In the late 1970s scholars of Europe and its colonies began probing the relationship between medicine and empire. In the decades since, following the cue of Steven Feierman, John Janzen, Megan Vaughan and Randall Packard, the literature has demonstrated that colonial medicine constructed an African ‘other’ and greatly contributed to harmful practices that did not improve the overall health and welfare of the local populations European administrations claimed to be civilising.Footnote 1 Through the 1990s, scholarship concentrated primarily on local agency and socio-economic and political factors that furthered our understanding of how medicine and health care operated in a colonial context. These foundational studies have enabled the most recent wave of research in the history of medicine to turn its attention to questions of public health, especially as it relates to the politics of development, nationalism, and decolonisation. Historians, including Sunil Amrith and Clifford Rosenberg, have emphasised the significant role medicine has played in projecting state power in European colonies and have shown how international organisations became prominent agents in shaping national and global health policies.Footnote 2 However, their important work has left unanswered questions about the intellectual networks that formed the elite scientific and medical minds of the day and the legacies of health policies under colonial rule.
New studies, several of which are under review in this essay, have broadened this field by placing Western biomedicine and European medical networks at the centre of the narrative. Through this approach, scholars are probing the long-term impact of colonial policies and analysing how local populations from different cultural and religious backgrounds interacted with biomedical ideas. While tackling these ideas from diverse perspectives, these new works, including the books discussed here, examine where medical authority originated and how medicine and public health, to borrow the words of Daniel Headrick, were used as a ‘tool of empire’.Footnote 3 More specifically, they ask: what beliefs and training did the earliest European doctors and scientists carry with them as they encountered local medical practices in Africa and Asia? What kind of networks existed at home and abroad for European medical personnel? And finally, how did ideas about medicine, power and authority change over time as locals in a variety of colonial contexts resisted, adopted and ultimately transformed Western biomedical practices to best suit their aims? By wrestling with these questions and making use of newly available archival material, Pratik Chakrabarti, Michael Osborne, Deborah Neill, Ellen Amster and Matthew Heaton have expanded the study of colonial medicine in new directions.Footnote 4 Their work demonstrates how the dynamic relationship between medicine and colonialism can further our understanding of the evolution of science and concepts of medical hybridity. Furthermore, it shows how local and international intellectual networks can be used to challenge notions of medical authority and rethink the often-separated colonial and post-colonial periods.
Expanding the field of Medicine and Colonialism
Nearly twenty years ago, Shula Marks assessed the state of the history of medicine and colonialism in her article, ‘What is Colonial about Colonial Medicine?’Footnote 5 She had recently attended a conference called ‘Medicine and the Colonies’ and was ‘struck by the enormous range and rich diversity of the offerings’ on the subject.Footnote 6 She marvelled that when she had begun her research in the 1970s, the only scholarship on medicine and colonialism was from a European perspective and celebrated the triumph of Western science over savagery. Marks's observations highlighted the exciting new directions of the field at the time, the limitations of colonial rule, native agency and medical contestation, all of which have been vibrant topics of debate among scholars ever since. However, two areas that she suggested merited further attention—class (and class formation) and legacies of colonial medicine – remained understudied until recently.
Warwick Anderson was similarly concerned with the lasting impact of colonialism and wondered if historians of medicine could move beyond an imperialist or nationalist framework. For him, it was not ‘enough to decolonize “colonial” medicine and produce fresh national narratives’.Footnote 7 He was instead looking for scholars to transcend conventional periodisations and to complicate longstanding categories such as nation and empire. Recent work is responding to Marks and Anderson by finding ways to dismantle binary pairings, most notably, metropole/colony, Western biomedicine/‘traditional’ medicine and colonial/post-colonial. These points of intersection defy national and imperial boundaries and point toward a continuum, rather than a rupture, of time and space, thus pushing historians to re-evaluate medical authority, scientific knowledge production and local agency in the twentieth- and twenty-first centuries.
