This review is the continuation of one published in the previous volume of this journalFootnote 1 devoted to the first volume of the series covering the results of the Rurland project under the direction of Prof. M. Reddé.Footnote 2 The purpose of the present book is rather different from the earlier one, since its aim is to provide an interpretative synthesis of the huge amount of data gathered by the members of the project. This change is reflected in the structure of the second volume. While the previous one was articulated in chapters describing the data from each area covered by the project, the present book adopts a thematic structure. Each chapter approaches a specific topic that is discussed (with some minor exceptions) by concentrating on a unified area similar to the extent of the northern provinces of Roman Gaul, Germania Superior and Inferior, and part of the Raetia province.Footnote 3
This unified geographical structure generates internal consistency across the volume. Its coherence is greatly reinforced by various editorial decisions, such as the selection of small subchapters or case studies that (as in the previous volume) are inserted at the end of most chapters. Additionally, the editor has introduced reflections (e.g. 144–45) and even complete chapters (chap. 9) to reinforce important ideas across the volume. These strategic additions help to balance the internal differences between the authors of different chapters.
Despite these efforts to achieve coherence across the volume, the truth is that we may consider this book as a choral piece that allows us easily to identify diverse scholarly positions and nuances (sometimes contradictory) from each author. Given the richness of topics and approaches, this review follows the same configuration as the book, to draw out the differences in emphasis that emerge from each of the chapters in the collection.
Introductory chapters
The book opens with a general introduction by M. Reddé, N. Bernigaud, and V. Zech-Matterne. This chapter starts with a summary of the essential achievements of the first volume, which allows the key issues discussed in the subsequent chapters to be highlighted. Three main issues are particularly noteworthy. The first concerns the diachronic analysis of rural settlement and economic development between the Late Iron AgeFootnote 4 and Late Antiquity. This diachronic concern is directly reflected in the book's structure, with individual chapters treating specific chronological periods. A second point is related to the hidden importance of smallholders or peasant communities in the configuration of Roman rural settlement in these sectors of the Empire (11–12).Footnote 5 This issue is directly related to the problem of the actual spread of the villa as the essential element for economic development in the Roman countryside of northern Gaul, as part of what P. Leveau has called “agrarian Romanization.”Footnote 6 This concern is rightly connected with the ambiguity of the archaeological and economic definition of the Roman villa beyond the Carandinian model.Footnote 7 I will probe this point more deeply in my comments on chapter 3.
Another key discussion introduced in this chapter is the concept of “agricultural system” (whose definition is analyzed in depth in the second part of the book) and how this can be documented archaeologically, mainly by analysis of agricultural facilities and tools and the use of archaeobiological approaches (24–27). The chapter is completed by an evaluation of the different sources of archaeological evidence employed to produce this synthesis, including aerial photography, archaeological surveys, remote sensing techniques, and, most extensively, data from preventive archaeology.Footnote 8 The limitations of this last type of data are explicitly shown by a map (chap. 1, fig. 4), in which we can clearly appreciate how the majority of preventive interventions in French territory analyzed in the framework of the Rurland project are placed around current urban cores or in its related transportation networks.Footnote 9 The sampling bias of this kind of data is also increased by the different criteria employed in the recording procedures for all these interventions that several national and administrative bodies employ. However, even assuming these limitations, the exploitation of archaeological datasets from preventive interventions offers a truly random configuration of the sample analyzed in this project, setting it free from previous scholarly and academic biases.
The introduction is followed by a long chapter on the environmental conditions in which the rural exploitation of northern Gaul was developed.Footnote 10 This chapter can be considered an authentic essay on the physical geography of the project's area, which discusses several aspects related to the geology, orography, hydrography, and climatology of the regions covered in the volume. All these sections offer a very detailed portrait of the different environmental factors that had an influence on the historical configuration of the local landscapes during the periods analyzed.
