This book is part of a long-term and wider effort by a group of academics at the School of Management of the Universidad de los Andes (Bogotá, Colombia) to develop studies on Colombian business history. In a process that started decades ago, this group has made important contributions to the previously nonexistent (and still small) academic field of business history with a series of publications and the training of young scholars. This volume focuses on the life of Enrique Luque Carulla, one of the most successful pioneers of marketing in Colombia. The first half of the book includes Gabriel Pérez's detailed chapter on how this project came to light; Carlos Dávila's discussion on how business historical studies can take advantage of theoretical advances on the study of entrepreneurship; José Miguel Ospina's chapter on the evolution of marketing as a science and the main concepts readers should consider; and two chapters by Luis Fernando Molina, the first a description of how the interviews with Luque Carulla were conducted and organised, the second a chronology of the main events affecting Luque Carulla's life. The second half of the book consists of a series of chapters in which Luque Carulla narrates his life through interviews with the authors. These chapters are organised chronologically and by the industries in which Luque Carulla was involved. Two chapters focus on his early life and the vicissitudes faced by his father, who migrated to Colombia from Spain just before the Civil War, and ten chapters concentrate on his life as entrepreneur.
Luque Carulla's first-person accounts focus mostly on the development of the Carulla supermarket, the first of its kind in Colombia. He shows how this chain introduced the concept of self-service in Colombia in the 1950s and used for the first time the latest advances in inventory management technology and marketing. For Luque Carulla, the introduction of the supermarket in Colombia and the adoption of cutting-edge marketing techniques contributed to the overall modernisation of the country. His contributions in marketing, however, had to adapt to the particularities of Colombia, such as the existence of the hordes of street vendors that are present in most Latin American cities, especially in bus stations or at traffic lights. Luque Carulla shows how some of the early promotions of goods that his company wanted to introduce were carried out through these members of the informal economy. His narrative about the evolution of his supermarket also shows the social changes taking place in Colombia in the second half of the twentieth century, such as the increasing number of adult women joining the labour force (therefore reducing the number of people shopping during office hours), the increasing literacy and urbanisation rates that made marketing campaigns more effective, and the increasing capacity of working-class people to shop at supermarkets instead of the traditional marketplaces. His story also shows the effects of economic policy, from protectionism before the 1980s (which limited the diversity of goods available in the supermarket, but made subsidised credit for modernisation available) to an open market after the 1980s (which increased the number of imported goods available in the stores and allowed stores to buy new equipment abroad). The success of the Carulla supermarkets made Luque Carulla a very influential person in the business world, in academia and in political circles, and he used this to promote his vision of improving the formal training of people in charge of sales and marketing in order to contribute to the country's development.
The authors could have exploited even better the wealth of information provided in Luque Carulla's personal story with a stronger connection between the theoretical discussions provided by Dávila's and Ospina's opening chapters and the second half of the book. The book could also have benefited from footnotes in Luque Carulla's personal story to guide an international audience not familiar with Colombia's geography, cultural characteristics or political history (a shortcoming also present in Molina's chronology). These limitations do not reduce the value of this volume, however.
Scholars interested in Latin American business history can benefit from this book in different ways. The personal accounts of Luque Carulla can provide a wonderful oral-history primary source by one of Colombia's main entrepreneurs in the second half of the twentieth century. The book includes some images of the material Carulla used in its early years to teach Colombians how to use a supermarket, and these will be valuable to scholars interested in the evolution of consumer culture in Latin America. This company and its leader created changes in Colombian's consumer patterns that can be contrasted with Julio Moreno's findings for the case of Sears in Mexico in his book Yankee Don't Go Home (2007).
Una mirada a la historia del mercadeo en Colombia covers a period of dramatic economic changes that also occurred in the rest of Latin America, such as the adoption of protectionist policies and their subsequent abandonment in the 1980s, therefore providing a first-person account of these changes from a member of the Colombian business elite. In short, this is a welcome addition to the narrow but rapidly growing field of business history in Latin America.
