In his 1605 Advancement of Learning Francis Bacon makes the striking statement that “immortality or continuance” is where human nature “doth most aspire.”Footnote 1 He goes on to say that the longing for immortality or continuance accounts for a great diversity of human works, including families, buildings, monuments, and celebrations. And he concludes by announcing that if one investigates the sources of human desires, one finds that beneath them lies this two-pronged wish to go on: for Bacon, the longing for immortality or continuance is the motive source of all human actions.
Nearly twenty years later, in his 1623 work entitled History of Life and Death, Bacon calls for future scientists to “become the instruments and dispensers of God's power and mercy in prolonging and renewing the life of man.”Footnote 2 He then presents an extensive natural history of the causes of decay and the means of regeneration that is to inform a science for extending life. Life extension is possible, according to Bacon, if humans better understand the causes of decay and the sources of repair—it is only the faultiness of past science that has prevented greater longevity.Footnote 3 As he argues in his 1625 De Augmentis Scientiarum, medicine proper has three tasks: preserving health, curing disease, and prolonging life. Physicians have failed at the third task because they collapse it into the first two—they think that in order to prolong life, it is enough to preserve health and to cure disease. Instead, they must develop a science for extending the “thread of life itself”—they must take up the science that the History of Life and Death outlines.Footnote 4
In light of the powerful longing for continuance posited in the Advancement of Learning and the proposal for a science of life extension presented in the History of Life and Death, life extension comes to light as a compelling new outlet for satisfying the desire for continuance. In other words, by advancing the project of life extension, Bacon suggests that humans can go to greater lengths to satisfy their deepest desire.
Bacon's call for a science of life extension stands in striking contrast with how his predecessors regard mortality. Those who come before him—from Homer to Plato to Augustine to Montaigne—regard death in this world as an unalterable necessity. While they acknowledge that humans have powerful passions to fear death and love life, they do not treat mortality as something that can change.Footnote 5 Instead, they respond by offering portraits of the kinds of posthumous legacies and otherworldly lives that humans might reasonably pursue. From the perspective of philosophy, moreover, death is regarded as a primary source of contemplative inspiration. Montaigne's Socratic formulation that “to philosophize is to learn how to die” captures this strain of the tradition nicely.Footnote 6 Before Bacon, readers are advised to come to terms with human mortality—to strive for heroic memory, to seek life in the next world, to embrace philosophical contemplation of death—not to try to alter it.
Against the backdrop of the tradition that he inherits, Bacon's call for life extension seems bold, if not hubristic. As the classical and Christian traditions often point out, longer life does not necessarily lead to the greatest human happiness, and death, for many, can seem like a blessing. Why, then, does Bacon depart so markedly from the past? And did he foresee the hazards of his departure? The History of Life and Death helps us begin to answer the first question. There, Bacon says that his life-extension project is for the broad benefit of humankind; he then goes further, arguing that as humans succeed at extending their time in the world, they can more fully develop and perfect technology. “Life is short and art, long,” he says—and he who seeks to perfect the arts should also undertake to prolong the life of man.Footnote 7 Life extension, then, in addition to having primal appeal, is in the service of Bacon's broad technological project.
The Wisdom of the Ancients can help us answer the second question—the question about Bacon's knowledge of the hazards of his project.Footnote 8 It shows that from the time Bacon articulates the longing for immortality or continuance in the Advancement of Learning to the time that he sets the stage for life extension in the History of Life and Death, he tackles some of the most difficult challenges for the political and philosophical tradition that life extension will bring. In other words, Bacon considers the hazards of his undertaking deeply. More specifically, the Wisdom of the Ancients contains Bacon's most extensive set of insights into the challenges that life extension poses for politics, and offers an account of the implications of life extension for philosophy. The argument of this paper, therefore, is twofold: (1) that through the fables of the Wisdom of the Ancients Bacon presents key political strategies for promoting life extension and tending to its hazards; and (2) as he presents his teaching on the politics of life extension, Bacon sketches a new portrait of philosophy, which is compelled to redirect some of its energies to discovering what makes longer life worth living.
Bacon's life-extension project—by which I mean the amalgam of his technical call to elongate life, his natural history, his theory of human motivations, and the moral philosophy he presents to address its hazards—has profound significance for our understanding of his political philosophy. It shows us not only that he treated mortality differently from the ancients, but also that he offered a political and philosophical framework for living with extended life.
Despite the scholarly significance of Bacon's project, his teaching on life extension has gone largely unexplored. Many scholars note that the desire for immortality is a central concern of Bacon's, but only a few explore the implications of this desire for his broad politico-scientfic project.Footnote 9 And yet the implications are very far reaching. Bacon's teaching on life extension has major implications for our understanding of several major spheres of his thought: (1) his teaching on charity; (2) his view of fame as an outlet in the quest for immortality; and (3) his account of philosophy.
Scholars working on Baconian charity argue that Bacon adapts the idea of biblical charity to sanction a science that works to relieve humankind from necessity, and in so doing, permits greater power over nature to human communities.Footnote 10 As we see in the History of Life and Death, for Bacon, life extension will permit a greater perfection of technology, which, in turn, can be put in the service of Bacon's broad humanitarian project. Life extension, therefore, extends the reach of Baconian charity. At the same time, Bacon is keen to show that the expansion of technological power can have consequences that are detrimental to human flourishing. He shows in the Wisdom of the Ancients, for example, that as technological affluence expands sources of pleasures, the human soul is increasingly vulnerable to self-enslavement (XIII and XXXI). Furthermore, for Bacon, some forms of pleasure-filled lives can get worse as they get longer—the potential corruptions of technology can be compounded by ever-longer life (XIII). To receive the largess of Bacon's technological affluence, humans need to develop certain characteristics of soul. By exploring Bacon's life-extension project, we start to see more clearly how individuals become psychologically equipped to receive Baconian charity in its many hazardous forms.
Exploring Bacon's teaching on life extension also helps us to understand his view of human motives. Most of the scholars who delve into Bacon's account of the desire for immortality focus on his account of how this longing leads to the pursuit of immortal fame.Footnote 11 The focus on fame is understandable, since Bacon suggests that one of the primary ways that the ambitious reckon with the longing for immortality is to pursue posthumous fame.Footnote 12 He also offers extensive reflections on how to build immortal legacies effectively.Footnote 13 The drawback of this focus, however, is that it turns away from Bacon's teaching on the way that the pursuit of physical life extension, an alternative outlet for the desire for continuance, alters human actions and goals, and introduces new challenges for individuals that are distinct from those that the pursuit of posthumous fame presents. By examining Bacon's teaching on life extension, we see him offer a new view of the ends of immortal ambition.