Especially relevant in this chapter is the analysis of the pedological composition of the soils in the study area (34–60).Footnote 11 This point will be essential in many successive chapters, especially those that discuss the relationship between the different types of soils or substrates and the rural settlement structure, types of enclosures, and fertilizing practices of the different regions (195–206, 386–91, 403–8). In this regard, most of the chapters make extensive use of the data from the Copernicus Land Monitoring Service and the European Soil Data Centre with subtle cartographical differences between some chapters (see chap. 1, figs. 5, 7, 8, 10; chap. 2, fig. 44a–b) that are difficult to explain.Footnote 12 Similar applications of modern databases on soil agrarian potentiality in archaeology have received criticism from multiple authors in the past, mostly focused on the disruptions produced by the anthropic action in recent centuries.Footnote 13 This is especially relevant for some of the regions studied, such as the Low Countries or the industrial regions of the Rhine Valley, where intense urbanization in the last two centuries has dramatically changed the landscape in many ways. But another methodological concern must be taken into account: namely, the scale of comparison. While the available data of soil composition are consistent both at regional and local scale, the data about rural settlement composition are limited by the aforementioned sampling bias. This divergence in both types of dataset makes a truly reliable large-scale comparison impossible. Given the current data on rural settlement patterns at our disposal, we should limit these types of comparisons to a micro-regional level in order to improve the consistency of the patterns documented, as in the first case study of this chapter on the Basse-Seine region (45–48). The results obtained from this case study (based on a comparison of up to 232 rural sites documented by archaeological survey) show an interesting settlement pattern in which large estates are concentrated in areas with lower agrarian potential, while the smaller farmsteads are mainly settled on better agricultural soils. The documentation of the same pattern in previous studies could be interpreted as indication that the wealthier villae, rather than forming great agricultural exploitations themselves, in fact acted as redistributive nodes in charge of the management of the agrarian production of the surrounding dependent farms.Footnote 14
Rural settlements
The next three chapters cover the characteristics, evolution, and dissemination of the several types of rural sites in this part of Roman Gaul. The structure is strictly chronological. From a methodological point of view, all these chapters have a purely typological orientation, mostly discussing the shape, construction techniques, and internal spatial distribution of the settlements and, to a lesser extent, the specific functions of the architectural features recorded at each site.
The first chapter, by S. Fichtl, is devoted to the analysis of the rural settlements during the late La Tène period.Footnote 15 As R. Agache established in his pioneering studies, enclosures are the main archaeological indicators of the nature of the rural habitats in northern Gaul.Footnote 16 Following a similar model, Fichtl offer us a typological synthesis based on the shape of the enclosures documented in the area of study. His proposal includes three basic types: simple, with internal partition, and multiple, in turn subdivided into several geometric forms (all illustrated in several figures: chap. 3, figs. 2–6). This trend to create general morphological classifications, present in many parts of the book, makes me reflect on the utility of these criteria. The application of geometrical labels such as “rectangular,” “trapezoidal,” or “mixed” is a simple but very effective way to classify habitats; nevertheless, were there real functional, social, or cultural factors that underlay these different formal variants? I wonder if in some cases it is more a question of adapting to the local topography. Similar concerns arise over the use of internal compartmentalization as a criterion for site classification. Is there a relationship between the kind of internal divisions recorded in these enclosures and the spatial distribution of functions or activities performed within them? If so, does this mean that simple enclosures have no internal distribution of functions or activities? To pursue these questions further, we should compare the compartmentalization of these enclosures with the in-site finds distribution to try to define activity areas. Another typological problem raised by this morphological principle for classifying enclosures lies in my suspicion that some of these categories may be concealing a sequence of successive occupations. In the case of formal variants such as trapézoïdal à partition interne, quadrangulaires emboités, and quadrangulaires accolés (chap. 2, fig. 2), I wonder how many of these sites were designed in this way ex novo and how many could be the result of extensions across time. As a Roman archaeologist interested in the study of domestic architecture, I think that this traditional focus on morphology can, in many cases, eclipse the diversity of functional situations and inhabitation sequences that each settlement could have, even where they present very similar shapes.Footnote 17
A very interesting part of this chapter is the discussion on the spatial distribution of rural settlements in specific territories (104–10). I found especially relevant the assessment of the sites at Object'Ifs sud (Caen) and Brebières (Pas de Calais), where preventive archaeology allowed the extensive excavation of all the structures of the two complexes. At Object'Ifs sud, excavations documented one aristocratic dwelling and several smaller enclosures associated with a quadrangular parcellation involving parallel paths clearly aligned with field limits (105, fig. 14). At Brebières, the excavation of an area of approximately 60 hectares recorded long-term occupation of the site from the Late Iron Age (La Tène C) to the Roman period, including the documentation of 120 buildings and 122 pits. In addition to documentation of a parcellation with several enclosures on the same orientation (confirming the existence of regular parcels in pre-Roman times), excavations at these sites have recorded a habitation sequence composed of several enclosures distributed across the site during the La Tène C, C/D, and D periods, which was completely replaced by a single larger enclosure during the Roman period (interpreted by Fichtl as the result of a process of hyper-centralization (108)). These examples show the existence of some degree of social inequality within the rural communities of the pre-Roman period. These sequences, along with the rise of aristocratic sites such as Les Pierrières (Loiret) (chap. 2, fig. 25), clearly demonstrate the social complexity of rural communities during the late La Tène period.
