While Young and Pao's books may not necessarily connect in scope and content, both provide necessary and vital contributions to contemporary performance scholarship. Angela Pao's study takes a semiotics-based approach to understanding the non-traditional casting movement in the United States from the 1960s to the present, providing a plethora of examples and case studies reflecting various productions and casting choices. She explains the various criteria used in non-traditional casting and explicates the differences for classical texts, contemporary drama (both realistic and non-realistic) and Broadway musicals, as each genre presents its own challenges. Famous controversial productions (such as Miss Saigon or Joanne Akalaitis's Endgame) are touched upon, but Pao favours examining lesser-known productions, teasing out the possibilities of why non-traditional casting works for some plays but not others.
While Pao's case studies offer fascinating reading about directorial choices and actors’ intents, the succession of examples becomes tedious. The ‘success’ of casting decisions tends to be measured by either newspaper reviews or letters to the editor (usually from confused patrons), and in the case of commercial productions only by the longevity of the run. One wishes for more theoretical grounding throughout the chapters, and that Pao's final argument were not merely that contemporary casting is complicated. What she does uncover is American audiences’ dependence on realism on the stage and how that peculiar desire affects casting, a connection which must be ‘renegotiated in particular ideologically informed ways when the various forms of non-traditional casting are deployed’ (p. 21). Overall, the book fills a need for more current scholarship on the subject, propelling non-traditional casting discussions to the forefront of how American theatre must consider its multiracial landscape onstage and in the audience.
Harvey Young's project chronicles ‘the ways in which an idea of the black body has been and continues to be projected across actual physical bodies’ (p. 4) and thus how such experiences contribute to the larger phenomenological experience of blackness. Young weaves his argument through the Zealy daguerreotypes of southern slaves and the photographs of Walker Evans, solidifying connections to the sport of boxing through the ‘performances’ of Jack Johnson, Joe Louis and Muhammad Ali. His argument traces through plays by contemporary female playwrights, including Suzan-Lori Parks, Robbie McCauley and the oft-overlooked Dael Orlandersmith, and ends with a meditation on the ghastly souvenirs of lynching body parts, photographs and a museum dedicated to recalling and remembering America's racial violence of the not-too-distant past. The black body becomes at once an individualized incident and a theorized construct, taking with it the memories and experiences of all other black bodies. Thus Ali's choice to stand before the draft board and elect not to go to war reflects the bodies of those before him, not only the boisterous showmanship of Johnson (which, of course, was a performance as well) but also the stillness of the black captive Renty, perpetually stilled in Zealy's daguerreotype, and McCauley standing still upon an improvised auction block in her play Sally's Rape. The various forms of stillness offer reclamation and resistance to the continuing formation of the black body as fixed.
Each of the chapters offers a complete narrative within, as well as connecting beautifully from one chapter to the next, even if the leaps are between photographs, sport and performance. While Young addresses some topics which have been scrutinized extensively in African American studies, he offers angles, suggestions and ways of looking that have not been explored heretofore, such as considering the ‘visual embodiment’ of language (p. 128) in Parks's plays through moments of silence, contending that ‘it is the body that speaks’ (p. 166). This connecting thread of stillness as empowerment is also reflected in lynching spectacles, and Young's final chapter on the body as souvenir is one of the most compelling in the book. His argument, layered and nuanced, suggests that the lynching keepsake (whether toe, rope, personal narrative or museum) operates on the past/passed bodies, through centuries of structural violence, and at times exceeds the bounds of definition and theorization. He concludes with an intriguing discussion of lynching survivor James Cameron's quest to see lynching remembered through ‘America's Black Holocaust Museum’, now a relic of its former self, but a testament to an individual's desire to stave off erasure of the past. Indeed, what a powerful relic. Young's close readings of each subject are exemplary and detailed, but also accessible and clear, making this book a sound example of performance-studies scholarship in the field today.