In a similar vein, exploring Bacon's teaching on life extension enlarges our view of Baconian philosophy. Most of the scholarship that explores Bacon's view of philosophy in relation to mortality rightly focuses on his character Orpheus, who, in the eleventh and final sections of the Wisdom of the Ancients, represents philosophy, and whose philosophic activity is shaped by his failed struggle to restore life. The most illuminating discussion of philosophy through Orpheus is presented by Timothy Paterson, but several others have explored the example in some detail.Footnote 14 According to Paterson, Bacon's Orpheus fable forms a critique of classical philosophy: because classical philosophy fails to attend sufficiently to the longing for immortality, it has become vulnerable to being destroyed by religious passions (which are inspired by fear of death). Since Paterson focuses in his reading of Orpheus on classical philosophy's failure, he does not fully explore the positive vision of philosophy that Bacon presents at the culmination of the Wisdom of the Ancients. That is, whereas the Orpheus that Paterson describes represents a failed classical philosophy, the Orpheus I will describe is a new exemplar of Baconian philosophy: a philosophy that concerns itself with discovering the activities of mind and soul that make elongated life worth living.
In addition to the scholarly value of Bacon's teaching on life extension, Bacon's thought is also of great contemporary relevance. One need only consider the current politics of life extension—the dilemmas of palliative care, the extension of childhood, changes in childbearing age, the midlife crisis, appropriate ages for marriage, education, work, and retirement—to see that we are not at ease in the greater expanse of time in which life takes place. A brief look at calls to treat death as a disease demonstrates how prescient Bacon's thought is.Footnote 15 Bacon's text, then, affords us the opportunity to consider more philosophically the hazards of pursuing longer lives. Although we cannot presume that Bacon foresees the specific manifestations of our own quest for longevity, his philosophical understanding of our fear of death and hope for life is invaluable for deepening our reflections on the increasingly long lifespans we currently enjoy.
To offer my account of Bacon's teaching on life extension and its implications for politics and philosophy, I follow two characters through the Wisdom of the Ancients. In the first part, I follow Jupiter, who represents the ruler in command of the Baconian world. I show that Jupiter presents Bacon's key political strategies for managing the consequences of life extension. In the second part, I turn to Orpheus, who represents the shift from a failed classical philosophy to a successful Baconian philosophy. Ultimately, I show that Bacon portrays the arc of a lifespan in a novel way, gives us conceptions of the virtues and categories that help us to make the best use of our extended time in the world, shows the political means to disseminate his novel framework, and gives us a philosophical perspective through which we can reckon with the new parameters of mortal existence.Footnote 16
How the Fables Work
Before delving into Bacon's fables on life extension, it is helpful to consider the context in which they appear. The Wisdom of the Ancients is a multifaceted philosophical work that takes up questions that are both timeless and timely. The work consists of thirty-three classical myths that Bacon retells and reinterprets in order to offer a series of philosophical teachings that address political, psychological, cultural, religious, and intellectual challenges—many of which begin to emerge in early modernity. The topics upon which Bacon reflects are diverse. He takes up themes as wide-ranging as the dangerous ambitions of scientists (XIX), the threat of mass political tumult (II), the relationship between medicine and political rule (III), the nature of religious zeal (XVIII), the challenge of ruling human passions (XXVI), the nature of the atom (XVII), and the political power of pity (XVI). Broadly speaking, the work is concerned with reinvigorating philosophy, and it does so by means of telling stories that help to expose philosophy's power in all realms of life (Preface). The Wisdom of the Ancients therefore displays not only the scope of Bacon's politico-scientific vision, but also the extent of his philosophic reach.Footnote 17
In each chapter of the Wisdom of the Ancients, Bacon retells a classical myth and offers an interpretation of that myth. Sometimes the myths recall a moral teaching associated with the classical figure at hand—the Sirens, for example, reveal the hazards of pleasures (XXXI). At other times the fables depart strikingly from the originals.Footnote 18 For instance, Oedipus is a victorious king of Thebes, and no mention is made of his classical tragic fate (XXVIII). The fables are also constructed provocatively to explore subjects not traditionally associated with the classical figure at hand. In this vein, Bacon announces that Cupid conveys insight into the atom, and the story of Proteus reveals the nature of matter (XII and XIII, respectively). The juxtapositions have the effect of provoking Bacon's readers into investigating unfamiliar phenomena by rethinking familiar stories.
Furthermore, the fables are not meant solely to entertain. As Bacon says in his dedication to the Earl of Salisbury, “to the vulgar apprehension they will be vulgar; but it may be that the deeper intellect will be… carried along.” In other words, the fables speak differently to different ears.Footnote 19 Bacon claims that for some readers, the fables mask radical thoughts, while for other readers, they convey them. In the latter case, Bacon suggests, fables are the ideal vehicle for introducing new models of the world. He writes, “as hieroglyphs were more ancient than letters, so parables were more ancient than arguments. And even now, if someone wishes to pour new light about anything new into the minds of humans, and not incommodiously or harshly, utterly the same way must be insisted on, and refuge must be taken in the help of likenesses” (Preface).
To heighten the enticing power of his fables, Bacon litters them with puzzles. Each fable consists of two sections: the retold fable, and the interpretation. The reader gains insight into the fables by taking on a few interpretive tasks: first, by examining what Bacon wishes to show in his telling of the fable itself; second, by reasoning through why Bacon chooses to reconstruct the fables as he does (whether they depart from the classical originals or only draw selectively from them); third, by figuring out the differences between the myth itself and the interpretive section. In general, Bacon's playful interpretations enlist his readers in the project of seeing more dynamically the philosophical insight behind his images.
