It is not a surprise that scholars have trouble agreeing on the overarching beliefs of Benjamin Franklin. Franklin lived a long, rich, and extraordinarily varied life. He won fame as a scientist, philosopher, moral preacher, publisher, statesman, revolutionary, diplomat, socialite, merry prankster, and more. His penchant for concealment and irony make it even more difficult to discern an order, if there was one, in Franklin's sprawling life. When it comes to Franklin's political philosophy, sharply divergent but nevertheless compelling accounts have emerged—thorough-going skeptic, Whig improver, embodiment of the capitalist spirit, and political opportunist, to name just a few. Kevin Slack's Benjamin Franklin, Natural Right, and the Art of Virtue makes an impressive contribution to the quest for the real Benjamin Franklin. His account has two main appeals. It finds Franklin to have a coherent political philosophy and, moreover, it finds this political philosophy to be very much in the mainstream of American political thinking at the time of the Founding. His Franklin is not an intellectual outlier swept up by the events of the Revolution.
Rather than using the Autobiography as the key to unlocking Franklin's thought, Slack begins at the beginning, so to speak, with the young Franklin and sorts through Franklin's thought with the occasional look ahead to the Autobiography. The young Franklin was a rebel, philosophically and theologically, and moved partly by “anger and resentment” (23) at his lowly condition. At this time, the thought of Bernard Mandeville loomed large in Franklin's mind. Franklin's scandalous pamphlet “A Dissertation on Liberty and Necessity” earned him an introduction to the scandalous author of the Fable of the Bees—“a most facetious entertaining Companion,” Franklin would later report of Mandeville. Mandeville called into question the distinction between virtue and vice, arguing that all apparent virtue has its foundation in self-interested behavior and, further, that “private vices” might have “public benefits.” Franklin's pamphlet eliminated the distinction between virtue and vice, as well as the conceit of free will. Franklin quickly and repeatedly repudiated the positions of this early pamphlet. Scholars divide, however, over whether Franklin's move away from what he seems to call “thorough” deism was merely tactical or genuine and, if genuine, what exactly the new position was. Slack believes that the shift was genuine and that it was motivated by Franklin's engagement with the thought of Mandeville's foil Anthony Ashley Cooper, the Third Earl of Shaftesbury.
Franklin's Autobiography mentions Shaftesbury as an early influence on his religious views. He in fact helped make Franklin a “thorough deist.” Slack argues that Shaftesbury (and John Locke before him) also showed the way out of this “not very useful” position through a different kind of natural theology. The discussion is complicated and culminates in a polytheistic-pagan-enlightenment synthesis wherein, to those who understand, one makes one's own providence. It is hard to know whether to be impressed with Franklin's argument or to laugh, as some commentators have done. Moving to firmer ground, Slack also finds Shaftesbury's influence in Franklin's new concern for human sociability and its connection to the issue of virtue and vice. Mandeville proclaimed as natural a radical self-interested individualism whereas Shaftesbury posited human sociability as natural: “Humans are by nature social creatures, and all possess in some degree the social affection in which the notions of virtue and equity are grounded” (83). According to Slack, Franklin's rejection of Mandeville marks a critical change that opened new and productive doors for him in moral, social, and political theorizing. Developing our social affections into real virtues is the critical task for individuals and for society. For individuals, what is required is rigorous self-examination through an ongoing internal dialogue about virtue and one's relations to others that aims at perfecting both. Similarly rigorous efforts are required by society at large. Franklin's civic projects point toward the kinds of instruction required: Poor Richard's advice, Franklin's self-improvement plans, his library plan, his clubs, his plans for higher education, and his Autobiography.
The latter parts of the book deal mostly with political themes. Two deserve mention because they cut against the grain of much Franklin scholarship. The first theme is that of natural rights, which some scholars have argued play only a minor role in Franklin's thought. Slack observes that Franklin appealed to natural rights early (at least by the 1730s) and often, serving throughout his life as the standard for political right. On the critical question of the grounds for natural right, Slack's argument is complex. He claims that Franklin as an individual possessed an idea of natural right that was similar to the classical understanding but, importantly, adds that he also held to a more modern, political understanding of natural rights. Rights are neither written in the hearts of men nor derived with certainty from metaphysical treatises. Natural rights instead “consisted of principles of good government and political economy, such as rule by consent and free trade” (147). Franklin in this regard is a Lockean but as much or more the Locke of the Essay Concerning Human Understanding than that the Second Treatise. Franklin's understanding of natural rights made him more aware than most of his contemporaries of the somewhat fragile character of natural rights. For one thing, according to Slack, the doctrine of natural rights is a “political creed” founded on “opinion” (123).
A second theme Slack develops is courage. In his discussion of Franklin's account of the virtues and his account of Franklin's statesmanship, Slack is emphatic that Franklin's understanding of “resolution” does not imply any narrowing of the understanding of courage. Slack mentions twice Franklin's own military service on the Pennsylvania frontier when he was charged with establishing security after a series of Indian massacres. Scholars, he believes, have given resolution too much of a commercial cast. This account of courage is also linked to his claim that Franklin was far from deaf to honor, the love of fame, and glory.
Benjamin Franklin, Natural Right, and the Art of Virtue is a formidable contribution to our understanding of Franklin. The Franklin that emerges is a serious statesman-philosopher. Casting a net over Franklin's long life and gathering in all its dimensions is a difficult task. Something is almost sure to escape. One aspect of Franklin that Slack downplays is his humor. One never quite knows when Franklin is being serious. This is a serious matter! To give just one example relevant to Slack's account of the role of Mandeville in Franklin's intellectual development: Franklin almost begins his Autobiography with a very Mandevillean reflection on the private and public benefits of the vice of vanity. This reader wonders just how Franklin understood Mandeville's provocations and whether Slack might overstate just how far Franklin broke with his facetious, entertaining companion.
