This short book is one of the first in a new series devoted to the history of Islam through the study of prominent and important Muslim individuals or—in some instances—groups. Evidently the aim is to produce a series of concise studies that can be read and understood without any previous knowledge of the subject, combining basic information in clear English with the insights of the latest scholarship (the authors being leading scholars in their fields). This book fully succeeds in meeting those ends.
Chase Robinson's main concern is with ʿAbd al-Malik as propagandist of the idea of a state over which the ruler, the caliph, had absolute authority as God's representative, and as the creator of several of the institutions that were to be typical of the Islamic state for long afterward. He relies mainly on the evidence of contemporary poetry and material remains such as coins and milestones and relatively little on the Islamic historical tradition, his reservations about which (but not complete scepticism) he makes clear. It is the prominence that he gives to the contemporary evidence at the expense of the later (and apparently much more detailed) literary sources that makes this work distinctive. Indeed, it is the relative abundance of material remains from the late-7th and early-8th centuries, compared with their paucity for the first seventy years or so of Islam, which is a main plank of his argument.
Among other innovative and interesting themes, the author rebuts the conventional dates given for the caliphate of ʿAbd al-Malik (arguing that for much of the time he was a rebel rather than a legitimate caliph), stresses the influence of Ibn al-Zubayr's ideology upon his Umayyad rival, and proposes that ʿAbd al-Malik played a significant part in editing and revising the text of the Qurءan.
Robinson recognizes that the evidence available does not allow us to answer several questions that we would wish to. Much of the life of his protagonist is obscure, and it is not possible to say how far the caliph himself was responsible for some of the developments discussed in the book. Sometimes—for example, regarding the Qurءan, the development of the Meccan sanctuary and the hajj, and their relationship to the Dome of the Rock—he suggests models and broad strategies for reinterpretation rather than precise and certain conclusions.
The bibliography of suggested further reading, sources, and secondary literature allows the interested reader (with some effort) to identify the evidence on which the arguments are based and to relate them to the modern scholarship that is behind them. There are no footnotes or endnotes, but the work does have a glossary, some tables and maps, and photographs of coins and inscriptions.
In comparison with his discussion of the place of ʿAbd al-Malik in the development of the Qurءan and the hajj, Robinson's approach to the question of the status of Muhammad in emerging Islam is relatively traditional. He does not doubt that belief in his status as a prophet was a fundamental ingredient of Islam from the start, in spite of the paucity of references to him in material that can be dated to the first seventy years or so. The first proclamations of him as the messenger of God on coins are on those minted by the Zubayrids in the mid-680s, and later ʿAbd al-Malik's coins and inscriptions repeat that formula. Robinson interprets this as a development in understanding the need to proclaim the fact, rather than of the fact itself. He does not give much space to those statements attributed in the literary tradition to figures such as Hajjaj and Khalid al-Qasri that appear to elevate the caliph at the expense of the Prophet. Robinson refers (p. 112) to the sermons and letters of ʿAbd al-Malik and his servants as “evoking God and his Prophet,” but the examples that he has given previously mention only God. (The reference to Muhammad at the foot of p. 111 is apparently a slip, and ʿAbd al-Malik is intended.) The charge made against Ibn al-Zubayr that he omitted the name of the Prophet from the introductory formulae to his sermons (p. 112) is curious, given the evidence of the Zubayrid coinage. Robinson seems willing to accept it at face value, but it might be interpreted in different ways.
Any reader, whether coming to ʿAbd al-Malik for the first time or already familiar with some of the evidence and literature pertaining to him, will find this book rewarding. For the beginner it is informative, and only rarely could it be clearer. One place where it might be clearer is the case of a photograph of a coin labeled “‘Orans’ coin” (p. 45). As far as I can see, that expression has nowhere been used in the text and there is nothing to indicate how it relates to the previous discussion of the Zubayrid coinage. For the more advanced scholar there is much that is insightful, suggestive, and thought provoking. Subsequent books in the series will have a high standard to maintain.
