The year 2010 is a good one to review the past and future of public health in England. On the one hand, we can shed some of the language and conceptual preoccupations of Labour and look again at what it achieved. On the other hand, the architecture of public health and the NHS is likely to change very substantially in the wake of the July 2010 White Paper (Department of Health, 2010).
Such imminent change makes a historically informed and systematic study of public health a very valuable need. The acronyms, reports and jargon will change ― but what Hunter and colleagues give us is a sense of the bigger issues, and how they have manifested themselves in one generation after another of jargon, reports, and acronyms. Rarely for a policy book published in 2010, this will be worth reading, and teaching, in 2013.
The book starts with a review of the often rather abstract debates about the nature of public health before making a plea for a ‘system’ approach (the futility of such debates is clear in their history chapters as well as their brave attempts to explain the differences between all the various professional bodies in public health). Its core is in the subsequent two chapters on the history of public health: a time of existential worry that runs from the 1974 abolition of Medical Officers of Health through to 1997, followed by a long series of efforts to take advantage of a government whose undeniably greater commitment to public health was more than matched by its commitment to public sector reorganisation. The penultimate chapter reviews the challenges facing public health today, which, given the assigned role and capacities of the public health function under Labour, mostly amount to joining up local policies. Watchers of the new coalition's plans for primary care will note that joint appointments and budgets, which come out looking relatively good, are the policies least likely to survive once divided in the hands of local governments and a new public health service.
Throughout, they make excellent use of 28 reflective interviews conducted in 2006. The reader is as impressed by respondents’ thoughtfulness as by the extent of their focus on joint working for health promotion; it is as if nobody ever had a problem with a leaking chemical tank or e.coli. This is emblematic of public health discourse, and not a research methods problem.
The fundamental problem of public health policy comes through on almost every page, sometimes quite explicitly in the interviews: there is a very poor relationship between the objective of public health (good population health) and the public health function (a scattering of doctors and variously trained others, mostly employed by the NHS). The public health function is a defined, if fractious, set of people. Public health, however, is produced by many people and policies, most unaware of their health effects, or confident that their methods (e.g. counting lives saved in highway engineering) account for them.
Schools do not do all the educating or social workers all the caring in society either, but their practitioners are not quite as distanced from their actual objectives. Consider efforts against that singularly useless product, tobacco. The most effective policies are taxes and bans on smoking in various locales. Taxes and fines are among the hardest tools government has, and are enforced by people much tougher than those found in a public health unit. On the individual level, personal medical advice and smoking cessation programs have a reasonably good record, and in the organisation of the English health system they are supplied by the NHS. What is left for the public health director? Pressure: on the NHS to fund smoking cessation properly, on the population to take advantage of it, on ‘civil society’ to educate people about it and on anybody who will listen to pass yet more stringent policies. Within public health, this pressure-function is valorised, but it presents a tempting target to anybody of a different ideology, or who is just feeling a bit gruff.
This situation is why the authors call for a systems approach – which means that ‘it would perhaps make more sense to have a clear understanding of the potential constituents of a public health system so that when issues arise in public health appropriate parts of the system can be mobilised’ (p. 48). That makes perfect sense and is what happens when there is a cryptosporidium outbreak or a shipment of contaminated heroin on sale. The problem is that it calls upon public health practitioners to develop a web of links with people who are otherwise engaged- and who might not appreciate being ‘mobilised’ to act in their own field of expertise.
The concluding chapter discusses the big new public health threats such as global warming. It is only there that the longest-standing functions of public health, the ones for which its organisation makes sense, and the ones that explain why it cannot be abolished, get much play. In other words, it is only in looking forward that infectious disease control starts to rise to the fore. The conclusion leaves the reader with the feeling that the future of public health might involve more bug-chasing and less paper-chasing. The economic and tax consequences of food, substances and inequality, meanwhile, push them far above the political levels at which public health practitioners matter much, but at the same time, we might see malaria return to Europe. That should keep the public health function busy, no matter where its practitioners end up working over the next few years.