In an effort ‘to make the history of medicine and imperialism as a specialization in its own right’, Pratik Chakrabarti's Medicine and Empire takes on the hefty task of surveying the history of medicine and imperialism from 1600 to 1960. While researching and teaching courses on imperialism, medicine and science, Chakrabarti noticed that scholarship on the subject was limited to certain geographical areas, particular epidemics or what he calls ‘tropes’, such as tropical medicine. In writing Medicine and Empire, he aimed ‘to make the historical and analytical links between medicine and European imperialism from the seventeenth century to the mid-twentieth century and to highlight the various research questions and intellectual traditions that have emerged in this field’.Footnote 8
Chakrabarti's study has an ambitious temporal and global reach. He divides the history of medicine and imperialism into four distinct periods: the Age of Commerce (1600–1800), the Age of Empire (roughly 1800–1880), the Age of New Imperialism (1880–1914) and the Era of New Imperialism and Decolonization (1920–1960).Footnote 9 Chakrabarti begins with Spanish, Portuguese, British and Dutch colonial expansion in the seventeenth century and shows how their search for new markets in the Americas and Asia ‘transformed the basic premise of modern medicine’.Footnote 10 The race to establish commercial ventures in these distant lands initiated a process whereby European travellers interacted with native inhabitants, different climates, unfamiliar physical landscapes and new diseases. In order to successfully carry out their commercial endeavours, Europeans abroad, and later at home, had a vested interest in learning how to maintain their health, as well as that of local populations.
Many of Chakrabarti's arguments on medicine and the colonial armed forces (chapter 3), medicine and the colonisation of Africa (chapter 7) and bacteriology and the civilising mission (chapter 9) are not new. Rather, he synthesises the major arguments in the field. However, the book's most significant contribution is that it provides an apt overview of the conjoined European and colonial histories that ‘cannot be understood without the other’.Footnote 11 For Chakrabarti, the history of modern medicine and European imperialism are ‘mutually constitutive’ and must be studied in tandem. Frequently, this important point is overlooked but it is one that several other works under discussion here also make.
Medicine and Empire is unique because it is one of the few sources that can act as a valuable textbook for both introductory courses on the history of medicine and more specialised courses on medicine and colonialism. Even though Western biomedicine and Europe are central to the book's narrative, Chakrabarti clearly illustrates that they were in constant flux in history. He quickly dispels Europe's supposed biomedical and cultural superiority by repeatedly stressing how European practitioners, military officers, traders and scientists were continually confronted with health and disease challenges for which they were wholly unprepared. By exploring a number of issues ranging from the use of medicinal herbs and plants and the role of missionaries, to the rise of germ theory and the revitalisation of ‘traditional’ medical practices after independence as a way to recover the past and legitimatise the nation, Medicine and Empire provides instructive snippets on questions that are frequently addressed in national or imperial contexts. Given the thematic nature of the book, there is significant overlap in the chapters, which are best used selectively depending on one's needs.
Tropical Medicine and International Networks
Within the extensive literature on tropical medicine to which Chakrabarti refers, recent scholarship has emphasised the importance of networks, both at the national and international levels. Michael Osborne's The Emergence of Tropical Medicine in France examines the profession's development in France from 1815 to the First World War and focuses on colonial naval medicine in the ports and coastal cities, which he argues were the epicentre of French medicine. He shows that, with the exception of in Algeria, naval doctors had the most significant impact on colonial medicine during this period.Footnote 12 The coastal towns of Brest, Rochefort-sur-Mer, Toulon, Bordeaux and Marseilles were the primary training locations for men planning to travel abroad to the colonies. Therefore, in order to understand French colonial medicine in the nineteenth century, according to Osborne, one must closely study the naval doctors, the local institutions that trained them and the ideas they carried with them throughout the French Empire.
Osborne's thick description of people, institutions and ideologies successfully recreates a rich French maritime culture in understudied port sites along the Atlantic and Mediterranean. In doing this, he decentres a narrative of French colonial medicine dominated by accounts that examine civil doctors’ experiences and concentrate on Paris. He stresses the significance of the physical place and region in which the individual medical personnel lived and trained. For Osborne, ‘place’ was more than ‘a point on a map’. In addition to a physical location, place, for Osborne, ‘is a site of meaning and attachment, one to which value is assigned, often through the textured facts of experience and memory’.Footnote 13 The men who trained at these various French port sites were imbued with a deep and intimate connection to that particular place. Subsequently, the physicians and surgeons drew upon their localised experience and knowledge to inform the ways in which they tackled diseases in diverse locales such as the Caribbean and Africa.
