When it comes to corporate malfeasance, it is common parlance to say ‘follow the money’. In Toxic Injustice, however, Susanna Rankin Bohme invites readers on a rich historical journey to follow a single chemical, the pesticide Dibromochloropropane (DBCP), across international boundaries, over the bodies of agricultural workers, and into the courtroom. Through detailed exposition of primary documents, we are immersed in the social and environmental life of DBCP. Bohme's readers are led through the complex processes by which narratives about toxic chemicals are written and reified, particularly through the interactive dialogue between corporations and regulators.
Environmental regulation in the United States often leans towards protecting economic interests, rather than defending human health and the environment. Bohme's work adds substantially to the literature in this arena, delineating the competing interests that existed within the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) in the first half of the twentieth century. That agency was responsible for developing and regulating toxic chemicals designed to keep US troops safe in war zones, and to improve agricultural yields at home. The Cold War influence was also strongly felt, as the anti-Soviet narrative of the time wove together the complex threads of scientific advancement, protection of public health, and agricultural and economic abundance. The ideology, Better Living through Chemistry, was central to that narrative.
Bohme grounds her argument in a range of legal, government, and other primary documents, illustrating the historical context in which the central drama of her text unfolds. DBCP, like many other new chemicals, emerged at a time when regulation of environmental and health hazards was in its infancy. Marketing efforts moved more quickly, at times before toxicity trials were complete. When scientific evaluations in labs (i.e. with animals) were completed, the uncertainties inherent in the process allowed chemical companies, like Dow and Shell, to counter toxicity concerns through public relations materials. As Bohme ironically observes, the existence of a weak regulatory process creates an illusory aura of accountability around the chemical companies and their products. Product warnings emphasised the importance of ideal handling and application of DBCP. Such conditions rarely existed on agricultural plantations in Central America, where significant numbers of workers became exposed.
In focusing on the exposure nexus of workers and chemicals, Bohme's work provides needed texture in understanding the role of toxics in the production of one of the world's most significant commodities, bananas. She argues that exposure among agricultural workers is a transnational phenomenon, and that the overall impact of toxic chemicals must be addressed from a transnational analytic perspective. Engaging across multiple frameworks, Bohme shows the significance of emerging social movements and their legal analogues. She deftly illustrates the conflict between consumer protections versus those of labour protections. When costs were at stake, chemical and fruit production companies, in conjunction with regulatory agencies, chose to focus on potential risk to consumers.
The core of Bohme's contribution is her focus on the processes through which worker social movements, particularly in Costa Rica and Nicaragua, sought relief and compensation for the health consequences of their DBCP exposure. Bohme describes circumstances on plantations preventing workers from adequately following the instructions accompanying the chemicals, even when written in Spanish. Workers were frequently forced to choose between physical comfort and use of personal protective equipment. The more protective the gear, the more uncomfortable it was to wear in hot and humid climates. Bohme also shows that optimal protective gear was not typically available. Her data suggest it was near impossible, in prevailing regional work conditions, to avoid contact with DBCP. The existing regulatory structure allowed significant blame to be placed on the workers for failing to comply, a key element of the strategy to deflect blame for toxic outcomes.
Many workers were hesitant to complain for fear of losing their jobs, but health consequences were eventually too extreme to deny. In particular, male sterility was widely documented among agricultural workers, an outcome that had both social and physiological consequences. On the strength of these claims, workers and their advocates began to pursue legal action. In Costa Rica, ironically, the much lauded National Health Service had a mechanism to compensate for occupational health issues. However, the compensation was hardly adequate to address the losses workers felt they had suffered. It was hoped that pursuing litigation in US courts might bring more just reparations.
The complexities of this process, as exemplified by several cases explored in detail through Bohme's careful research, form the basis of the book's most fundamental contribution. The history of how individual cases came to be tried in specific courts (Florida vs. Texas, for example), and the dramatic emergence of the arcane legal concept of forum non conveniens (FNC) as a villain in its own right, plays out like a tragic documentary, the ending of which we already know. However, Bohme is careful to underscore the specificity of each case, with the goal of documenting the tragedy, while finding instructive lessons for ongoing struggle. The use of legal loopholes such as FNC, which allows judges great flexibility to throw otherwise valid cases out of a particular jurisdiction, are weighty precedents. However, these legal frameworks can be addressed through social and democratic movements, as well as in court. Legal teams working across political and cultural boundaries can make significant errors in prosecuting their cases, but we and they can learn from those mistakes. Workers may not have scientific knowledge of a particular chemical, but they can speak truth to power about their own experiences. In Nicaragua, for example, the national movement of those affected (afectados) was successful in promoting local laws that eventually led to reconsideration of some cases in US courts. Many advances can come with efforts to improve awareness and understanding of cultural knowledge across legal and regulatory processes. In this sense, Bohme's conclusion is one of hope. However, it also leaves readers with the open question. What will it take for voting and consuming publics to see that their own interests are reflected in the social and environmental struggles of people around the world?
