By dedicating the year 2013 to ‘Pan-Africanism and African Renaissance’ the African Union (AU) has acknowledged that its political project, despite far-reaching declarations and decisions, is still hampered by a lack of support from member states. In this light, Martin Welz's book, which explores why AU member states are so reluctant to commit themselves to continental integration, is a timely, empirically rich and insightful contribution. Its thoroughly researched eight case studies, based upon field research in six countries, offer a much-needed analysis of the African Union from the perspective of its member states. The book reflects the ambivalences and contradictions in how member states make use of the African Union and how, given precariously legitimated national political orders, heads of state and government exploit continental integration as an opportunity structure for their own politics of survival (p. 177). Moreover, the book also illustrates that sub-regional integration is in fact a viable alternative, so that continental and regional integration may in reality be better understood as competing projects.
If true, these observations obviously come with thought-provoking and critical consequences for the future of the African Union (pp. 184–186). Welz suggests a distinction between Defenders (Zimbabwe and Swaziland), Guardians (Algeria and Ethiopia), Volunteers (Burkina Faso and South Africa) and Enthusiasts (Uganda and Mauritius), reflecting the different degrees to which member states are supposedly willing to surrender national sovereignty (pp. 22–23). The author finds that both the historical legacies of liberation and self-determination (in Zimbabwe, Algeria, Ethiopia, South Africa and Uganda) as well as the level of democratisation (in Burkina Faso, South Africa, Uganda and Mauritius) are crucial factors in explaining these differences.
It is this analytical framework which unfortunately sometimes seems to function rather as a straitjacket than a convincing heuristic, for example when Uganda's doubtful democratic credentials are used as an explanation for its willingness to ‘cede sovereign rights’ due to its support to the EAC or the ICC (p. 152). The analytical focus thus remains in a language of sovereignty, despite the acknowledgement that the classical understanding of sovereignty has been found problematic in understanding African politics (p. 10). Such a perspective is constrained, for it understands sovereignty as a zero-sum game in discrete social spaces, where promoting regional or continental integration means ceasing power at the national level. Museveni's support for the ICC, Mauritius' open policy towards international organisations, endorsement of the debate around the United States of Africa, or Compaoré's peacemaking role in West Africa, here generalised as signs of a willingness to ‘cede sovereignty’, might in fact be better understood as examples of the ambivalent ways in which the international remains crucial for the legitimation and maintenance of existing governance structures. Moreover, the case studies on so-called Defenders and Guardians provide numerous examples of a strategically sought engagement with the African Union, while for Swaziland (p. 58) and Mauritius (p. 171) the author in fact finds no explicit AU policy at all. The findings thus all seem to point to the fact that support for or resistance to integration projects is not an either/or question but that its purposes, normative foundations as well as questions relating to whose terms will ultimately set the tone have to be problematised first. Then the eight case studies in fact all alternate between moments of defence, guardianship and voluntarism. This then raises the interesting question of where and why these strategies sometimes fail or backfire as well as how the AU Commission as an emerging bureaucracy backed by massive international (financial) assistance is able to respond to this spontaneous and partial support.
However, the book's innovative general perspective and its well-structured and accessible empirical material make it an important contribution to the academic debate on the African Union as well as an insightful read for everyone – academics, students and practitioners alike – seeking to understand African continental integration dynamics.
