of his protégés are worth mentioning. He consistently negotiated for them in the literary marketplace, promoted friends like Carlyle, and served as their editor. This significantly complicates and contextualizes his rhetoric of the “natural merchant” Everton frequently cites.
This book finally succeeds in its revelation not just of complaints against publishers, but from publishers about troublesome authors and the stormy market conditions. We learn, for example, that the average antebellum bookselling venture lasted sixteen months; publishers were facing pressure from moralists and readers for entertainment alike. Evidence of their intensely conflicted roles as “culture bankers,” as Bourdieu aptly describes them, lends itself well to Everton's broader survey of their often-untenable defenses of the morality and dignity of their trade. As such, The Grand Chorus of Complaint functions best as a clearinghouse of antebellum arguments about the struggle to moralize the publishing industry during a key phase in the development of American print capitalism. The table is now set for future research into precisely which tactical shifts occurred in the trade that were accepted among publishers and which were rejected, and which grew to define the industry, particularly in the context of such long-term author–publisher relationships as Bonner–Fern, Duyckinck–Meville, and Murray–Irving. Thus literary biographers, and indeed biographers of editors and publishers, have much to learn from this landmark study.