Jupiter's Strategies for Extending Life
In light of the complex and intricate character of the fables in the Wisdom of the Ancients, the project at hand will require that I interpret individual fables, and trace out the theme of life extension through the book as a whole. Although many of the fables seem to be discrete, one feature of the book is that certain characters—like Jupiter and Orpheus—appear in multiple fables. These characters shape the broader imagined world that all of the characters implicitly inhabit. Therefore, observing them affords us insight into the cosmos that Bacon presents in the Wisdom of the Ancients. As I outlined above, in the first part, my focus will be on Jupiter, who appears in a number of fables in the book as an exemplar of Baconian rule. In the course of his actions, Jupiter illustrates the political strategies that Bacon recommends for disseminating and managing his life-extension project. In a number of fables Jupiter manipulates views on mortality, and in some cases extends the lifespan directly. My focus is on Jupiter's involvement in four fables where changes in mortality and life extension are beginning to unfold: Cyclops, Memnon, Tithonus, and Prometheus.
Jupiter's Co-optation of Aesculapius's Power
Jupiter makes his first appearance in the Wisdom of the Ancients in the opening fables of the book where he is struggling to maintain power as a new king. In “Cyclops, or Ministers of Terror,” Bacon describes how Jupiter uses the Cyclops as his henchmen for suppressing rebels with terror (III). In the midst of his attempt to suppress violent rebellion, Jupiter also kills Aesculapius (the god of the medical art) in order to punish him for “raising a man from the dead with medicine.” This conspicuous and offhand detail is the first clue that Bacon is presenting a political art that concerns itself with the powers of extending life.
Bacon says that the fable “Cyclops” is about “the doings of kings.” By killing Aesculapius, Bacon suggests that managing Aesculapian power is in the domain of kings. Yet, Bacon leaves us with something of a puzzle concerning how rulers ought to regard the potential life-extending power of medicine. In light of the classical version of the story, it appears as though Jupiter simply does not want humans to possess the art of restoring life. This is borne out by Apollodorus, an Athenian chronicler of ancient fables, who says that Jupiter slew Aesculapius because he was afraid that human beings would use the medical art to come to the rescue of each other.Footnote 20 If, as the fable suggests, Jupiter rules primarily by fear of death, and by holding a monopoly on the means to live, then Aesculapius's power can subvert Jupiter's rule. Jupiter seems to kill Aesculapius to prevent the spread of his life-extending power.
This reading is not adequate, however, since later in the book we see that Jupiter is quite willing to grant humans both extended life and perpetual youth (in fables XIV and XXVI respectively). In light of these later developments, we realize that when Jupiter kills Aesculapius, he takes the power of the medical art and wields it on his own terms. For Bacon, the power to extend life must be guided by the political art. That is, Bacon uses Jupiter to show how the powers of the medical art, and, subsequently, the longings that it awakens, are to be governed in the political realm.
In the next fables, we start to see what Bacon means by suggesting that Jupiter wields this political art. It is not merely that he possesses the technical power to extend life; he also shapes how humans respond to this power. The political art that embraces the power of life extension concerns itself with reshaping the public understanding of the human lifespan.
Jupiter, Memnon, and the New Prime of Life
Jupiter's ruling strategy begins to unfold as he manages the public response to the death of a young man who falls in battle. As Bacon tells it, Memnon was a foolhardy youth who rushed vainly into battle with Achilles and was promptly killed (XIV). After he died, Jupiter sent lugubrious birds to wail at his funeral. From then on, his statue, when hit by rays of the sun, emitted a mournful sound.
The first thing that stands out in this story is that Bacon's telling of it contrasts starkly with the classical original. In classical sources, Memnon is depicted as a noble man who is Achilles's equal in strength. His fall is tragic.Footnote 21 Bacon writes, in stark contrast, that men such as Memnon are “swollen and empty with external looks,” and typically “dare things greater than their strength.” They forfeit the fullness of their lives out of vain hope for success at great deeds. By making Memnon less noble than he appears in original sources, Bacon downplays the glory of his original story. The attempt for posthumous fame by dying heroically in battle is not celebrated here. The world that Bacon would have humans inhabit is one that de-emphasizes martial valor in favor of something else.
Accordingly, when Jupiter has birds mourn at Memnon's death, they do not mourn for the fall of a great war hero. Instead they represent the “infinite commiseration” that follows the untimely death of a young person. Bacon says, “none among the fates of mortals is so mournful, so powerful to move compassion, than the precipitous premature end of the flower of virtue.” Furthermore, the lamentations for such a person will be strongest at the beginnings of new enterprises, “like by the rays of the morning sun.” Compassion for untimely death generates a powerful vision of what might have been: Memnon's death is lamented because it was a life in potentia.
The powerful inclination to envision Memnon's potential that Bacon describes, and that Jupiter inspires, indicates that Bacon wishes to display the possibility that there is a natural fulfillment to human life that only arises after one has matured and lived long enough to achieve something: a prime of life. The infinite commiseration that Bacon describes for Memnon's lost life demonstrates that human beings have a longing to see human potential realized, and that premature death for the sake of immortal glory typically does not satisfy this longing. For Bacon, it is the task of the political art to give direction to the wish to see youthful potential reach its prime.
We see Jupiter demonstrate this art when he awakens sympathy for Memnon; in so doing he begins to reconstitute how the political community imagines the prime of life. Jupiter has the potential to use compassion much as Pericles uses compassion in his funeral oration when he paints a portrait of the heroic and patriotic Athenian.Footnote 22 That is, when Athens is mourning for the loss of its young, Pericles gives an unconventional speech exalting the Athenian citizen willing to sacrifice his life for democratic Athens. In the Baconian world, where the conquest of nature is increasingly taking the place of conquest by war, the heroic vision of young men sacrificing their youth in battle can be accompanied by another model of the fulfillment of youthful potential.
Bacon does not here provide an image of this model, but he does indicate that Jupiter has deliberately awakened a passion for seeing men fulfill their lives in new ways. In the New Organon, Bacon argues that those who make discoveries rightly hold the first place in the ranking of human actions, and those who have successes in the political world are second in deserved honors.Footnote 23 The former benefit all of humankind without necessarily risking their lives, while the latter only benefit a particular geographic region, often at the risk of death. In drawing out compassion for those who die too young, and depicting their deaths in war as foolhardy, Bacon shows Jupiter redirecting popular energies. Jupiter paves the way for a citizenry that supports youth who fill out their lives in pursuit of new ends and discoveries. More broadly, in redirecting popular ambition away from posthumous fame, Bacon's Jupiter places ambition in the service of his vision of human charity. Instead of serving national interests and personal memory, youthful energies can be directed at human flourishing in this world.