But the use of localised (French) knowledge was disrupted at the end of the nineteenth century. Osborne carefully explains the transition from an unregulated and pluralistic medical profession to a ‘regime of universal tropical medicine’.Footnote 14 This seismic shift had significant implications for the way in which French practitioners learned about and treated medical conditions in the colonies. The new military regulations increasingly curtailed that flexibility and ushered in more centralisation and institutional oversight at home and overseas.Footnote 15
Osborne's work effectively highlights the interplay between naval medicine and the rise and transformation of French imperialism. However, his larger claim that ‘maritime France was the cradle of the new French Empire’Footnote 16 is less convincing given that his study is deeply rooted in French domestic networks. This is a subtle yet important difference. Even though Osborne follows several of his individual French medical actors abroad, he remains most interested in how their personal attachments to French cities influenced their medical and healing practices.
Deborah Neill's excellent study, Networks in Tropical Medicine, also examines the rise of tropical medicine in Europe but, unlike Osborne's, her analysis earnestly extends to African colonies. She aptly reconstructs intellectual networks between the metropole and the imperial territories, persuasively disrupting previous notions of medicine and empire. She argues that European doctors, scientists and clinicians developed close networks in training facilities across western Europe and built upon their expertise through extensive experimentation in Africa and Asia. She challenges the view that science and medical knowledge made significant strides solely within a national and nationalist context. In fact, she convincingly shows the opposite. To this end, she offers a compelling response to Maureen Malowany's call for scholars to interrogate the ‘vibrant networks that were both intra-colonial as well as international’.Footnote 17 Prominent men of science, including France's Louis Pasteur and Alphonse Laveran, Germany's Robert Koch and Paul Ehrlich and Britain's Patrick Manson and Ronald Ross collaborated across national borders and established transnational and transimperial networks abroad which were supported by numerous governments.
Neill focuses on European medical practitioners, not their African subjects. By tracing their intellectual formation in institutes such as the Pasteur Institute and the Institute for Infectious Diseases, she demonstrates how their scientific knowledge production reflected the culture and politics of western Europe and directly contributed to ‘othering’ the local populations over which France, Britain, Belgium and Germany ruled. The book sheds new light on western European ideologies, as well as Europeans’ fears and anxieties as they built their empires in the decades following the Berlin Conference (1884–1885). Despite some of the risks of living in the tropics, the members of this epistemic community firmly believed in the superiority of their science, technology and culture. They remained committed to spreading, what they perceived to be, the benefits of Western medicine around the world.
The very term ‘tropical medicine’ eschews simple characterisation. In his book The Problem of Nature, historian David Arnold explains that Europeans divided environments and climates into two categories, temperate and tropical, but both of these categories were grounded in Euro-centric understandings and perceptions of environment.Footnote 18 Not surprisingly, western Europe was described as a temperate climate, whereas the colonies were described as tropical climates. Tropical climates, according to many European officials, were to be tamed, as were the local inhabitants. The scientists’ expert opinions’ informed policy decisions in their countries’ African colonies. Many of the resulting programs led to oppressive and degrading policies, the likes of which still resonate today.
Rather than attempting to analyse African subjects through a European lens, Neill focuses on the tropical medicine community itself. Central to her study is analysis of the sleeping sickness epidemic that occurred between 1900 and 1930. By focusing on this disease campaign, she artfully elucidates how the small, but highly influential, tropical medicine community developed a variety of treatment and prevention measures in British Uganda, German East Africa, the Congo Free State, German Cameroon and French Equatorial Africa. On the one hand, their efforts reflected the latest scientific discoveries. On the other hand, however, they resulted in harmful and discriminatory policies for the African people in these territories. British officials first noticed the disease, also known as human trypanosomiasis, in 1901 in the region of Busoga, Uganda. Even though the disease had existed in the area before the turn of the century, administrators were puzzled by its rapid spread. They then turned to tropical medicine experts for help managing the impending public health crisis. Over the next several years, rivals David Bruce and Aldo Castellani collected samples from humans and animals, conducted surveys and autopsies and examined countless blood and tissue samples in their microscopes. Their efforts determined that the tsetse fly was the source vector that transmitted sleeping sickness.
