In this brief work of eight chapters, Anthony King, a highly regarded professor of government at the University of Essex, wishes “to provoke Americans into thinking” in fresh ways about their political system (x). He does so by inviting his readers to confront a series of paradoxes in which America's standing among the world's preeminent democracies is seen to be in tension with the country's federal Constitution. More particularly, these paradoxes result from the American political system resting on two tectonic plates rubbing “up against each other” (2), with one being the constitutional system of government and the other a commitment to radical democracy.
In the first chapter, King outlines these puzzling features of the American system of government. They include restrictions on who can run for president; term limits on the president; the absence of referendums at the federal level; the unusual power of the Supreme Court, including its having decided on whether abortion should be legalized whereas elsewhere it would have been a legislative matter or decided by popular referendum; and the Electoral College which “institutionalizes a form of indirect democracy” (11). The second chapter considers the eighteenth-century meaning of “the people,” and King suggests three meanings. One, “a composite picture of ‘the American people’” (26), comes closest to what the Founders had in mind, but still “their understanding of the term ‘the people’ was not ours” (17).
The third chapter considers the role the people were to enjoy in the new constitutional frame of government, at least as envisioned by the delegates as articulated in James Madison's Notes. King points to the people's voice being embodied fully in the House, with little input into the second and more powerful chamber, the Senate, and none into the federal judiciary. The federal executive, too, was to express the people's will but only in a limited fashion. In comparing American federal institutions to those in other advanced polities, King suggests that in many instances American national institutions are less democratic. Still, he wishes to emphasize that “America's 1787 Constitution was, by the standards of the contemporary civilized world, many decades ahead of its time” (62). Surprisingly, though, King fails to consider that the Constitution's forward-looking nature might have been offset by a backward-looking structural design borrowed from an eighteenth-century British Opposition exaltation of the 1689 English constitution that, by 1789, had already become outdated as Britain had begun to develop a “responsible party” system of government.
In the fourth and fifth chapters, King turns to the second plate—the democratic one—and describes how the limited role for the people envisioned by the Founders morphed into a system of government that exalted the people (81). Popular political engagement continuously gained ground across the nineteenth century with the development of initiative and referendum (93), and direct primaries (94). As a consequence, the constitutionalism of the Founders and the democratic populism of those who followed them came to diverge (99). It is this divergence that King most skillfully describes, most especially in his account of how the states and would-be candidates for the Senate began finding ways to circumvent the Constitution's prescribed method for choosing senators by state legislatures.
In the sixth chapter, King convincingly begins by arguing that there are two different political shrines at which Americans pray with “fundamental[ly] different characteristics … [and that] conflict with one another at almost every point” (131). For King, the first of the two revered gods is the Founders. He characterizes them as a unitary elite with book-lined libraries who led the country first to independence, and then to a new Constitution. The second religious-like image—awkwardly he shifts from gods to images—is of small-town and localistic America: “it is essentially a rural and small-town image, one well captured by the paintings of Norman Rockwell” (131). The first set of values King goes on to describe as republican or constitutional (132) with its core being the importance of individual inalienable rights. King seems to confuse constitutionalism with liberalism, both with republicanism, and all with the balance/separation of powers.
When he turns to the second conception, with surprisingly “even deeper roots—in the American past and American psyche,” with no reference to when that might have been, King labels it “radical democracy” while noting that “its emphases are entirely different from those of constitutionalism” (143). It seems that King has supplied not one, but two descriptions for each of his tectonic plates.
In the seventh chapter, King turns not to what one might have expected in a chapter titled “an assortment of solutions,” but instead to rehearsing in greater and helpful detail the various anomalies outlined in the first chapter.
In the book's final chapter, King remarks anew that his intention throughout has been to draw attention “to some of the paradoxes that stem from the endemic conflict … between the claims of strict constitutionalism and the claims of radical democracy” (177). But has this tension, in truth, resulted in “endemic conflict” in America, so that his chosen metaphor, “tectonic,” would appear to be aptly chosen? Instead of confronting directly this question, King next examines the claims of influential American political scientists who offer their own plans by which America might be made more democratic. Additionally, though, King highlights the work of two less well-known empirical political scientists, John R. Hibbing and Elizabeth Theiss-Morse, who argue that “‘the last thing people [in America] want is to be more involved in political decision making’ … and those pushing for more of the same are likely ‘misguided’” (193). The endemic conflict, to the degree it exists, seems not to emanate from the American people.
In the last few pages of his book, King belatedly addresses the question whether by using the metaphor of tectonic plates he means to suggest that “in the not too distant future a major and potentially destructive political earthquake” is in the offing. He quickly answers that “no such earthquake is likely to occur” (204). But if not, why did King use such an explosive metaphor throughout this work? In partial answer, King suggests that it is because Americans are so deeply divided “from one another by region, race, ethnic origin, religious affiliation … and, perhaps most deeply of all, by profound differences in their whole philosophy of life” (205). But these same radical divisions, unexpectedly, also help explain why a violent earthquake is not to be expected. That is, the present tension-ridden plan of government has “the great advantage of identifying potentially threatening issues and of taking many of them out of politics” by handing them to the Supreme Court (206–7). The Court, in turn, takes advantage of the US Constitution's being an icon that Americans “can worship together” (207). It seems as though King wants to use these tensions to explain not only why they are potentially explosive, but also why they are not likely to be so.
King has produced a work with significant strengths and weaknesses. Its central strength is persuasively drawing attention to the powerful tension in American iconography between “the Founding” and “democracy” and arguing that the first is most fully embodied in federal institutions and the latter in the governmental practices of the states. Among its weaknesses is that the specific nature of the two opposed plates is anything but clear with two, if not three, distinct characterizations. King also fails to have considered the fundamental tensions between the localistic impulses embodied in the Declaration (and the Articles of Confederation) and the centralizing ones of the Constitution in which each document helps define contrasting impulses rather than serving as one pole in opposition to a later-to-develop set of democratic institutions.
There is much to like in this brief book but it could and should have been written with greater precision, greater historical breadth (there are no references to a world before 1780), and familiarity with modern Western political theory.