Jupiter, Tithonus, and the Pitfalls of Everlasting Life
Having initiated a turn from immortal glory toward lives dedicated to new ends, Jupiter begins to display some of the pitfalls of life extension. In the fable that follows Memnon, Bacon tells the story of Memnon's father, Tithonus, and his wife, the immortal Aurora. Aurora begs Jupiter that Tithonus will not die, and Jupiter grants her wish, but Tithonus becomes increasingly old and frail—so much so that his life becomes miserable. Jupiter then takes pity on him and turns him into a cicada.
The subtitle of the fable is “Satiety,” and Bacon says that the story is “an ingenious shadowing-out and description of pleasure” (XV). The mention of pleasure is puzzling in light of Memnon. The two fables seem to be a natural pair: the first on premature death, and the second on overextended life. The pair seems to point to a mean: the perfect proportion of life. But Tithonus, Bacon says strikingly, is not about overextended life simply; rather, it is about satiety with pleasures. Why does Bacon wish to connect his account of extended age with a discussion of the pitfalls of pleasure? What we see is that examining satiety with pleasure helps us to gain clarity on how to avoid satiety with longer lives.
To illustrate this insight, Bacon explains the stages of Tithonus's life of pleasures, and then surveys the decline. Bacon says that at the outset of an experience of pleasure, (particularly bodily pleasure), men find it so favorable that they make prayers that its enjoyments be theirs perpetually. They forget, however, that tedium comes with pleasures much like it comes with old age. In this light, the message seems to be that a life in perpetual pursuit of pleasure will get worse as it gets longer, and the fable looks like a cautionary tale against an extended life of hedonism.
Yet the message of the fable is made more complex by Jupiter's actions. When Jupiter takes pity on Tithonus and turns him into a cicada, Tithonus is no longer subject to the pitiable life of satiety in endless pleasures. Instead, he faces a new difficulty. Though he is without satiety of bodily pleasures, he is not without desires. “As Bacon says, when the actions of pleasure desert men, . . . the “passions and affection truly do not die.” Instead, like cicadas “whose only vigor is in their voices,” Tithonus resembles old men (especially lustful and martial old men) who entertain themselves with endless discourses on their deeds and exploits. When they cannot enjoy pleasures in action, they enjoy reflecting on past pleasures in speech. What is more, the desire to reflect on past pleasures in speech is insatiable.
The vigor of Tithonus's voice that Jupiter affords him as a cicada, and the insatiable desire to recollect in speech, point to a part of the human psyche that can prevent humans from becoming sated with extended life. Bacon makes this latter suggestion with two distinctive turns of phrase. First, he says that men who pursue infinite pleasure and follow the initial path of Tithonus do so “without their thinking,” as though “their thinking” is a part of themselves that they have lost sight of or abandoned.Footnote 24 The endless pursuit of pleasures suppresses the power of reason, effectively making humans little more than living bodies rather than embodied minds, and making life worse as it gets longer. When humans with longer lives pursue pleasures they ought to guard especially against losing their thinking parts.
Bacon indicates that one way for humans to keep their thinking as they extend life is to embrace what he terms the “vigor of the voice”—the second stand-out phrase that he crafts for his teaching on preventing satiety with life. When Bacon speaks of the vigor of the voice, he describes martial and lustful men who reflect back on their exploits. He suggests that these men have engaged a more vital part of themselves than do men who pursue the actions of bodily pleasures alone. For Bacon, the vigor of the voice represents what is truly vital in a human life: the high moments that we insatiably reflect upon because they make life worth living. To grasp the vital is to begin to distinguish between the ephemeral pleasures and the moments when we are truly alive. As Bacon argues in the Advancement of Learning, the pleasures that can be sated are, in fact, not true pleasures, and the one true pleasure, a pleasure that is insatiable, is knowledge.Footnote 25 Tithonus has begun to distinguish between the ephemeral and the true pleasures because he is acquiring self-knowledge.
Bacon does not indicate clearly one way or the other how far he thinks old men like Tithonus will engage their voices in high-minded reflections on the ultimate source of the vital and the ephemeral, or on true and false pleasures. And indeed, not all old men become philosophers.Footnote 26 Yet Bacon does suggest that the shift from the mad masters of the body to the delight of the voice permits reflection on the highest points of life, and this is a starting point for the new model of philosophy that Bacon will develop later. In the natural course of events as we have known it, in old age, when the body declines, human beings necessarily turn to the voice for solace. In a world that increasingly permits the extended life of the body and its attendant pleasures, however, humans may lose the natural impetus for turning to the voice that they now possess. Here, Bacon introduces the vigor of the voice as an essential part of correcting a world that will increasingly admit the actions of pleasure. Instead of ending Tithonus's life, Jupiter turns him away from the inconstantly sated body, toward the actions of an insatiable mind.
Jupiter's Gift of Perpetual Youth
Once Jupiter draws out Tithonus's voice, he goes on to grant another challenging gift: the gift of perpetual youth (XXVI). In this instance, perpetual youth paves the way for a new kind of hope, and new virtues. Jupiter gives the gift of perpetual youth in the fable “Prometheus; or the State of Man.” In this fable, we witness the familiar story of the rivalry between Jupiter and Prometheus. True to form, Prometheus steals fire from the heavens, grants human beings technological power, and suffers his classic torment with the eagle. Jupiter is a very different king from his classical counterpart, however. Whereas the classical Jupiter (i.e., Aeschylus's or Hesiod's Zeus) tries to annihilate the human race, and only rules by might, fear, and necessity, Bacon's Jupiter grants humans a far more powerful gift than their Promethean benefactor, and rules them by implanting hope in them for an even greater dispensation of human power. In this regard, Bacon's Jupiter is more Promethean than Prometheus. He also illustrates how far Bacon's vision of human charity extends.
Bacon begins his story by telling his reader that after they receive the gifts of fire and the arts from Prometheus, humans were ungrateful for the help. Jupiter, in turn, delights in human ingratitude and rewards them with perpetual youth. At first sight, Jupiter's pleasure at human ingratitude is puzzling—why would Jupiter be delighted by human ingratitude in the face of a benefactor?Footnote 27 One answer to this question is that Jupiter is pleased to see that he has not lost human loyalty to his rival. Since Prometheus competes with Jupiter for the love of humans, their loyalty indicates that he has not lost his power.
