In the fifteen years since the South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) began its work, there have been innumerable assessments of its significance by former commissioners, scholars and journalists. Theatre practitioners, novelists and filmmakers, too, have given us their interpretations of its role in achieving national transformation through an investigation into the country's apartheid past. It was perhaps because I had seen William Kentridge and the Handspring Puppet Company's spectacle Ubu and the Truth Commission that I had expected something rather different from Catherine Cole. For what we have here is not, with the exception of a section on Philip Miller's REwind: A Cantata for Voice, Tape and Testimony, a study of the extant representations of the TRC in drama. Rather it is a constantly absorbing exercise in the application of performance studies to the proceedings of the TRC and an exhaustive analysis of the nature of transitional justice. Cole asserts that the proceedings of the commission themselves constituted a performance, whose characteristics, decisive for any true understanding of the commission's impact, have been largely neglected in scholarly analysis. In seeking to fill this gap in our understanding, she asks, ‘What insights into the TRC public hearings do the terms and theories of theatre, performance, ritual and drama enable?’ (p. 8). In her analysis, viewing the commission as performance and focusing narrowly on a few of the testimonies given before it necessarily includes both the spectators at the hearings and, through the media, the wider audience; in so doing it implicates them in the action as witnesses.
Cole's study significantly enhances our understanding of the TRC. She focuses, for example, on the crucial role of the interpreters; she views the TRC in the context of previous show trials such as the Treason Trial staged by the apartheid government; she analyses the television reporting of the proceedings, closely investigating the role television can have in such events ‘like a chorus in an ancient Greek play . . . witness, narrator, and commentator on the action’ (109). Some of what is reported will no doubt surprise the reader: the fact that only one out of ten cases was heard before the commission, and the evident reluctance of the authorities to allow researchers access to most of the TRC archive.
As an outsider, Cole paid considerable attention to getting the South African detail correct. She is sensitive to the way the TRC reversed the norms of the old South Africa by allowing broadcasting without censorship; she praises the transformation of the role of television, once a prime mouthpiece for apartheid but now in the process of redefining itself.
Cole's desire is to ‘stimulate informed public debate and advance a discourse about something that matters’ (p. xxi). This study is to be welcomed as a true example of committed scholarship.