A final interesting question raised in this chapter relates to the internal organization of some of these aristocratic sites such as Les Pierrières, where we can envisage a true hierarchy of spaces with a residential part clearly distinguishable from the more rustic sectors (chap. 2, fig. 27). This internal organization could be interpreted as an indication that the traditional Catonian model of the villa (composed of a pars urbana spatially segregated from the pars rustica) was not exclusively a Roman innovation, and could have been present in rural settlement traditions of the Iron Age.
The next chapter of this block, by A. Nüsselin and N. Berningaud, is devoted to early Imperial rural habitats and settlement. Given its length (100 pages), it can be considered as one of the most important contributions to the volume. The authors begin with an explicit renunciation of treating the productive installations in the sites sampled (133).Footnote 18 This constitutes a fundamental difference from the other two chapters in the section, which include detailed treatments of this issue.
A central point in this chapter is the dichotomy between the ferme (farm) and the villa. The latter is considered by the authors as the key element for understanding Roman rural settlement in this region. The chapter's general approach, which can be considered as villa-focused, is revealed by the space devoted to these types of rural site.Footnote 19 Essentially, Nüsselin and Berningaud conceive the evolution of the Roman countryside in this area as a transition between the Gaulish ferme and the Roman villa (166–168). To justify this transition, they allude to traditional arguments such as the introduction of stone-based architectureFootnote 20 as an innovative characteristic of the Roman period, or the internal hierarchy of rural habitats according to the canonical pattern of the three partes (urbana, rustica, and frumentaria), which isolated residential from agricultural activity areas.Footnote 21 This general approach is pertinently nuanced by M. Reddé with an incisive point about the importance of farms and enclosures in the rural settlement of Roman Britain on the basis of the new data published in the framework of the New visions of the countryside of Roman Britain project, where the quantitative importance of other more humble rural (non-villa) sites is widely attested in all periods of Roman Britain.Footnote 22 I agree with Reddé in the importance of highlighting how the absence of reliable statistics on this type of farm site in France (as in most European countries) impedes us from having a really accurate view of the settlement patterns in the countryside of most provincial areas of the Roman Empire.Footnote 23
The rest of the chapter, following the morphological focus also found in the preceding chapter, produces a typological synthesis of the villa sites documented in northern Gaul. The classification proposed comprises three main typologies based on the orientation of internal structures of the villae: “axial-longitudinal,” “axial-transversal,” and “non-axial” (chap. 3, fig. 17). Although the first two categories are well defined, the last is equivalent to a kind of catch-all category, gathering together a range of very different examples. The authors develop an interesting analysis on the basis of this classification. They perform a correspondence analysis (CA) on a sample of 25 extensively excavated villae belonging to some of the three categories, comparing two other variables: the area of the excavated buildings in each villa and the minimum surface area of each site.Footnote 24 This analysis results in the recognition of some hidden patterns that cluster each type within a well-defined size range in all these villae. These patterns reveal a relationship between the form and orientation of the villae and the social inequality of the communities underlying the differences in size of these settlements. This interesting analysis could have been even more revealing if the authors had included the chronology of the sites as another variable for comparison. By doing this, they might have been able to infer hidden diachronic patterns.
Another interesting pattern inferred by Nüsselin and Berningaud relates to the regional distribution of the three main types of villae. Whereas the “axial-longitudinal” and “non-axial” types were spread across most parts of the project's area, the “axial-transversal” type is exclusively concentrated in a reduced territory limited to the interior of the Netherlands and the Ardennes. (The reasons for this concentration are not discussed.)