The gift of perpetual youth and the details that surround it, however, suggest that there is an additional reason for Jupiter's delight at human ingratitude toward Prometheus. Bacon suggests that Jupiter is pleased because he sees that their ingratitude will continue to generate new arts: it is only out of dissatisfaction with the arts that men are “perpetually stimulated to new industry and new discoveries.” By endorsing their dissatisfaction, Jupiter helps humans see the potential reward for ingratitude: power over their lifespans. Jupiter is able to retain human loyalty in the face of Prometheus because he tantalizes humans with the promise of greater autonomy over the length of their lives. Whereas Prometheus gives humans particular arts, Jupiter promises the advancement of technology.
In Bacon's depiction, once Jupiter witnesses the expansion of Promethean technology, he sees no other alternative than to develop it even further. In this regard, Bacon's Jupiter illustrates the broad reach of Baconian charity and, in fact, resembles Bacon himself. Baconian charity includes not only relief from natural necessity, but relief from the imminence of death. The age that Jupiter and Bacon usher in will give humans even greater command over nature and themselves than Prometheus had originally granted them.
The advancement that Jupiter initially promises, however, quickly comes to a halt when humans hand over the gift of perpetual youth to an ass. This change in the course of technological progress reveals to Jupiter a new set of challenges with which he must contend. Bacon says that the ass is representative of experience, which is slow, and which generates the complaint that “life is short, and art, long.” Instead of developing the gift of perpetual youth through the technical arts, humans turn to slow trial and error. In this light, Jupiter's gift appears to be a gift only in potentia: to use it, humans must work at it, and if they work with experience, not much will be accomplished in a short lifetime. In other words, the technological charity that comes through Jupiter requires that humans receive technology with a view of how to advance it.
As fast as humans give the gift to the ass of experience, moreover, the ass abandons it to a snake, which, Bacon says, is representative of experiments for profit or ostentation. The situation in which humans find themselves under Jupiter, then, is that they have the promise and potential to advance technology and to elongate life, but they slow their progress by turning from the technical arts to unorganized experience, and they halt it altogether by turning to profit and ostentation.
As humans begin to squander the potential power that they have from Jupiter, they reconcile themselves with Prometheus, and Prometheus expresses his malice to Jupiter by giving him a gift of false sacrifices. In response, Jupiter takes revenge on humans; for as Bacon says, “[Jupiter] could not reprimand the insolence of Prometheus unless by afflicting the race of man.” The punishment that Jupiter employs comes in the form of Pandora. Jupiter has Vulcan build a “beautiful and lusty woman, [with] whom each of the Gods would share their gifts.” In her hands, Jupiter had him place a vessel “in which all evils and hardships were included,” but “subsiding in the bottom of the vase . . . was hope.” According to Bacon, Pandora represents pleasures and lust, which are enflamed “after the civil arts and culture of life and luxury arises.” In other words, after humans reconcile themselves with Prometheus, and make a hasty return to the old arts, Jupiter appeals to them with gifts of pleasure. Because the pleasures come with evils, human indulgence in them effectively punishes Prometheus. By drawing humans out in this way, Jupiter compels humans and Prometheus to develop the qualities they need to receive his gifts once again.
Of course, true to form, when Prometheus himself is presented with Pandora, he rejects her. But (also true to form) his brother Epimetheus opens the box and unleashes new evils into the world. Only hope remains in the bottom. Bacon says that Prometheus and Epimetheus, in their respective responses, illustrate the “two conditions of human life.” Those who follow Epimetheus, on the one hand, lack foresight. They pursue only what is charming in the present, and for this they eventually meet with calamity. In the meantime, however, they soothe their wits and delight themselves with empty hopes. The followers of Prometheus, on the other hand, since they are “prudent and forward looking,” avoid many evils. Yet in so doing, they also deprive themselves of pleasures and they “torture and kill themselves with cares and solicitudes and intestinal fears.” The initial response to the evils and troubles that attend the development of the arts leave humans in either a deluded or tortured state. By placing humans in this condition alongside Prometheus and Epimetheus, Jupiter compels them to undertake two tasks: first, to convert empty hope into reasonable hope, and, second, to transform intestinal fears into a new kind of courage.
To understand how humans are to transform hope, it is useful to contrast Bacon's depiction of hope in Pandora's vessel with how it appears in two other places: earlier in the Prometheus fable itself and in the New Organon. First, in the fable itself, Jupiter and Bacon both give humans hope for developing the arts in general and for the extension of life in particular. Bacon says, for example, that the gift of perpetual youth shows that “the ancients did not despair of making modes and medicines for the retardation of aging and the prolongation of life,” but that “they were numbered among those things which—though once accepted—either perished or were frustrated by man's sloth or carelessness.”Footnote 28 The gift that Jupiter gives mankind, even though it is lost, gives men hope that the potential for extending youth remains available to them.
Bacon suggests, further, that both dissatisfaction with the arts and hope that work on them can lead to results are essential to their progress and development. In the New Organon, Bacon expands on the value of hope for advancing the sciences. There, he says that the greatest obstacle to scientific progress is the hopeless assumption that certain goals are impossible. Nonetheless, Bacon is not of the mind that all hope is to be valued—some hope is light, while other hope is sound. The kind of hope that is most valuable comes either from demonstration or from knowledge of past errors, and for Bacon, this kind of hope is not blind.Footnote 29
The hope that Jupiter offers humans highlights further how Bacon's story departs from the classical view. In the most famous classical version of the story, Aeschylus's Prometheus Bound, it is Prometheus who gives hope to humans, and he does so on two occasions.Footnote 30 First, Prometheus grants humans blind hope by allowing them to forget their forthcoming mortality. In becoming ignorant of the fatedness of death they are able to go on living. As a result, they continue to expand the arts. Prometheus also gives Io hope by telling her that eventually, someone in her bloodline (Herakles) will free Prometheus from the eagle. She opts to live, rather than to end her life, once she hears that she may be responsible for liberating the one who saves humankind from the wrath of Zeus (again, Herakles). Bacon and his Jupiter, in contrast, give humans hope by suggesting that their lives and power can be extended greatly. In the classical version, hope lies in being blind to the time of death, and in the prospect that one's progeny will help humankind; in Bacon's version, hope lies in challenging the necessity of death, and in expanding the future empire of humankind.
