The importance of sports as an industry (already at multi-billion dollars), its obvious worldwide popularity, growing interest in and investment by the media, and heavy governmental involvement, coupled with a high availability of data, led to a rise in the number of contributions of economic literature to the study of sports. These studies bring together theoretical and empirical approaches covering almost every area in microeconomics. Applications typically emphasize topics in public finance, industrial organization, or labor markets.
Richard Pomfret (Professor of Economics at the University of Adelaide) and John K. Wilson (Senior Lecturer, School of Commerce at the University of South Australia) offer us an interesting perspective of sports economics issues through the lens of economic history. The book gathers relatively independent essays and presents them with the intent of providing insight into the history of sports.
The book examines in turn: (i) how rising revenues, together with globalization, were catalysts to the professionalization of sports from the mid-1800s; (ii) the fact that despite foreign players’ high average productivity, they have had very short tenures in the Nippon Professional Baseball League; (iii) a detailed look into the history of the Tour de France (while the largest events in sports are characterized by multi-sport competition or by a knockout tournament within a single sport, the Tour de France has reached similar status with one event within a single sport); (iv) the use of evidence between 1920 and 1983 to explore the relationship between crowd attendance and how competitive the South Australian National Football league was in that time period; (v) (chapter 6) one of the major issues related to stadiums, that they are very large investments typically financed with taxpayers’ money, but then seldom used (the contributors look into how, in Australia, cricket and football have prospered by subsidizing each other with ground sharing); (vi) the role of employers as facilitators in the provision of sports in Britain, going back to the beginning of the twentieth century; and (vii) labor market discrimination, the central topic in the final chapter. The authors of this chapter look into the possibility of labor-market discrimination against French-Canadian hockey players in the National Hockey League.
Being a collection of separate essays, there is always the risk of the book’s lacking unity or that some of the chapters overlap with each other. In this work, the authors try to avoid that risk with a well-thought-out introductory chapter and epilogue, but, unfortunately, I think they fall short in the attempt. The one general theme of this work is to provide insight into the history of sports, but each chapter is really a very separate look at a specific sport and context, lacking interdependence and connection. There is no real lesson from one chapter that should be used in the understanding of the following one. As for the concern about some of the topics being covered more than once, chapters 3 and 8 both revolve around player discrimination and, in spite of the authors’ attempt “to provide insight into the development and history of sport across the world” (p. 1), three of the eight essays concentrate only on Australia’s history of sports. While this is not to say Australia’s rich history in sports should be set aside, a greater diversity with either the countries or sports used in the text could/should have been used.
That having been said, one should not discard the book immediately. As the authors put it, “The contents are, of course, partial and selective” (p. 5), and “The intention is to highlight the wide range of possibilities once sports economists look to the past for evidence” (p. 145). I felt that the chapters on the “professionalization of sports” (chapter 2), “ground sharing” (chapter 6), and “worker’s playtime” (chapter 7) accomplished particularly well that objective. While, in some other chapters, the historical perspective is the mere fact that the analysis covers a span of many years, in those three chapters the reader is immersed in the history behind the issue approached and learns how historical events help the understanding of the sports economic issue being studied. That is refreshing and uncommon to the most current sports economics literature, and could be an influential reference to authors to come.
In conclusion, the book highlights the use of economic history in the understanding of specific sports issues. My belief is that this book will be met with interest by historians of economics and sports economists in general. This could very well be a starting point to a closer look to more important (based on viewership and money involved) sports such as soccer, basketball, or the National Football League, as well as more inclusive worldwide events like the World Cup in soccer or the Olympic games.