A substantial part of the chapter is devoted to the analysis of the diachronic sequence of many of these settlements through a comparison of the plans of each site in various phases of occupation (168–81). This method of illustrating the occupation sequence of the sites analyzed requires the synthesis of a huge quantity of information on the architectural configuration of a large number of sites across the territory. There is not enough space here to discuss in detail the main patterns inferred from this micro-regional approach. However, some brief comments are in order. The first concerns the composition of the sample. At the beginning of this section, its author (Bernigaud) indicates that 4 basic types of sequences were recorded: La Tène farms that disappear after the conquest; La Tène farms that continued without notable modifications; La Tène farms that evolved into villae; and villae created ex novo. This classification reflects the influence of the traditional model that identifies farms as pre-Roman settlements and villae as the result of the Romanization process. But were no Roman farms created ex novo in northern Gaul? Similarly, some of the architectural features usually adduced to describe the villa model (e.g. the axial model or the spatial segregation of activities and functions in different parts) were also present in some late La Tène sites such as Les Perrières (chap. 2, fig. 25). These similarities, previously noted by authors such as Habermehl, reveal the existence of a clear link between some late La Tène sites and the villae of the axial-longitudinal type.Footnote 25
In addition, attending to purely constructive criteria, there are some examples sampled that can hardly be considered canonical villae. This is the case with sites such as Rue F. Villon, Les Mottelettes, Le Bois du Canada (chap. 3, fig. 25), La Foulerie (fig. 27), Zac de Tulipes, Les Trois Mares (fig. 28), and Zac de Collines (fig. 30). Based on this evidence, I do not agree with the conclusion that the countryside of these northern provinces underwent a process of “agrarian Romanization” based on the spread of the Catonian concept of villae. Despite the villa-focused sample included in this part of the chapter, there were many other forms of rural settlement equally or significantly present in several of the territories analyzed by the Rurland project. As the authors rightly remark in the chapter's conclusion, almost until the end of the 2nd or 3rd c. CE, a larger part of the agricultural productive force in northern Gaul was in the hands of peasants or smallholders.
This block closes with a chapter by M. Kasprzyk, on rural settlements of the diocesis Galliarum during the Late Roman Empire. Kasprzyk insightfully pinpoints the fundamental problem that any synthesis on this later period must face: namely, the traditional villa-focused orientation of the study of the Late Roman rural world in continental Europe. Most of the previous scholarship has been exclusively focused on the so-called “end of the villae” problem.Footnote 26 The analysis of these sites on the basis of the exclusive classification of plan morphologies has certainly created some distortions. However, an approach based on the taphonomic analysis (239–40) of the sites, as proposed by Kasprzyk, reveals a more nuanced panorama. In many cases, the Late Antique reoccupation of these villae is clearly documented by several types of architectural features (e.g., pits, hearths, soil backgrounds).Footnote 27 The example of sites such as Mosenay (Seine et Marne; 239, fig. 3), where we can distinguish a non-monumental Late Roman habitat totally different from the previous peristyle villa, is used to illustrate this distortion. However, behind these apparently superficial classification problems lies a broader issue. Some authors have considered these different habitats as the mere product of “squatter” occupations.Footnote 28 In fact, these types of labels reveal prejudicial underlying categories of analysis mainly based on architectural or aesthetic criteria. We should avoid such generalizing topoi and perform specific analysis of the archaeological record from these sites, case by case, to define different forms of habitat included in the long-term occupation sequence of these Imperial villae.Footnote 29 The rest of the chapter comprises a highly detailed typological synthesis of all the types of buildings documented in these rural settlements, from aristocratic residences to the humbler Germanic-fashion pit houses that proliferated in this period, including an interesting review of the features related to productive activities (269–81).Footnote 30 The chapter concludes with an exhaustive table condensing all the architectural characteristics from all building environments mentioned in the text.