While hope fuels the project in general, its benefits can be undermined by both Epimethean afterthought and Promethean foresight. In the Promethean age, and under Bacon's Jupiter, this is the paradoxical state in which humans find themselves: if they lack foresight, their hope is allied blindly with the desire to continue to gratify the flow of pleasures that come from the arts; if they have foresight, they are plagued by perpetual fears of what may come as they are freed from necessity. Both hope and fear require transformation.
Hercules, who represents courage, makes possible the transformation of Promethean fear. Hercules arrives near the end of the fable to rescue Prometheus from the eagle. According to Bacon, Herculean courage “prepares for all events and is equal to any sort of thing, foresees without fears, is fruitful without fastidiousness, and tolerates without impatience.” Surprisingly, Bacon says that Herculean courage is necessarily imported from without: “no inborn or natural courage can be suitable for so great a thing.” Instead, Herculean courage comes from “the ends of the ocean and from the sun,” or, in Bacon's gloss, it comes from “meditation on the inconstancy, and, as it were, the waves of human life” and from knowing the causes of things. Bacon here suggests (with his fitting allusions to Plato's waves and sun), that the new kind of courage humans need is more like philosophical courage than a dogmatic or dyed-in-the-wool steadfastness.Footnote 31 It is a courage coupled with knowledge about the nature of change, and it amounts to an ability to use reason to summon strength of soul in the face of a continuous flow of new fearful things.
In Plato's Republic and his Apology, Socrates presents courage as strength of soul in the face of fearful things, and one of the original candidates for the most fearful thing is death. Philosophical courage, in turn, is depicted as knowledge of what is truly fearful, and death is not necessarily the most fearful thing.Footnote 32 Like Socrates, Bacon introduces the possibility that the most fearful thing may not be death, but he also presents us with a new variation: the most fearful thing may be to live a life that gets worse as it gets longer. Herculean courage is therefore needed to respond to the unforeseen consequences of expanding human power, and to remain philosophically reflective as humans continually face the challenge of discerning what makes their changing lives worth living.
The story of Jupiter's gift and Prometheus's response, then, shows that for Bacon, the promise of extended life and the charity of extended technological power demand leadership over technology, reasonable hope, and a new variant of philosophical courage. Jupiter encourages the development of technology by promoting dissatisfaction with the arts and planting hope for the extension of life. He also compels Prometheus to respond to the pitfalls in the development of technology. With the help of Hercules, Promethean courage allows humans to find constancy as they come upon new fearful things.
Orpheus's Philosophic Return
While Bacon has Jupiter set the stage for the hyper-Promethean condition, he also illustrates that this condition inspires a new portrait of philosophy. In the eleventh fable of the book, “Orpheus,” Bacon suggests that past philosophy has failed to address satisfactorily the longing for immortality, and that it ought to return to the technical task of extending life (XI). Once life extension happens, Bacon suggests further, philosophy is compelled to redirect some of its energies to understanding what makes longer life worth living. Instead of describing a philosophy that reflects on the necessity of mortality, Bacon depicts a philosophy that is moved to sing songs to capture what is lofty and divine against the distractions of technological affluence.
In Bacon's version of Orpheus's story, Orpheus's wife dies prematurely and Orpheus goes down to the underworld to try to convince the Furies to restore her to life. They agree to do this under the condition that Orpheus not look back until the two return to earth. At the last minute, however, Orpheus becomes impatient, looks back, and his wife tumbles back to the underworld. For a time, Orpheus plays his lyre mournfully, which has the effect of bringing beasts, stones, and trees into accord with one another. Then Bacchus blows a horn, which arouses a group of Thracian women and their noise suppresses Orpheus's songs. The beasts return to their original natures, and Orpheus himself is torn to pieces. His head disappears underground in the river Helicon only to reappear later.
One of the notable features of the fable is that when Bacon describes philosophy, he says that it sings two songs, and suggests that one song follows from the other. Orpheus sings his second song (for harmonizing beasts) in response to his failure with the first. These two songs represent the two branches of philosophy: natural philosophy and moral philosophy. Bacon does not wish to sever natural philosophy (what we call science) from moral philosophy. The two are distinct, but essentially related: natural philosophy inspires the thoughts and actions of moral philosophy.
Another conspicuous feature of the fable is that Orpheus, Bacon's representative of philosophy, is depicted as a failure at natural philosophy. Understanding this failure is the first step toward understanding the new portrait of philosophy that Bacon envisions. Natural philosophy, Bacon says strikingly, takes the regeneration of bodies as its noblest work. Hence, original Orphic philosophy has failed at restoring life. For Bacon, this failure is of profound significance. As we recall, for Bacon the desire for immortality or continuance is the most powerful human longing.Footnote 33 To say that philosophy has failed at restoring life is to say that it has turned away from a potential means of satisfying humans' deepest hopes.
Since Orpheus fails with his first song, he turns to his second song, which harmonizes natures and which, Bacon explains, represents civil philosophy. Accordingly, Bacon says that care for civil things follows after the frustration of experiments for the restoration of mortal bodies. Bacon suggests that here, too, philosophy finds itself in error. First, he claims that the turn from natural philosophy to civil philosophy is hasty: when Orpheus turns back to look at his wife, Bacon says it is “very like the truth,” that natural philosophy fails to achieve its effect “not more from any cause than from curious and untimely busy-ness and impatience.”Footnote 34 Philosophy's problem is rushed curiosity to see the potential extent of its power. As Bacon argues in the History of Life and Death, there is no reason in principle that natural philosophy fails at restoring life.Footnote 35 With moderation and due diligence, natural philosophy may go further in achieving its goal.
Second, Bacon suggests that the turn to civil philosophy ought to be considered not as a turn to a superior form of philosophic understanding, but as a compromised alternative in the battle against mortality. Bacon suggests that Orpheus's motivation for turning to civil philosophy is to seek immortality, by “merit and name.” In this light, philosophy has tried to compensate for the failure to restore life with the promise of immortal fame. Far from the equanimity of Socrates in the face of death, Orpheus has not come to terms with mortality. For Bacon, philosophy ought to acknowledge that it actually desires fame only if it cannot find an alternative way of satisfying the desire for immortality or continuance, and that the turn to fame is only the result of an overhasty assessment that it is impossible to restore life.