Bruce and Castellani's important discovery changed the way European colonial administrations tackled the disease, but before they could embark on implementing treatment measures, officials had to decide where their priorities should be in containing the health hazard. They chose to focus on the African people as the disease source. According to administrators’ logic, the disease's rapid spread was the result of the Africans’ poor hygienic practices and loose morals rather than harsh conditions introduced by Europeans. They did not fully consider the massive social and environmental changes wrought by European colonialism, many of which led to the widespread migration, dislocation and malnutrition of local populations, thus making them more susceptible to diseases such as sleeping sickness.
Neill's compelling study firmly establishes the extent to which colonial regimes relied on medical experts to generate policies aimed at more effectively running the colonies. Moreover, she illustrates how this influential small group of scientists routinely exchanged ideas and possible health care solutions across national and imperial lines. However, their willingness to cooperate with one another changed during and after the First World War. British, and especially French, scientists were unwilling to work with their German counterparts and went to great lengths to disparage them publicly. Even though German medical specialists had been at the forefront of tropical medicine and sleeping sickness campaigns, their reputations were tarnished in the wake of their nation's military aggression across Europe. This pivotal final chapter in Neill's analysis suggests the limits of internationalism and the far-reaching consequences of the Great War, questions that warrant further study.
Medical Power and Local Authority
Shifting our focus from European practitioners to local experts, Ellen Amster's Medicine and the Saints explores similar questions to Neill about the nature of scientific and medical networks. However, rather than investigating medical networks among Europeans in western Europe and Africa, Amster concentrates on how medical knowledge was constructed, modified and used for political gain in Morocco, a French Protectorate from 1912 to 1956. In doing so, she shows that studying medicine and empire can deepen our understanding of the multiplicity of relationships that existed under colonial rule.
Amster examines how local understandings of medicine and health and healing were inextricably linked to Islam and the peoples’ Muslim identity. She argues that ‘Islam and the Moroccan polity were lived, imagined and remembered in the body, a discursive and physical meeting-place of God, the polity, shari‘a (religious law) and the soul’.Footnote 19 Her analysis ascribes central agency to the body, ‘a social vehicle’, and ‘a mediator upon which to read ways of knowing and doing’, during the colonial period.Footnote 20 Theories of embodiment, she writes, allow scholars ‘to move beyond the state to deconstruct the human as a meeting-place of social order and interior life’.Footnote 21
Amster focuses on how everyday Moroccan men, women and children cared for their bodies, and she highlights their personal philosophies and belief systems. In doing so, she makes evident why French administrators and medical personnel bristled with local populations over health care issues. More often than not, they approached health and healing from different cosmologies. For example, Amster shows how at the dawn of French colonial rule, Sufi saints were the prime sources and arbiters of medical knowledge. They were political and religious authorities whose connection to God superseded that of any other political figure. However, their power was eroded when Sultan ‘Abd al-Hafiz signed the 1912 Treaty of Fez, thereby accomplishing three major changes that continue to reverberate in Moroccan history. First, the Treaty of Fez shifted Moroccan power away from Sufi saints to the sultan and the Moroccan monarchy. Second, it positioned the sultan as a strategic interlocutor between the French and the Moroccan people. And third, it introduced a new set of (French Western) beliefs about medicine, health and hygiene that the sultan indirectly legitimised as preferable to those that had been in place prior to the French's arrival in Morocco. Therefore, the 1912 Treaty of Fez, according to Amster, ‘decapitated the Muslim body politic and replaced its makhzan state with a French technocracy, a regime of science imposed over and against the Muslim body politic’.Footnote 22
Western biomedicine was used as part of the colonisation process; indeed, Amster contends that it was marshalled throughout the protectorate period to ensure French control over the Moroccan people. She presents a particularly poignant example in chapter 5, ‘Harem Medicine and the Sleeping Child: Law, Traditional Pharmacology and the Gender of Medical Authority’, which shows how French women were used to breach the divide between Muslim women and the French colonial state. French female nurses undercut Moroccan female medical authority by introducing them to French public health requirements such as an identity card for native midwives. This certification, colonial officials claimed, would regulate the profession and ensure that all practitioners had proper training. However, a by-product of these ID cards was that midwives were classified and accredited by French medical standards, not local ones.