Agrarian systems
The second part of the book is devoted to a discussion of some structural elements that characterized the agrarian economies in northern Gaul. A first chapter, by M. Reddé, discusses the agrarian models and practices recorded in the classical sources (both textual and iconographic). This chapter confronts a key question approached by Reddé in several previous works: the existence of different economic models of agrarian management of Roman rural settlements beyond the Catonian villa.Footnote 31 Despite the fact that many influential scholars from continental Europe have considered the ideal model of the villa as the essential core of the agrarian economy of the Roman world,Footnote 32 the truth is that there are many discrepancies between the archaeological concept of villa developed since the 1980s and many patterns of economic performance described by the Roman agronomists.Footnote 33 Trying to solve this dilemma, Reddé's proposal is based on a reinterpretation of these and other classical sources from an economic perspective. The fundamental contribution of his chapter is related to the need to avoid the generalized application of some previous assumptions. The economic analysis of some passages of the Younger Pliny (Ep. 3.19) and a number of inscriptions (CIL 9.1455; CIL 6.33840) allows Reddé to dismantle previous assumptions on the relationship between the size or monumentality of the villae and the size or productivity of their respective fundi.Footnote 34
Contrary to this ideal model of the Catonian villa, a reinterpretation of some well-known figures from the agronomists (e.g. Cato, Agr. 56; Varro, Rust. 1.44; Pliny, NH 18.64) allows Reddé to propose a peasant economic model (sensu Chayanov).Footnote 35 The economic performance of a large part of the Roman rural settlements included in the volume could be approached by an analysis based on this peasant model of the family farmstead (321–23), and it is a pity that this approach was not taken up in any of the three previous chapters of this volume.
The next chapter of this block, by S. Lepetz and V. Zech-Matterne, can be considered as one of the most relevant of the entire volume.Footnote 36 It provides a synthesis of all the archaeobiological evidence related to those regions of France analyzed by the Rurland project.Footnote 37 Their proposal for the analysis of the agrarian systems that characterized this part of Gaul from the Late Iron Age to the Roman period is articulated around three main themes. The first is an analysis of the main vegetables and animals exploited. The second provides a cartography of agricultural production by mapping the spatial distribution of crops and husbandry practices. The third is a diachronic study of agriculture in the region.
To approach the first of these themes, the authors apply successive CAs with different ranges of two variables.Footnote 38 In the case of the faunal remains, 4 species are sampled (pigs, sheep/goats, cattle, and horses) in relation to the volume of finds recorded in several regions of France. In the case of crops, the authors sampled carpological series of 18 different taxa proceeding from sites with almost 100 finds of each species. All the CA was carried out with reference to three chronological ranges: from the Late Iron Age to the Augustan period; the Early Roman Empire; and Late Antiquity. The regional patterns recorded are best summarized in a figure (chap. 6, fig. 13), which allows us to observe certain specialization or regional complementarity in the production of different cereals. In the case of husbandry, one of the main trends detected is the growing spread of cattle, which reached its peak in Late Antiquity. All these patterns are explained in detail within the text, but the fact that all regional references or sites included in the CA and in the charts appear codified with letters makes it difficult to understand the geographical differences in these illustrations.
Regarding the cartographic representation of crops, the chapter includes individual maps (figs. 14–18) representing the volume of finds with scaled circles. This mapping procedure allows regional concentrations to be perceived more easily. However, the fact that the maps use the spatial limits of the Rurland project's area, when, as I have mentioned above, it is only the data from France that are discussed here, could generate distortions or fake gaps that could affect the reliability of some of these concentrations. As for the cartographic depiction of husbandry practices, the scale of the maps employed is more adequate to the sample represented. These maps are complemented by scaled pie charts representing the proportion of two species (sheep/cattle and horses/cattle) in each region. The maps illustrate the aforementioned trend toward an increasing spread of cattle but they also confirm that there were few changes in husbandry practices between the late La Tène period and the Early Roman Empire. This section is completed by a rich discussion on the improvement of animal feeding during the Roman period (360–64). Also fundamental for the understanding of the agrarian structures of northern Gaul is the progressive selection of animal variants of larger size recorded in all domestic species sampled. Not only are all these improvements are related to husbandry practices or meat consumption itself but they also had an impact on the use of animal power both for plowing and for the transport of agricultural products in the region. The data analyzed also allow us to infer a regional specialization in the raising of some smaller variants of cattle with lower productivity, and therefore linked to poorer agricultural capacity for the generation of surpluses devoted to feeding animals (e.g. the case of Vénetés, fig. 31).
