The debates between 1980 and 1990 on the participation of women in the imperial cult of the Eastern provinces of the Roman empire, and not least R. van Bremen's The Limits of Participation (1996) more generally on the conditions under which women became active and visible in the public sphere, have raised an awareness of the role of women during the imperial period. This edited volume, which contains a selection of twelve papers from three scientific meetings between 2012 and 2014 on the history of women in the provinces of the Roman East, aims at contributing to further discussion of the history of women's lives in that period. The editor Sophie Lalanne introduces the scope of the volume with its three sections devoted to the representation of women in the religious sphere, in the public sphere, and in literature and the visual arts, respectively. There is considerable overlap between the sections, which might have been given more consideration by the individual essays. An epilogue by Violaine Sebillotte Cuchet recapitulates the results of the volume for the field of the history of women.
Most of the papers in the first two sections examine the presence of elite women in the public sphere in general, mainly on the basis of epigraphic documentation. Some of the points raised by Gabrielle Frija in her synthetic contribution on the high priestesses in the imperial cult have particularly wide relevance. She points out that the study of women's involvement in the imperial cult as a criterion for their social and political involvement in public life reveals a diversified picture. Some regions established priesthoods that were almost systematically performed by couples (e.g. Asia, Cyprus); others ignored this model (Bithynia). The office of high priestess was probably introduced to the province of Asia under Caligula or Claudius, but other provinces may have differed. The general point Frija is making here concerns the impossibility of sketching any universal picture of the involvement of (elite) women in the Eastern Roman provinces and the need to take local particularities into consideration.
François Kirbihler's in-depth analysis of the priestesses of Artemis in Ephesus between the first and third centuries a.d. can be read as an example both of how the power of these priestesses extended to civic life and of those particular circumstances in which the female priesthood was introduced. Kirbihler argues that the introduction of priestesses instead of the male priesthood with the Persian title Megabyzos was initiated by Octavian as a restoration of the ‘old’ cult prior to the Persian domination, but it was under Claudius and Nero that the priesthood began to be held by young daughters of elite families, predominantly of Roman citizenship. Holding this priesthood became one of the first steps in what Kirbihler has called a local female cursus honorum: some of the priestesses of Artemis were high priestesses of the imperial cult or theoroi of the Great Olympia, and some fifteen of them were prytanes or gymnasiarchs, or both.
In a further local study, Olivier Ventroux examines the very limited epigraphic evidence on women in the public sphere from Roman Pergamon. According to his prudent interpretation, wealth constituted an essential criterion for women's public activities; this was, however, selectively invested in order to promote or to preserve the social standing of their families and to implement prestigious urban development plans connected with emperor worship or with Rome in general. Jesper Μ. Madsen focuses on the female Roman nomenclature in the province of Pontus et Bithynia. He considers onomastics a deliberate medium for displaying a family's belonging to the Roman cultural community. The fact that daughters of Roman citizens automatically followed Roman naming practices cannot, however, be qualified as ‘adoption’ or ‘imitation’ of a Roman cultural practice.
Éric Perrin-Saminadayar on the women of Herodes Atticus’ family circle should be read together with Ewen L. Bowie on the denigratory depiction of women in Philostratus’ Lives of Sophists. Bowie contrasts Philostratus’ conspicuous failure to mention the social position and the activities of wives and daughters of sophists with the epigraphic documentation. The richness of this documentation, as shown by Perrin-Saminadayar, confirms their contribution to, and influence on, Athenian society as much as their contribution to the ‘international’ reputation of the family. The honours decreed by different cities, associations and sanctuaries demonstrate the public recognition and esteem of the female members of the family of Herodes Atticus beyond their homeland.
Elias Koulakiotis and Jean-Baptiste Yon complement the previous papers by considering non-elite women and women outside the Greek-speaking provinces, respectively. Koulakiotis comments on the complex manumissions through consecration or dedication of humans from the sanctuary of the Great Mother at Leukopetra in Roman Macedonia. He argues that the young female slaves who were manumitted had to spend a transitional phase in the sanctuary as textile workers before being fully integrated into the civic community. Yon emphasises the family context of the private dedications of women and the vast majority of representations of women on funerary busts found in the necropoleis of Palmyra, where they appear in the midst of their family members. What is noticeable in contrast to the male figures is the uniform iconography of the deceased women, who are accompanied by gender-specific attributes such as the distaff, the spindle or the key.
Sophie Lalanne and Romain Brethes focus on images of women in the Greek novels. Do the novels reflect current social conditions and mentalities with regard to the role and status of the women in the provinces? Lalanne gives a detailed overview, while Brethes focuses on social constraints, especially those related to marriage. Systematic engagement with the epigraphic evidence would certainly have been beyond the scope of either article, but some cross-references to the contributions of Kirbihler, Perrin-Saminadayar and Bowie could have been expected.
Based on Late Antique and Byzantine hagiographies of female martyrs in Asia Minor (especially in Bithynia), Sylvain Destephen examines the role-model function assigned to them by the male Christian writers. It is a religious model that masks or ignores all social and gender differences in order to construct a uniform and universal discourse of evangelical virtues (Piety, Wisdom, Good Will or Temperance).
The last paper of the volume, by Alix Barbet and Sophie Lalanne, considers the fact that three houses at Seleucia at Zeugma each have a single room decorated solely with full-length paintings of female figures. The twelve female figures remain unidentified, apart from three who can be identified through labels. The authors argue that the iconographical choice reveals the function of these rooms as separate spaces for women, and thus as part of a gynaeconitis. However, the archaeological evidence is not conclusive and the interpretation of the paintings as serving an ideological and educational function is therefore far from compelling.
The editor has put together rewarding contributions offering a variety of methodological approaches and reflections. It certainly succeeds in reminding the reader that, irrespective of the period under study, women's history cannot be perceived without taking into consideration the historical, political, social or religious context of the available sources.
