The use of psychoanalytic theory to think about crime tends to yield scholarship on the motivation for deviancy. David Gurnham's new book represents, appropriately, a diversion from the norm. Grounded in an understanding of legal discourse as an expression of unconscious desire, it provides a richly evocative text that should attract a variety of readers interested in contextual approaches to law. Whilst primarily concerned with crime and sexual desire, his argument is informed by reflections on literature and cultural studies. His take on a series of key narratives – the criminalisation of HIV, sexual exploitation, and erotic asphyxiation – is an absorbing exposition of Freudian subtext.
Gurnham's own desire is to address the lack at the centre of existing discourses, and to undertake alternative readings to prevailing accounts of well-known debates. He thus considers, for example, whether criminal approaches to HIV transmission are in fact a consequence of unconscious efforts to deny the ‘reality’ of death, rather than an unpleasant result of legal liberalism. Similarly, whilst much of the commentary on the trials of Asian men accused of sexually exploiting women and girls in Rochdale and Oldham in 2012 centred on issues of race and gender, Gurnham supposes that public condemnation of the men masked repressed fantasies about the consumption of ‘white meat’. In so doing, he is concerned with the idea of absence, ‘that the judicial and scholarly narratives about the dangers of sex and sexuality are sites both of invention and of repression or strategic forgetting’ (p. 4).
Gurnham is, first, very much concerned with his methodological framework, largely because of the depth of suspicion aroused by Freud's work. Conscious of feminist critiques and questions about the explanatory substance of Freud's theories, he argues that the book is about cultural discourses and constructions, rather than truths. His project thus concerns reading Freud's writings as narratives rather than actual depictions of feelings and relations. The purpose is to draw out unconscious meanings rather than produce evidence of ‘actual’ intentions (in the acknowledgements, Gurnham asks that his son, were he to read this book, not take the Oedipal complex too literally!). He makes a good, detailed case for this eschewal of the ‘reality’ of Freud's observations in favour of this focus on narrative and metaphor. He argues: ‘Metaphors in law and literature serve in many ways as means of poetically enhancing our appeals to justice and fairness, but they may also serve as repressive substitutions (and hence as disguises and distortions) for the meanings that we do not want consciously to acknowledge’ (p. 40; emphasis in original).
Gurnham insists that psychoanalytic readings do shape and deepen our understanding of contemporary constructions of criminal behaviour. He acknowledges the hazards of venerating psychoanalysts as the ‘true’ sense-makers of the unconscious, or of the psyche in its entirety. Turning to the feminist critiques of Freud's works, he acknowledges concerns about his understanding of fixed gender roles, notwithstanding the contingency of the era in which he was writing, his inability to account for the ‘enigma’ of feminine sexuality, and the ‘more problematic’ (and more famous) assertions about ‘penis-envy’ and women's related passivity. Gurnham is also conscious of the criticisms of Freud's analysis of memories of child sex abuse, which he attributed to Oedipal fantasies rather than evidence of actual abuse. Without dismissing the dangers of literal interpretations of Freud's work, he continues to emphasise that his own focus is on techniques for exploring how language creates new lines of inquiry in respect of repressed memory and thought.
If Gurnham's inspiration is Freudian psychoanalysis and the enunciation of the repressed, his thematic interests are more prosaic. He is primarily concerned with the tensions between sexual agency and victimisation, autonomy and protection, and with problematising liberal notions of consent. As might be expected from a Freudian scholar and critic of criminal responses to sexual behaviour, Gurnham has his sights trained on carceral feminists in particular. The book is peppered with criticisms of discourse on sex and consent, and his (understandable) irritation at simplistic assertions and the dogma of female victimisation occasionally spills over onto the page. Although always conscious of the harm experienced by women due to inequality and power imbalances, and the threat of exploitation, he has little time for those feminists who disavow the context in which consent takes place. In Chapter 6 he is particularly concerned by feminists’ responses to the Canadian case R v. J.A (R. v. J.A [2011] SCC 28), and their endorsement of jail sentences for (male) ‘perpetrators’ of apparently consensual ‘rough sex’. In this case, a man was incarcerated for strangling his female sexual partner to unconsciousness and subsequently binding her and penetrating her anus with a dildo. Any initial revulsion at such acts is tempered by the female partner's testimony that she consented to the ‘erotic asphyxiation’ and its consequences. There may be little novelty here for those readers already familiar with such critiques, or feminist debates on Freud, although Gurnham's argument is set apart through his explanatory use of tales of the soul. The judgment in R v. J.A is justified, for example, according to an unconscious wish to limit the ‘possibility of contagion in acts of transgression’ (p. 121).
In his discussion of the criminalisation of HIV transmission (Chapter 3), Gurnham argues that this process of criminalisation is a ‘pointless’ state exercise based on misconceptions about infection, one being the suggestion that HIV is likely to be fatal. As such, we should not try to find any public health or legal rationale for this punitive development; instead, the answer lies in a psychoanalytic understanding of the ‘fantasy of choice’ over death that is embedded in our collective unconscious. This argument that the criminalisation of transmission satisfies a ‘wish-fulfilment’, and the desire to control death through an eschewal of human fallibility, is well explained and insightfully illustrated. Although the claim that HIV transmission is better understood in terms of its unconscious cultural symbolism is persuasive, it inevitably marginalises other explanations such as how being seen to be ‘tough’ on such behaviour might serve expressive, political ends. Gurnham does not lay claim to a ‘true’ reading of the subject, however. Rather, he aims to offer a ‘credible alternative narrative that gets beneath the usual debates’ (p. 70).
Gurnham discusses repressed sexual fantasies in the narratives of race and culture pervading the reports of exploitation and rape among girls and young women in the north of England. Nine men from Rochdale and Oldham were convicted of offences such as rape and sex trafficking in May 2012, and the British media was awash with opinion and commentary about the racial dimension of the crimes. Gurnham argues that such commentary repressed class-based concerns about sex and sexuality, providing a potentially pivotal re-imagining of the relationship between sex, race and class that could prove to be a very fertile future line of inquiry. He also suggests a perverse enjoyment in the public consumption of such reports due to feelings of fascination, judgment and condemnation. Our shame at such enjoyment finds its expression in the condemnation of people who knew about such crimes – who watched and yet did not intervene. Gurnham illustrates his argument with reference to cultural works by Susanna Moore, the Marquis de Sade and J. G Ballard. He writes: ‘Both legal and literary narratives together attest … to a dark underbelly of sexuality that, in being repressed, quietly insinuates itself in apparently natural assumptions about the consequences for certain girls and women of heterosexual desire … they induce anxiety by drawing attention to these assumptions and the violence they engender’ (p. 108).
As a reader with only an introductory understanding of psychoanalytic theory, I found this book to be provocative and enriching. Gurnham does not forgo clarity for the sake of conceptual depth, and he manages to blend a complex set of narratives and methodological endeavours. However, those hoping for a novel psychoanalytic reading of the law, or perhaps a Freudian exegesis of legal texts, may be disappointed. This book is unashamedly, perhaps one might say irrepressibly, about sex, sexuality and crime, rather than an addition to the still fairly limited volume of work on the relationship between psychoanalysis and law in general. This should not be understood as a criticism, since Gurnham never claims to be doing otherwise. The ending was, on the other hand, abrupt: there was no overall conclusion to bring the book's distinct threads together, and I would have liked to finish with some sense of cohesion regarding Gurnham's overall thesis. But then perhaps it is only right that a book so driven by lack should conclude with an absence. There is, in any case, much to commend in this thoughtful and novel take on some key debates in criminal approaches to sexual behaviour.