All these data permit a detailed record of the substantial changes introduced in agrarian practices in this region between the Principate and the Late Roman Empire. One of the main conclusions of the chapter is that we can observe a large rationalization of the crops cultivated and productive cycles during the Roman period. The introduction of several alternating and rotating agrarian practices is clearly attested. This is the case, for instance, in the cultivation of oats, which requires small labor and maintenance investment, to complement the production of more traditional cereals such as wheat and rye. At the same time, the aforementioned improvements in cattle husbandry allowed the use of animal power for agriculture more intensively than in other regions. This could help to explain the well-known linkage of the vallus (a Gallo-Roman reaping machine) with northern Gaul, as recorded in the classical sources (Pliny, NH 18.72; Palladius, Op. Agr. 7.2.1–4).Footnote 39 These changes created one of the most productive agrarian systems in the western Roman Empire, a phenomenon that is characterized by the authors as a “small agricultural revolution.”
The section is closed by a chapter by F. Favory and C. Fruchart on the study of land-division systems between the late La Tène and Roman periods. The study of fossilized cadastres by French scholars has a long tradition that can be traced back to M. Bloch.Footnote 40 In the case of Roman studies, this tradition had a boost in the 1980s by the progressive generalization of aerial photography.Footnote 41 This chapter can be considered as an update of this tradition, thanks to the application of remote-sensing techniques such as LiDAR.
The analysis of LiDAR terrestrial models is especially useful in forested environments, given its capacity to “clean” all overlying vegetation. This type of remote-sensing technique is used to analyze up to 17 different zones. Even when the total space analyzed represents a minor percentage of the Rurland project area, the authors are able to confirm some important patterns argued for in the previous chapters. This is the case with the tendency to find less regular land-division systems in those areas with lower agrarian potential.Footnote 42
Another question raised in this chapter is that of the progressive regularization observed in the enclosures and parcels recorded in northern Gaul. Previous scholarship was marked by recording of irregular land divisions, named “Celtic fields,” as the main characteristic of the land-division systems in the Low Countries and the UK.Footnote 43 However, in this chapter (and in chapters 2 and 8) we find several examples of pre-Roman enclosures inserted in regular grids, mostly related to co-axial systems. These systems, certainly similar to some “Celtic fields,”Footnote 44 are clearly regular even when they are not oriented according to the canonical rules of the Roman agronomists.
Economic development
The last part of the volume can be considered as essential, since it contains the conceptual basis on which the main conclusions of the whole project are anchored. This block starts with a chapter by F. Malrain and T. Lorho on the economic organization of late La Tène rural communities. Consistent with the proposal in chapter 2, they show the existence of a growing hierarchy and complexity of pre-Roman rural settlements, illustrated by cases such as Ourcel-Maison/Hardivillers (chap. 8, fig. 2) or Poulaninville (fig. 7). In certain ways, this characterization contrasts with the simplifying view of the first Gallo-Roman sites developed by the main authors of chapter 3 with regard to the introduction of internal complexity in the rural settlements of northern Gaul as a consequence of the influx of Italians after the Roman conquest.
The review of all pre-Roman archaeological evidence is also explored in this chapter, to demonstrate the specialization and complexity of the agrarian tools recorded on these sites (468–70). In addition, Malrain and Lorho allude to the rise of more complex settlement categories such as towns and rural agglomerations, and a general growth in the number of rural sites in the north of France that can be dated around 100 BCE. All these patterns are adduced by the authors to characterize this final period of the Late Iron Age as an “agrarian revolution” (474–75). This is the second time in this volume that some of the authors have identified a specific chronological period as “revolutionary.” In consequence, we could characterize the agrarian history of the period covered as a curve with two main peaks that coincided with the two “agrarian revolutions” proposed: the first placed around the later 3rd–middle 2nd c. BCE and the second at some point after the second half of the 1st c. CE.
This question is also raised in the next, short chapter by M. Reddé, which discusses the settlement dynamics recorded in northern Gaul. The data corroborate the proposed chronological curve with two main “revolutionary” peaks, as well as confirming the trend toward the intensification in occupation of agrarian soils during the Roman period previously observed by P. Ouzoulias.Footnote 45
The next chapter, also authored by Reddé, is the first one that approaches directly the question of economic development in these parts of Roman Gaul.Footnote 46 The outlook introduced here can be traced back to the discussion around Roman economic growth started by K. Hopkins, and more recently continued by other authors such as W. Scheidel and A. Wilson.Footnote 47 The chapter focuses on the main factors that allowed economic development of the region during the Roman period.