In depicting philosophy in this light, Bacon suggests that Orpheus must reconsider both the potential for natural philosophy to extend life, and the longing to resist death that is present in the compromising attempt to overcome it through immortal fame. In so doing, he also presents a departure in his vision of philosophy from classical philosophy. Unlike classical natural philosophy, which is generally dedicated to the observation of nature rather than the alteration of it, Baconian natural philosophy is dedicated to the project of slowing mortal decay. Furthermore, Bacon departs from the classical depiction of the turn from natural philosophy to moral or civil philosophy: the Socratic turn.Footnote 36 Unlike Socrates, who, in the Phaedo, explains that his turn to human things was motivated by the realization that natural philosophy would not provide insights into the human good, Bacon depicts the turn to civil philosophy as the result of a frustrated, and potentially hasty, conclusion that mortal decay is unalterable.Footnote 37 Whereas Socrates leads his listeners to human dialogue for philosophical insight, Bacon encourages his readers to revisit the turn away from natural philosophy to ascertain whether its abandonment was premature. As the new Baconian natural philosophy succeeds at life extension, it opens the way for philosophical alternatives to sorrow and the pursuit of posthumous fame in the face of mortality.
In the fables that follow “Orpheus” Bacon returns to the subject of natural origins, and illustrates the prospects for manipulating matter, thereby offering a starting point for reconsidering natural philosophy's restorative potential (XII and XIII). Later in the text, he also offers an account of some of the main challenges to material restoration more generally, and suggests that it is possible if we understand it differently (XXI). And near the end of the book, he says that the restoration of natural bodies is not to be despaired of; it is simply “abstruse and… out of the way” (XIX). The alchemists have failed to find the philosopher's stone, Bacon says, because their “theory is without foundation.” But their goal is not impossible.
In both this last statement, on the prospect of restoring bodies, and in his later works, Bacon seems to entertain the possibility not just of extended life, but also of immortality. For example, in his History of Life and Death, he writes, “whatever can be repaired gradually without destroying the original whole is, like the vestal fire, potentially eternal.”Footnote 38 By planting a seed of hope that inspires natural philosophy to return to the task of restoring and extending life, Bacon effectively kindles hope that physical life extension will stretch toward physical immortality. To the extent that Bacon is entertaining the possibility of physical immortality, his philosophy is challenged with asking not only “how do we live well as life gets longer?” but also, “what activities would we happily do forever?” His Orpheus at the close of the book offers us a glimpse of how he begins to answer the latter question.
As I have discussed above, however, Bacon's focus in both the Wisdom of the Ancients and the History of Life and Death lies primarily in the prospect of life extension rather than in the prospect of immortality.Footnote 39 In this sense, the new philosophy that Bacon proposes still faces eventual death, and the classical tradition remains a resource for contemplating mortality. At the same time, Bacon emphasizes that with extended life, philosophy will be compelled to attend to the increasing amount of time that humans live, and to discover what makes longer life worth living. As “Prometheus” and “Tithonus” show, technological affluence, by luring humans to a host of new pleasures, can lead them away from the activities essential to a good life. As death moves farther from immediate view, humans lose some of the urgency for asking what kinds of activities are worth doing. Philosophy can recover this urgency by exposing the pitfalls of pursuing endless pleasures. And it can help point humans toward true flourishing by asking what activities make life worth living for longer and longer stretches of time. In this regard, Bacon's philosophy shifts from a focus on learning how to die, to a focus on learning how one lives well with the hazards of affluence and the gift of an increasingly extended lifespan. In short, Bacon's philosophy focuses on the art of living well as new sources of pleasure flood into the world and death recedes from immediate view.
The new natural philosophy that embraces the project of extending life, and the accompanying moral philosophy that guides longer life, are not on display immediately after Orpheus's initial appearance, however. Bacon says that after the Thracian women tear Orpheus apart, his head is left in the river Helicon only to come up at a later time (XI). In the meantime, Bacon shows that the world is wrestling with additional challenges that emerge with technological affluence, including the envy and moral vices characteristic of some types of scientists (XIX), the urge to falsify imperfect sciences (XX), the distractions of profit (XXV and XXVI), and, in “Prometheus,” the hazards of pleasures (XXVI). As the fables unfold and Jupiter shapes the political morality surrounding extended life, we are left wondering how philosophy will respond to the changes that Jupiter and Prometheus bring into the world.
After Bacon displays a series of new human trials in his world, Orpheus resurfaces in the final fable of the book where he is restored to life (XXXI). In the time he has been away from the action of the fables, he has been transformed from a melancholy to a joyful singer. Orpheus now faces the new world—the world of pleasures and scientific trials—with delight. What gives him his new joy? Upon examination, his songs represent Bacon's model of a moral philosophy that advances human flourishing against the hazards of the new world.
Orpheus appears in the context of the fable “Sirens.” The subtitle of the fable is “Pleasures,” and hence the final fable returns to a theme central to the book: that the primary challenges of living in the world of ever-longer life are the pitfalls of indulging in the ever-new flow of pleasures. Bacon suggests here not only that novel pleasures are dangerous, but also that pleasures are increasingly tailored to appeal to different natures (XIX). Constant vigilance is necessary. In “Sirens,” therefore, Bacon displays a series of remedies for continually resisting the calls of the Sirens (which are themselves representative of pleasures), and says that Orpheus's harmonious singing is “the most outstanding class” of the remedies (XXXI).Footnote 40 What is the power of Orpheus's songs?
In explaining the remedies to the Sirens, Bacon argues that Orpheus's songs have a particular power to overwhelm the Sirens' voices because they draw their power from the Muses. Bacon says that just as the Muses pluck the wings of the Sirens to take away their power, philosophy has the power to elevate the soul above the Sirens' earthy realm (XXXI). Whereas previously, the human soul was stuck to the soil, with philosophy, the thoughts of men are winged. Orpheus has access to elevating insight. In the pleasure-filled world of Baconian technology, one task of philosophy is to elevate the soul above earthy, ephemeral things.
