Despite ongoing debates about immigration reform, tightening border security and the nationwide rallies for amnesty that took hold of the United States in 2003, the voices of immigrant workers, and especially undocumented immigrant workers, are rarely heard in the archive. In this respect, Apostolidis's study of the “new” Latin American immigrants and their fundamental role as workers and activists in the United States makes a significant and compelling contribution to the literature. Breaks in the Chain brings recent immigrant workers, both the undocumented and those who became naturalized under the 1986 Immigration Reform Control Act, onto the political stage as “narrators of power” (xiv) and proponents of a new radical democracy.
In analysing power and democracy in the workplace, Apostolidis meshes political theory, a Foucauldian understanding of biopolitics and a Gramscian framework of hegemony and counterhegemony with the oral testimony of immigrant workers from Mexico. In doing so, Breaks in the Chain generates fresh insights into the “politics of narrative” (xxxvi) and the ability of immigrant workers to challenge neoliberal power: while immigrant workers often assist hegemony, argues Apostolidis, “individual acts of freedom-within-power congeal into shared practices for narrating the social world and thus help to constitute it and to expose it to collective challenges” (xxxii).
Apostolidis's case study concerns a group of Mexican immigrant workers in Washington state's meatpacking industry. Here, in 1999, in the slaughterhouses of Iowa Beef Processors, Inc. (IBP, later Tyson Foods), Mexican workers staged an illegal six-week strike to improve health and safety in the workplace, reorganize the union and empower the rank and file. Although the IBP unionists, known as Teamsters Local 556, were eventually defeated (the union fragmented into “reformers” and “counter-reformers” bent on seeking redress through a “liberal-legalist” campaign (201)), the 1999 strike established the ground upon which workers later collaborated at the local and transnational levels with activists in the labour, immigrant and consumer-rights movements. Thus, insists Apostolidis, the agency and political narratives of immigrant workers hold the key not only to understanding the dynamics of neoliberal power, but also to challenging hegemony through a radical democratic activism that can transcend special interests.
By focussing on the immigrant worker as the key to the revitalization of the US labour movement and radical democratic politics, Breaks in the Chain is nothing new: Apostolidis exploits a wealth of existing literature on the “new” nativism, neoliberalism and transnational capital, as well as the central dilemma behind the latinization of the United States: how to translate demographic power into political and economic power. The book's strength, however, lies in Apostolidis's detailing of the intricacies and continuities within individual worker testimonies, which begin not in the United States, but in the regions of Mexico where neoliberalism has thwarted the possibility of upward social mobility. Apostolidis traces individual narratives and counterhegemonic strategies that were devised in the moment of uprooting from the homeland, then redeployed on crossing the US–Mexico border, and again in the collective drama of the 1999 strike.
Although the theorizing in the early sections of the book suggests the possibility of either subduing or overworking the testimony, Apostolidis's handling of the oral interviews in the central chapters is both sensitive and incisive. These individual narratives exhibit a central tension: immigrant workers “consent” to neoliberalism, the surveillance of the border zone and the disciplinary power of the US meat industry, at the same time that they contest the system. Apostolidis's analysis of biopolitics through workers' narratives gains most momentum in chapter 4, as the regulatory dynamic of the IBP chain of production in the slaughterhouse wields “despotic power” (116) over the immigrant body: workers respond with “bodily practices” (94) patterned after those used to cross the US–Mexico border, such as finding “routes” in the workplace to avoid injury and surveillance, applying creams to damaged skin (160), and establishing group survival strategies from individual acts of defiance, all foundations for the 1999 strike activity.
Apostolidis's transnational analysis becomes a core element in the book's call for change. While the collective strategies of the IBP strikers evolved within a transnational terrain encompassing the US and Mexico, once in the US, Local 556 went on to pattern “a new vernacular of shared, multiracial, cross-class, transnational struggle against neoliberal hegemony and its biopolitical methods” (232) by working across a variety of borders with other immigrant, labour, health and consumer-rights groups: for example, Portland and Los Angeles-based organizations engaged in transborder labour activism, while Mexican immigrant activists networked into their hometowns of Oaxaca, southern Mexico, local non-profit group Safe Work/Safe Food, and the nationwide Immigrant Workers Freedom Rides of 2003. The closing stages of the book demonstrate exactly why the IBP activists, and their melding of immigrant and worker rights, educate us about power and democracy. Ultimately, Breaks in the Chain exposes a system in which racialized immigrant workers and the perceived beneficiaries of neoliberalism are exploited in different ways by the system's contradictions and imbalances: flaws in the system, whether contaminated food, overproduction or the rise in obesity deriving from a food manufacturing industry reliant on high-speed production and the super-exploitation of cheap labour, or the multifarious modes of surveillance that accompany increased border security and militarization, affect us all, claims Apostolidis. Thus the multiple alliances forged by the Local 556 activists present a way forward for the future.
Much like the varied groups who forged alliances out of the events of 1999–2000, different audiences, including political theorists, sociologists, anthropologists and activists, should read Breaks in the Chain for different purposes. Indeed, Apostolidis positions the book as part of an alliance between different groups for change. Although Apostolidis's theorizing is sometimes neutralized by the force of the narratives (the degradation of the slaughterhouse and the strategies fashioned by workers under such circumscribed conditions all too often speak for themselves), the book's conclusion is ultimately satisfying. And most importantly, Breaks in the Chain retains its currency and powerful political message without ever denying its immigrant protagonists humanity, dignity and agency.