A first factor analyzed is the (always elusive) question of ancient demography. Despite the arguments of previous scholarship on the paleodemography of the region,Footnote 48 the settlement data synthesized in the previous chapters do not allow us to demonstrate either a dramatic demographic drop as a consequence of the Roman conquest or a large increase produced by the arrival of contingents of Italic peoples. A second factor relates to the impact of Roman taxation and army provisioning. More specifically, this question is analyzed in relation to the slow implantation of the villa in the region until the late 1st c. CE (508–12). Reddé's argument is that the first phase of the conquest of German provinces, around the turn of the 1st c. BCE, introduced a larger tax pressure on the Gaulish small- and medium-sized landholders, which impeded the faster development of large estates and rural latifundia. Later, once the German limes was more established after the Trajanic conquests in Germania and Raetia, the rise of a network of villae (chap. 10, fig. 7) devoted to feeding the army can be detected.Footnote 49 Nevertheless, these concentrations of rural sites in the hinterland of the military camps of the limes did not comprise monumental villae, similar to the ideal Catonian model, but rather far more humble rural habitats that in German scholarship are usually termed villae rusticae.Footnote 50 It is in this later period, coincident with the second “small agrarian revolution” advocated by chapter 6, that a substantial change in the rural landscapes of Roman Gaul can be identified.
The next chapter, by M. Reddé, N. Bernigaud, S. Lepetz, and V. Zech-Matterne, is also oriented toward explaining other factors related to the economic development of the region. On this occasion, the analysis is exclusively devoted to markets. Even when the authors affirm that they are approaching Roman economics from a strict practical approach, they start from an implicit theoretical or conceptual point related to new institutional economics.Footnote 51 In fact, they articulate their analysis of agrarian markets around three main scales of trade (long-distance, regional, and local). This structure is clearly related to previous proposals developed by scholars such as P. Erdkamp and L. de Ligt.Footnote 52 These Dutch ancient historians can be considered as some of the most prominent applicants of the new institutional economics approaches to the study of Roman economic history. The importance attributed by Reddé to some state factors (such as taxation or army supply) confirms this undeniable influence.
Another feature linked to a neoclassical conception of Roman economics is the importance given to long-distance trade for a study of rural markets in northern Gaul. This analysis is approached by two main proxies: the distribution of amphorae finds (the archaeological proxy most widely scrutinized by scholars of the Roman economy) and the volume of epigraphic documents that mention negotiatores. Regarding the first proxy, the authors’ analysis is based on the work of F. Laubenheimer and E. Marlière on the distribution of amphorae in the north of Roman Gaul.Footnote 53 This monograph was not limited to the study of such finds in rural areas, but was mostly focused on the regional towns. This implies the need for a prior refinement of the data recorded in the original study (with a subsequent loss of quality). In addition, the area covered by Laubenheimer and Marlière is only a small fraction of the whole territory of the Rurland project. Nevertheless, the interpretation of these data is a very good first approach on the impact of long- (and medium-)distance trade on Roman rural markets, which could be developed in the future by the integration of further regional studies.
The other proxy analyzed, the epigraphic references to negotiatores,Footnote 54 shows the importance of the commercial axis established around the courses of the Rhone, Saône, Moselle, and Rhine rivers as part of the economic structure created by the need to feed the Roman army on the German limes, and, via the English channel, with the limes in Britannia.Footnote 55 Linked to this commercial axis one needs to take account of the introduction and acclimatization of hexogen vegetal species explained in chapter 6.
The regional and local scales of analysis are approached by the authors through other proxies. In the case of the regional, the main index analyzed is the distribution of horrea, thanks to the publication of a recent monograph that was also written within the framework of the Rurland project.Footnote 56 The interior distribution of these granaries (chap. 11, fig. 9) shows that the circulation network of cereals was essentially regional in northern Gaul. The chronological comparison of horrea capacities reveals a growth in storage potential in the 2nd c. CE that can be linked to the “small agrarian revolution,” but also to the increasing capacity of the local elite to concentrate surpluses.Footnote 57
For the analysis of the local scale, the authors use the hinterland of 4 towns as case studies: Amiens, Metz, Reims, and Troyes. The territories of Amiens and Metz offer examples of productive hinterlands densely populated with a wide diversity of economic activities. In contrast, the territory around Reims and Troyes was less densely inhabited, with a lower economic potential. It must be said that this type of analysis based on the convergence or absence of productive features around urban cores seems to reflect the Weberian model of the consumer city as the main option for the study of local rural markets. Of course, we cannot underestimate the undeniable importance of towns as local cores of economic activity. But local markets were also influenced by the interests of the main economic agents of any agrarian society: the farmers. To provide a more balanced approach to the articulation of local markets, we must also analyze the “productive” settlements in the hinterland of Roman towns as consumption cores.
