The author of this book is a medical doctor with keen interest in modern scientific achievements across the board. He accepts the validity of most theories in sciences dealing with the physical world, the processes of life and the nature of mental phenomena, but complains that they do not provide the ultimate explanation for the existence of the world. This, he thinks, can be remedied if traditional Indian religious and philosophical thinking is taken into account.
In western thought, the author argues, the progress of science produced an unbridgeable gap between religious faith and scientific knowledge. Thus Darwin's theory of evolution, new theories in physics and astrophysics concerning the nature of matter, space, time and the origin of the universe and the new understanding of biological processes have made untenable, on rational grounds, the idea of a God Creator of the monotheistic religions, which dominated western thought until relatively recently. It would seem, then, that “religion is contradictory to science and that to follow a religion one must give it the indulgence of not opposing it with scientific facts”.
However, “one religious philosophy not only accepted these [i.e. scientific] theories but was actually supported by them”. And that was, in the author's view, Advaita Vedānta, a system which “remains the only spiritual philosophy that is not only not negated but actually vindicated by modern science”.
After summarising briefly the development of the history of Indian civilisation and thought the author concludes that “reason demands that we should accept the philosophical system or religion that best aligns with scientific knowledge. The rigorous logic of Advaitism and Buddhism enables these philosophies to stand up to modern scientific thought and embrace it”. But Buddhism is ruled out as a remedy for the limitations of a purely scientific outlook, because when it comes to the “higher truth to the world, the absolute”, the author opines, “Buddhism eventually could not stand up against Hindu logic and was absorbed into Hinduism”. It is true that Buddhism has recognised the relativity of the world (its dependent nature), but it lacks the realisation of the “intrinsic commonality” and “the presence of the absolute as the commonality” from which all things are derived, namely the Advaitic Brahman. For Buddhism “the universe has always existed in this state of ‘dependent arising’ (pratītya samutpāda)” which the author compares to the scientific ‘steady state’ theory of the universe. But in Advaitism, the author maintains, the universe, which does not have an absolute reality, proceeds in cycles of creation and dissolution and this is a part of the natural cycle of the absolute Brahman, although Brahman as such remains unaffected by this cyclic process. The author seems unaware of the alternative scientific theory of the pulsating universe, but in fact argues for it by asserting that the ‘big bang’ could not have been the first moment of creation: “there must have always been a continuous cycle of creation and resolution”.
These are the basic theses of the book which the author elaborates throughout in numerous and sometimes repetitive variations. A substantial part of the book is further dedicated to descriptions of the four traditional yogas (bhakti, rāja, karma and jñāna) whose ultimate goal is the achievement of direct perception of Brahman, “a final, direct realisation of the absolute truth”. To achieve it, the author recommends a combination of bhakti and jñāna yogas: the effective but harsh and lonely path of jñāna yoga can be combined, in the author's view, with love of God, because the absolute “can be approached by personalizing it for the purposes of Bhakti” which “appears to be a universal need for humanity”.
Books attempting to reconcile modern scientific knowledge with a spiritual outlook derived from Eastern religious and philosophical traditions have been appearing for quite some time and some of them even became best-sellers (e.g. Fritjof Capra's The Tao of Physics, 1975, which utilises, besides Taoism, ideas from Hindu and Buddhist traditions). None of them won universal acclaim, however, even if some are quite open-minded and those which adopted one particular philosophy as expressing the final truth are usually less dogmatic than the present book. The author's adoption of Advaitism as the final solution of the riddle of existence has a strong dogmatic air about it and can be regarded only as his personal choice and a matter of faith; just as is the belief in a God Creator or in any other view, theory or philosophy, including the materialist one. No rational argumentation can ever decide the matter and certainly not as presented in this book. In fact, no advocate of Advaitism has ever succeeded in explaining the reason of how and why the absolute Brahman produces relative multiplicity. Saying that it is in Brahman's nature is an assertion, not a rational conclusion. There are other weak points in the author's argumentation and some misleading interpretations of other systems’ propositions, perhaps with the aim, conscious or unconscious, of demonstrating the superiority of Advaitism. The book has no academic merit or philosophical depth and is just the author's personal statement of his own world view as he developed it for himself from reading his sources and thinking about them. Its usefulness for prospective readers is questionable. Newcomers to Indian traditions would get from it a distorted picture while readers familiar with them would hardly learn anything new; the undoubted parallels in modern scientific theories with eastern thought are better explained in other works, notably that of Fritjof Capra.
One substantial misrepresentation of Indian traditional teachings is the author's view of the rebirth or re-incarnation doctrine which is an integral part of all Indian schools of thought (except the materialist Lokāyata or Cārvāka). According to this doctrine individuals are reborn in successive lives until they reach the ‘Absolute’ by their conscious effort on the path of Yoga. The author rejects the Upaniṣadic arguments for it and asserts, curiously enough in conformity with modern biological materialism (which is in this respect as dogmatic as any opposing theological doctrine), that “individuality is no doubt formed in the brain . . . and cannot survive its disintegration”. There is no continuity of individuals in another life. Death is for the author “an expansion of our individual identity into the Brahman”. Does it apply to all regardless of their state of knowledge and moral character? If so, why then should anyone bother with choosing to follow a Yoga path? The author's stance on the rebirth doctrine is not, of course, the position of the classical Advaita Vedānta.
Of the author's blatantly misleading characterisations of other systems let's list a few: “The concept of male-female duality” derived from Sāṅkhya “is also seen . . . in Chinese philosophy, to which it had spread through Buddhism, as the Yin-Yang concept”; Jainist kaivalya is “blessed oblivion”; “. . . [T]he world is an illusion . . . This illusion is called maya in Buddhism”; Adherents of the Mādhyamika school of Buddhism are “radical Buddhist nihilists”. Etc.
One fallacious view peddled in the book deserves explicit refutation. It concerns the origin of Indo-Āryan people who, as transpires from research into Indo-European origins, gradually drifted in several successive migratory waves into North West India between the years 1900–1500 bc from what is now Afghanistan and Iran, having previously migrated over several centuries through Asia from the assumed original homeland of all Indo-European nations placed somewhere in Southern Russia and around the Caucasus. The Indo-Āryans succeeded the urban Harappan civilisation centred within the Indus valley (which flourished between 3000–2000 bc), created the Vedic civilisation and later occupied also the Gangetic region. The author lumps the Harappan and Vedic civilisations together under the name Indo-Saraswati civilisation contemporary with early Mesopotamian and Egyptian civilisations and regards its inhabitants as indigenous, Sanskrit-speaking Āryan people (p. 51ff.). In his polemical attempt to refute the origin of Indo-Āryans outside India he shows total ignorance of the results of research in the field of Indo-European studies.
Unfortunately this has been the case even with some authors in academic positions in Indian universities after independence who have advocated an indigenous origin for Indo-Āryans. To help dispel this ignorance and to facilitate the study of the vast literature concerned with Indo-European and Indo-Āryan origins, I wrote, at the instigation of the late distinguished Vedic scholar, Professor R. N. Dandekar, the article “The Indo-Europeans and the Indo-Āryans: The philological, archaeological and historical context”Footnote 1 which helped some but was ignored by others. Since its topic is still highly relevant, it would, I think, merit updating and re-publication.
When I received this book for review, my initial reaction was to advise the review editor that it did not merit a place on this journal's pages. On second thoughts I decided that the opportunity to point out the fallacies still appearing in print about the Indo-Āryan topic has its usefulness, hence this review.
