There is little rigorous scholarship on professional theatre for young audiences (TYA). This comprehensive and diverse collection of essays by a major figure in the field provides a welcome starting point for expanded inquiry into TYA, both locally and within the context of global theatre studies. Van de Water approaches theatre for children and youth (broadly defined as birth to twenties) as a sophisticated and influential art form whose aims, methods and works are perpetually transforming due to ‘the shifting material circumstances (social, cultural, economic, ideological, and political) under which this theatre is generated and perceived’ (p. 1). The book focuses on theatre in the United States, Russia and the Netherlands. Although Van de Water encourages further research in other geographical areas, these diverse cultural landscapes triangulate nicely, providing ample contrast and correlation across multiple topics.
The first chapter looks at the historical construction of TYA in the United States, (Soviet) Russia and the Netherlands in order to demonstrate how narratives about the field's past shape current policy and creative output. The second chapter employs the work of Pierre Bourdieu, Ric Knowles and Jacques Rancière to explain (and challenge) how adult perceptions about children's lack of cultural capital contribute to TYA's marginalization. Chapter 3 is a discourse on taboos in TYA, outlining how and under what circumstances taboos are generated in different social, political and cultural contexts. It also incorporates a broader discussion of childhood studies, citing William Corsaro and Jacques Rancière, among others, to argue for an understanding of children as active members of society, or, to use Gerd Taube's terminology, as ‘“human beings” versus “human becomings”’ (p. 121). Drawing on material from two recent conferences discussing TYA and taboos, this chapter is the most international in scope. In Chapter 4, Van de Water focuses on one taboo in depth, examining representations of gays and lesbians in TYA in the United States. Chapter 5 uses the aftermath of the 2004 terrorist attack on a school in North Ossetia, Russia, to reflect on the therapeutic benefits of theatre for children. The final chapter discusses the emerging genre of theatre for the very young (birth to age three).
Wielding a dizzying array of methodologies, including historiography, cultural-materialist theory, material semiotics, textual analysis and ethnography, Van de Water demonstrates her considerable knowledge and experience as an international scholar, practitioner and pedagogue. Underlying the text is a mounting critique of the assumptions and misperceptions about the aesthetic value of children's theatre, as well as its potential as a serious subject of inquiry for scholars of theatre and performance. But the book's tone is not bitter; it is optimistic, even heartfelt. Rather than offering ‘definitive answers’ (p. 141), Van de Water invites – and indeed inspires – further research into all areas of TYA, except, perhaps, the heretofore dominant tendency to calculate its educational and moral value.