The next chapter, by S. Martin, asks if we can really quantify economic development in northern Roman Gaul. Rather like the previous chapter, the conceptual standpoint is similar to that of those Roman economic historians influenced by new institutional economics. Although Martin replaces the concept of “growth” with “development,” the quantification question connects with other proposals in some other recent scholarship.Footnote 58 Martin's analysis is based on a comparison of two main archaeological proxies: horrea and numismatics. The choice of these two proxies seems to me adequate for the analysis of any agrarian economy. Both are easily quantifiable, and they were complementary as the basic form of income and taxation in the political economy of any European preindustrial society.
The most remarkable conclusion presented in this chapter is methodological. Martin advocates a (commonsensical) middle-range position between a total refusal to engage in any type of quantificationFootnote 59 and the current trend to apply increasingly more complex statistical procedures for the analysis of the ever-larger datasets of finds.Footnote 60 By doing this, his analysis offers arguments, based on a convincing sampling of the selected archaeological proxies, that support the idea of general economic development in the region parallel to the proxies sampled in other parts of the volume, such as the growth of the average size of millstones, the rotation of marginal plots,Footnote 61 the specialization of cereal crops, or the introduction of exotic finds and species.
This section is closed by another chapter by M. Kasprzyk on the changes that occurred during Late Antiquity in the rural economy of Roman Gaul. First, he outlines a generalized decline in the number of rural sites recorded in the region. This decline is accompanied by changes in the land-division systems and the abandonment of lands previously exploited during the Early Imperial period. An especially remarkable feature of this chapter is the introduction of a discussion about the social transformations that these economic changes could generate, a positive exception in the volume.
Final discussion
The two volumes reviewed here and previously contain a huge quantity of data that must be fully exploited in the future. As a result of the Rurland project, it is possible to affirm that this part of Roman Gaul is now one of the most extensively known rural areas of the Roman Empire. I have no doubt that the project will be taken as a model internationally for future research initiatives on the Roman countryside. But, even though these volumes can be characterized as admirable for many reasons, the amplitude of topics and approaches covered stimulate multiple points of discussion.
The application of the development concept to the study of the Roman rural world is an innovative avenue of research inspired by influential scholars such as P. Leveau and other Roman economic historians strongly influenced by new institutional economics. Nevertheless, a different notion of rural development has been approached from the perspective of so-called developmental studies.Footnote 62 In contrast to the conclusions of neoclassical economists, for these scholars the notion of development is not a simple synonym for economic growth. According to these approaches, research must also be conducted on underdeveloped areas, and on those sectors from regions that experienced important economic growth, but which remained less developed. Such a research initiative will permit us to identify those structural elements, not only institutional or environmental but also social and cultural, that can explain the maintenance of difference between developed and underdeveloped areas of the Roman world. To approach this task, we must select case by case the appropriate archaeological proxies to test previous assumptions and general models. Only by doing this will we be able to move beyond traditional paradigms that have been widely applied to different provincial scenarios.
The application of a development studies approach for the study of Roman countryside allows us to draw other important lessons from this book, in this case related to the concept of sustainability. If, as is demonstrated by many of its chapters, the 2nd and 3rd c. CE can be considered as a period of intense economic growth in northern Gaul, it is no less true that this growth dramatically came to an end in Late Antiquity.Footnote 63 This intense but relatively short cycle of growth in the economy of Roman Gaul makes me wonder if the use of the concept of development to characterize this period is really appropriate. The introduction of sustainability as a complementary vector of development is essential to a deeper understanding of the structural factors that explain the unequal evolution of all social sectors involved in the rural economies of the Roman world. Thanks to the Rurland project, northern Gaul will be a privileged region in which to explore this new research horizon in the near future.