Amster's analysis of female practitioners distinguishes her study from earlier works. Not only does she emphasise gender, she also prioritises local female knowledge in Moroccans’ understanding of health and healing. Women played critical roles in childbirth and childrearing. They also had intimate knowledge of local plants and herbs, which Moroccans used as medicinal remedies for a variety of illnesses and conditions. Analysing female medical practitioners, both European and African, offers historians important insight into the experience of colonial rule and the administration of territories. A second unique aspect of Amster's work is the centrality of religion, particularly Islam. Her heavy reliance on Arabic sources deepens her analysis of how local people conceived of themselves in relation to their religion. That being said, Amster's interpretations frequently do not allow for any other understanding of health and healing outside of religion. Were there other networks or methods of transmission that did not operate within a religious framework? If so, how might their incorporation enhance our comprehension of medicine in a colonial context?
Medicine and the Saints ends with an eye towards the development of nationalist agitation in Morocco and explains that ‘nationalists adopted the French positive language of science even as they indicted French colonialism’.Footnote 23 Although her study is firmly rooted in the colonial period, Amster draws the reader's attention to the varied outcomes and consequences of medicine and science under French rule and points towards a provocative argument that local Moroccan leaders instrumentalised particular elements of scientific language for their own personal and political ends. Her analysis invites scholars to examine the consequences of locals’ appropriation of biomedical ideas, thus contributing to bridging the gap between the colonial and post-colonial periods.
Decolonisation and Legacies of Colonialism
Heaton's Black Skin, White Coats picks up where Amster left off by squarely addressing the impact of nationalism and decolonisation on health care in Africa. His primary concern is to examine ‘the transformations in psychiatric theory and practice that accompanied the decolonization of European empires in the mid-twentieth century’.Footnote 24 Using Nigeria as a case study, Heaton makes three arguments. First, he contends that the transformations in Nigerian psychiatry were linked to the socio-political and historical contexts of the time.Footnote 25 Second, he demonstrates that Nigerian psychiatrists were actively engaged in (re)defining modernity in ways that incorporated the Third World. To this end, he engages with concepts of alternate modernities from the perspective of post-colonial Africa. Last and most significant is his argument that Nigerian psychiatrists were part of the large-scale changes of psychiatric discourse occurring at the international level.Footnote 26
The historiography on the history of medicine and colonialism has firmly established that local peoples shaped colonial regimes’ responses to health care during the period of formal empire. However, it remains less clear the extent to which individuals in the Third World influenced global discourse and practice, including, but not limited to, psychiatry and mental health. Heaton's work makes an important contribution to this end. He focused on Nigeria precisely because Nigerian psychiatrists were at the centre of transcultural psychiatry debates. Indeed, they developed unparalleled psychiatric institutions; virtually nothing similar could be found on the African continent. Furthermore, Nigerian psychiatrists showed that local Nigerian health care problems and solutions could offer valuable lessons to medical practitioners in the developing world and western Europe. In this manner, Heaton aggressively refutes the notion of ‘Western hegemony and of a unidirectional power flow’.Footnote 27 He shows that ‘the political, social, and cultural dynamics in the context of decolonization and independence in a non-Western space transmitted outward to transform psychiatric knowledge production processes in ways that have significantly influenced what cross-cultural psychiatrists think and do today’.Footnote 28
The narrative style that Heaton employs is effective. Black Skin, White Coats revolves around the central figure of Thomas Adeoye Lambo, an exemplary individual whose biography allows for Heaton to investigate the networks of psychiatrists in the region. Lambo was born in 1923 in Abeokuta and attended local mission schools as a young child. He went on to receive medical training at the University of Birmingham in the United Kingdom. After a brief interlude back in Nigeria in the early 1950s, he resumed his studies in London and specialised in psychiatry at the Maudsley Hospital. In 1954 his background earned him the position of head of Aro Mental Hospital, located a few short miles from his hometown. In this role, Lambo used a combination of his Western-style training and knowledge of the local community to generate innovative strategies for treating mental illness. For Lambo, incorporating local culture and outpatient networks into treatment plans were critical for short and long term success.
