John L. Busch has masterfully produced a dual biography of both the steamship Savannah and its creator, Moses Rogers. It is the first such biography in over half a century, and by far the most complete account of the first crossing of the Atlantic by steamship. The ‘barrier’ in the title refers to the technological and psychological obstacles that Rogers and other steam visionaries faced in the early 1800s. Steamboats had been sporadically plying the rivers and canals of America and Europe since the 1780s, soon after James Watt had introduced his improved steam engine. Early teething problems with boilers, fittings and propulsion devices hampered the development of a commercially viable steamboat. Finally, in 1807, Robert Fulton successfully married a reliable steam engine with reasonably efficient paddlewheels to create the North River Steam Boat that regularly travelled the Hudson River, from New York City to Albany and back. The age of the scheduled steamboat service had arrived, and steamboat lines quickly opened across the young nation.
The notion that maritime transport of goods and passengers could be scheduled and not dependent on the prevalent winds changed the nature of commerce. Predictability became a business keyword. Within a few years, a regular sailing packet service was begun between New York and Liverpool. But this service could only promise a departure date; there was no guarantee of when the ship would arrive. Moses Rogers, a Connecticut sailing-ship master, had witnessed Fulton's first steamboat trials and decided to get in early on this newfangled technology, spending the following decade piloting increasingly sophisticated steamboats up and down the East Coast. But these steamboats had short ranges and limited ability to sail on the high seas. By 1818, Rogers had worked out a novel vision with investors in Charleston and Savannah – to extend the predictability of the steam service across the Atlantic by building a long-haul steam ship, which could compete with New York sailing packets to open up European markets to the southern states.
Rogers fully understood that, in order to gain the confidence of potential investors, his pathbreaking steamship would have to be familiar and dependable in all aspects, save the novel technology of the steam engine. For this prototype, steam would be used primarily in conditions that often made sailing times so irregular: calm conditions and coming in and out of port. Since the ship would spend most of its time under sail, it had to be completely seaworthy and the steam propulsion system could not interfere with normal sailing. Rogers chose a solidly built sailing-ship hull under construction in New York City in which to install his engine, renaming it Savannah. The steam engine was fitted low in the hull so that it did not affect stability, and the small paddlewheels were built to be easily disassembled so they did not add to drag while under sail.
The ship was dubbed a ‘steam coffin’ when completed in 1818, an undeserved designation that Rogers intended to disprove. He began this process the following year when he sailed and steamed his ship to its home port of Savannah, where he hosted President James Monroe on a short coastal journey. A few days later, Savannah embarked on its historic month-long transatlantic voyage to Liverpool. Steam power on the high seas was such a novel sight that when Savannah brushed past Ireland, a revenue cutter came to its aid, its crew believing the ship was on fire. Although the ship spent less than one-seventh of its voyage under steam, its arrival in Liverpool attracted immediate interest and accolades – for here was an American ship using a British invention in a way that many had thought impossible. Moses Rogers had indeed shown that a steamship could operate across the Atlantic, but this revelation turned out to have bent, but not broken, the ‘barrier’, for Savannah was a one-of-a-kind ship, and regular transatlantic steaming would not, in fact, take place for another twenty years.
John L. Busch, who is the author as well as the publisher, has produced a massive, handsome book, with clear typeface and informative maps and illustrations. It is meticulously researched, the author having mined hundreds of archival and primary sources in eight nations. It is well written, the author taking great care to locate Moses Rogers and Savannah in the larger political, social and economic context of a post-Napoleonic world. This is seen, for example, when British officials consider the threat of the steamship, which could approach the windswept St Helena Island and remove Napoleon from his exile without any sailing warship able to stop it. It is also seen in the interest of fledgling South American nations like Chile in acquiring steamships as weapons in their wars of independence against Spain.
Busch is especially adept at describing the steam technologies then in use, providing ground-level details on the manufacture of boilers and cylinders. He clearly explains the difficulties in fitting steam apparatus into an ocean-going vessel, in particular the hazards of shipboard fire and fighting the build-up of salt deposits in pipes and boilers. At the same time, he paints altogether human portraits of the men who developed, built and operated these novel technologies.
Steam Coffin is both a great read and a vital reference for serious scholars. For all that, the text is marred by the author's insistence on italicizing and defining every new word, as if the book were a 7th-grade history primer: ‘chimera (khi-máir-uh)’ (p. 71). As intelligently as the author writes, he should assume equal intelligence among his readers.
