Lisa Hopkins reads the history of Tudor and Stuart succession through the lens of “succession plays.” Such works, she argues, do not form “a discrete body of drama which can be classified easily and solely as such,” but rather share a tendency to mobilize problematic political vocabularies and to raise complex questions of governance “in particularly urgent ways” (16). According to Hopkins, the commercial stage allowed England to address practical tensions surrounding succession, to explore cultural fantasies about monarchy, and to participate in wish fulfillment. Drawing on a vast knowledge of European lineage, Hopkins urges scholars to recognize that conflicts surrounding English succession continued well beyond Elizabeth I's reign.
Chapter 1, “Christopher Marlowe and the Succession to the English Crown,” emphasizes Marlowe's Tamburlaine as a play that represents “the immediate success and the ultimate failure of the attempt to build and secure an empire” (24). This focus, combined with Tamburlaine's intense intertextual overlaps with plays such as Locrine and Gorbuduc, positions Marlowe at the heart of philosophical debates about the principles of effective governance. Chapter 2, “Romans and Fairies,” meditates on the link between two seemingly disparate figures and the communities they respectively represent: Measure for Measure's Pompey and A Midsummer Night's Dream's Oberon. Positing a shared literary lineage that connects the Romans and the fairies of these two plays to Julius Caesar, Hopkins argues that theatrical references to Pompey and Oberon evidence the usefulness of exploring succession debates through historical and fantastical perspectives. By existing in the “safely past and the never real,” fairies and ancient Romans could covertly represent contemporary questions about the challenges facing new rulers (56). Chapter 3, “Robin Hood and the King's Two Bodies,” shifts attention to yet another literary figure. Tracing the character of Robin Hood through plays of the 1590s–1630s, Hopkins asserts that the outlaw's defense of the common voice and his belief in good governance over hereditary claims to power offer a powerful critique of James I's and Charles I's assertions of divine right. Chapter 4, “Female Transmission, Female Taint,” turns to questions of gender and inheritance, arguing that women's roles as wives and queens shape two major succession plays from very different genres: Henry V and As You Like It. In each, audiences experience worlds of wish fulfillment in which virtuous women assist in the emergence of strong male governors whose authority is both inherited and deserved. Chapter 5, “Antonios and Stewards,” opens with Hopkins's claim that the continued popularity into the Jacobean period of succession plays such as Julius Caesar reveals a continued preoccupation with the Stuarts' questionable hold on the throne. Examining Twelfth Night, The Tempest, and The Duchess of Malfi, Hopkins argues that this trio of plays—because of its historical relationship to Elizabeth's reign and Prince Henry's death, and because of its deployments of Antonio characters who harken back to the Portuguese succession crisis—comments on Charles's rise as heir. Chapters 6 and 7, “One King, Two Kingdoms?” and “John Ford and the 1630s,” explore how the problem of doubling—of kingdoms and of princes—in plays such as Cymbeline and Perkin Warbeck drew attention to Jacobean and Caroline political debates about uniting or splitting England and Scotland.
Throughout the book, Hopkins displays a nuanced familiarity with monarchical lineage stretching across early modern Europe; this is both a strength and a weakness of her volume. When Hopkins uses this knowledge to read plays critically, discussing the allusive importance of names, and performing detailed comparative studies of vocabulary across plays (as she does in Chapter 4), the argument is grounded and strong. Yet historical knowledge, at times, overwhelms Hopkins's readings, leading the discussion into a tangle of plays and events that would benefit from more in-depth examination, or toward intense speculation about the relationships and lives of historical figures whom the plays potentially represent. In these moments, the argument's unstable grounding manifests itself in the prose, with multiple cues urging readers to doubt what “may well have been,” “can be seen as alluding to,” “seems likely,” or “might well look . . . conceivably like a reminder” (19, 21, 30, 62). The structures of the chapters themselves mirror these moments of strength and weakness: although speculative Chapters 1 and 3 do not provide an argumentative claim until their final pages, Chapters 4 and 5 are front-loaded, clear, and logically ordered. Regardless of inconsistent organization, however, the chapters never fail to remind readers that early modern drama emerged out of, and engaged with, a complex set of cultural and political concerns.