A cornerstone of Lambo's research was to fight against ‘racialized conceptualizations of culture that had characterized colonial psychiatry’.Footnote 29 According to Lambo, ‘there [was] no such thing as “African culture, and therefore ‘African mentality”’.Footnote 30 In his position at Aro Mental Hospital, the subject of chapter two, Lambo offered significant insights into mental health practices in south-western Nigeria among the Yoruba, which helped explain Nigerian cultural attitudes towards mental illness. But more notably, Lambo's research typically underscored the universality of ‘psychological disorder[s] across races and cultures rather than the differences’.Footnote 31 This transcultural position, which Heaton explores more fully in chapter four, was revolutionary at the time and seriously questioned many of the assumptions upon which medicine was predicated during the colonial period.
Heaton's last chapter, ‘The Paradoxes of Psychoactive Drugs’, did not make as compelling a case about the local and global connections involved in drug use in Nigeria between 1950 and 1980 as the previous chapters. Heaton argues that ‘discourses about drug use were simultaneously illustrative of political and social concerns specific to the Nigerian context of decolonization, modernization, and independence on the one hand, and growing international concerns about the medical and sociological role of drugs in society on the other’.Footnote 32 He focuses on cannabis use and shows how both Nigerian and German psychiatrists linked its mounting availability to foreign demand and to Nigeria's emergent export economy. Moreover, he suggests that local male migrant workers, who were dealing with stressful physical, economic and social demands, comprised the majority of users. Heaton's attempt to further his analysis about post-colonial Nigeria and insert it into global patterns of drug use is compelling. However, his assertions here did not adequately demonstrate the effect, if any, that Nigerians had on global discourse or practice of drug use.
Even though Heaton's analysis is limited to Nigeria, he believes he avoids the nationalist trap common to many studies of post-colonial Africa.Footnote 33 He writes that his work, ‘contributes to new trajectories in the post-colonial history of psychiatry and the history of post-colonial psychiatry in its emphasis on the blurring of the colonizer/colonized dichotomy, its negotiation of the national with the global and universal’, and ‘its recognition of the legacies of colonial structures in post-colonial psychiatry’.Footnote 34 In some ways, Heaton is heeding Frederick Cooper's call to rethink the distinction between the colonial and post-colonial periods and explore continuities over time. Colonialism, and all of the practices and ideologies that accompanied it, were not simply ‘turned off like a light switch’ when African governments raised new flags.Footnote 35
Black Skin, White Coats uses psychiatry as a lens through which to evaluate the continuities and changes of colonialism. It has broad appeal and encourages scholars to move ‘away from an outdated reliance on the development and spread of “Western” psychiatry and towards a theorization of a “global” psychiatry that recognizes a greater diversity of actors within psychiatric science and the complexity of flows of people, knowledge, and information that characterized the discipline particularly since the 1950s’.Footnote 36 As a result, the methodological approach therein is ripe for comparison to different diseases and public health concerns in other contexts.
The books discussed in this review represent exciting new directions in the history of medicine and open up different ways of conceptualising formal European rule and its aftermath. By turning our attention to individuals and medical networks at the local and international levels, historians can better understand how and why particular health care policies were implemented in western Europe and its colonies in the twentieth century. Given the growing number of available archival sources on the decades after which African countries became independent, scholars can begin to bridge the gap between the colonial and post-colonial periods and to analyse the legacies of colonial medical governance and control. Moreover, historians of medicine will be able to further probe the ideological continuities in health care policies, which will provide important insights into how and why states and international organisations respond to health care crises such as the recent Ebola outbreak in West Africa.
It is also an opportune moment to reassess the ideologies and medical practices that informed many of the post-colonial policies. As all of the authors reviewed here showed, there was a constant interplay between European medical practitioners and the local populations over whom they ruled. These historical roots are essential to any study on the relationship between newly sovereign countries and their former European ruler. Much work remains to be done in this area, particularly on the development of national health industries, training and technical assistance, exchange programs and international humanitarian organisations. As Heaton showed through his examination of Thomas Lambo, African and Third World actors, although few in number, especially in the 1950s and 1960s, were at the centre of international intellectual and medical networks that made discoveries with global significance. Now, historians of medicine and science are tasked with uncovering more of these kinds of stories, ones which place the local, national, regional and international in dialogue with one another and which emphasise continuity and adaptation rather than a neat and absolute rupture between the colonial and post-colonial periods. These new approaches offer scholars fresh and innovative ways of understanding health, wellness, family, the state and the world in the twenty-first century.