Bacon's distinction between the lofty and ethereal, on the one hand, and the low and earthy, on the other, seems to be in keeping with his broader description of nature as a whole as possessing a biform structure. In the human realm, this structure generates a normative ranking between the high and the low. He describes this in “Pan, or Nature,” where he explains that there are parts of nature connected to beauty, equability, and constancy of motion, and parts full of perturbations and inconstant motions (VI). Hence, Orpheus's songs are not merely about what is airy as opposed to what is earthy; they suggest that the human psyche has the ability to distinguish what is naturally high from what is naturally low.Footnote 41
In this regard, the song of Orpheus resembles Tithonus's voice. Like Tithonus, who activates the vigor of the voice over the pleasure-seeking body, Orpheus's songs contain harmonies that help orient life within a pleasure-filled cacophonous world. Bacon suggests that Orpheus's songs have gone further to access the source of human elevation. Whereas Tithonus stumbles into the vigor of the voice by reflecting on past experiences, Orpheus has accessed the source harmonies of the Muses, and in so doing, is able to distinguish between the false charms of the Sirens and the delights of cosmological order—which are centered around understanding the natural basis for the high and the low.
For Bacon, one sign that an activity is of a higher sort is that we do not get sated with it. Tithonus, as we have learned, enjoys exercising the vigor in his voice insatiably (XIII). Orpheus, too, seems to be inclined to sing continually and above all other activities. As Bacon says of Orpheus at the close of the book, Orpheus's songs “surpass the pleasures of the sense not merely in power, but even in charm” (XXXI). In the Advancement of Learning, Bacon says, “of knowledge there is no satiety, but satisfaction and appetite are perpetually interchangeable; and therefore appeareth to be good in itself simply, without fallacy or accident.”Footnote 42 Philosophy and its dialogical precursor (represented by Tithonus) have discovered the songs, ideas, and memories that delight us endlessly, and therefore appear to be good simply. Because of its characteristic insatiability, Bacon's model of philosophy can adapt to a lifespan that gets ever longer.
Additionally, Bacon says, Orpheus meditates on “divine things” (XXXI). Bacon does not go into great detail regarding the nature of Orpheus's divine meditations, and interpreting his statement in this regard is perhaps one of the most difficult challenges of the book.Footnote 43 The reading that I find most compelling is that Orpheus's harmonies reflect a cosmological order that he can behold after natural philosophy has begun to grasp the structure of the world and the place of humans in it. Philosophy, Bacon says in the Essays, often leads to ideas that typically concern religion: “for while the mind of man looketh upon second causes scattered, it may sometimes rest in them, and go no further; but when it beholdeth the chain of them, confederate and linked together, it must needs fly to Providence and Deity.”Footnote 44 Deep reflections on the causes of observable things, according to Bacon, inspire us to sing philosophic or religious songs about divine order. The divine meditations that Orpheus undertakes, then, appear to represent philosophical insight into the cosmological order that he can see or hear through the flux of the world he beholds.
Though Bacon's direct description of these songs is limited, he gives us a view of what they look like by his own example. Bacon is doing the very thing that he describes Orpheus to be doing: singing philosophical songs of divine things. He does so in two ways: in the sense that his subject matter is divine—the gods of the ancients; and in the sense that his myths open the way for insight into the cosmological order that his fables disclose.
Though his songs range from lessons on technical science to political policy to the sources of the sublime, they allow us to consider the flux of a changing world, and ultimately reveal some of Bacon's deepest insights into the categories and ideas that allow humans to distinguish between the high and the low, the sublime and the base—whether in politics, nature, metaphysics, or human life. They present us with puzzling appearances of things, and then they offer us an interpretive commentary, which we turn to, to understand the meaning of the fable. We work through them dialectically to understand the coherence and order of the insight that Bacon wishes to convey in them. Broadly speaking, Bacon, something of a poet-philosopher, uses the fables to present his reconfigured world.
In his final remarks, Bacon likens the Wisdom of the Ancients to grapes that are ill-trodden. It is our job to squeeze the wisdom out of them (XXXI). We squeeze them, and in doing so, draw out the dynamic harmonies they convey. Like Orpheus's songs, they take us from the distractions of appearances to insight into the higher order that makes our lives, especially our longer lives, worth living. Here, I have focused on the songs that guide us through the illusions of pleasures and fears in the world of life extension. Dialectically, we arrive at the vigor of the voice in “Tithonus,” informed hope and foresightful courage in “Prometheus,” and the cosmological harmony beneath the delights of philosophy in “Orpheus.” Generally, as we work through the shifting appearances of Bacon's fables, we can access categories, concepts, and judgments that guide human flourishing as technology expands the sources of corruption and the length of our lives. Bacon's philosophic songs take us from the flux of human change to questions about the greater cosmological harmonies beneath our highest experiences.
Conclusions
The teaching on life extension that appears in the Wisdom of the Ancients helps us to see the far-reaching political and philosophical vision that Bacon offers humanity. His political leadership is concerned not merely with the challenge of acquiring technological power, but also with advancing the moral framework for human flourishing once humans begin to alter the arc of the human lifespan. Longer life permits leaders to reconstitute the way political communities understand the prime of life, and Bacon suggests that the prime of life may best be dedicated to the charitable project of expanding human power over nature.
By exploring his Wisdom of the Ancients, we can see that Bacon sees the need to develop new variations on our classical inheritance—variations in our conceptions of virtue, hope, and the activities at which human life ought to be aimed. He also presents a vision of philosophy that contrasts with the classical tradition as he inherited it. First, he sees the need to reconsider the previous view of the limitations of natural philosophy with respect to mortality, and claims that natural philosophy ought to consider continuance of life as a primary goal. Second, he reasserts the intimate connection between natural philosophy and moral philosophy—scientific discoveries present philosophy with new questions, especially in the human realm. As natural philosophy permits extended life, philosophy suspends the question, “how ought we live when we only live for a time?” and instead asks, “how do we live well with longer lives?” Bacon's answer to this question is that we should be careful not to allow ourselves to be lured in by the ever-new flow of pleasures that technological affluence will bring. By the end of the text, Bacon goes on to show that when humans begin to distinguish the lofty from the low within the flux of their changing lives, they begin to access the harmony of his elevating songs. As they do so, they find the charms of philosophy insatiable. Bacon's philosophy reveals what we can delight in perpetually against the backdrop of technological change.
