This book is an erudite and imaginative rereading of al-Ghazali's vast intellectual and spiritual legacy with a view to demonstrating its lasting relevance to the intellectual debates within the contemporary Muslim community. The book consists of an introduction, nine chapters, and a conclusion followed by a glossary, an index, and a bibliography. The author is absolutely right in emphasizing al-Ghazali's towering stature in and long-ranging influence on Sunni Islam. For some he is nothing short of a cult figure: until recently in the Shafiʿi areas of Yemen, copying his masterpiece, Ihyaء ʿulum al-din, was considered to be not just an act of piety but a pass to paradise. Moosa probably would not appreciate this belief, which goes against the grain of his project to bring out the creative potential of al-Ghazali's insights into the meaning of faith, religious ethics, and soteriology.
In unpacking al-Ghazali's complex and voluminous oeuvre, the author relies on three methodological premises. First, taking his cue from Levi-Strauss (p. 36), Moosa declares al-Ghazali to be a bricoleur, namely, an intellectual who strove to revive Sunni Islam by intricately combining ostensibly incompatible and often mutually hostile forms of knowledge from apodictic/philosophical and nomocentric/theological to poetic and mystical. In so doing, according to Moosa, he was able to remain within the confines of mainstream Sunni Islam while producing “a coherent and profoundly refigured” version of it (p. 38). Second, building on the idea of bricolage, Moosa describes al-Ghazali as a “threshold thinker,” namely one who positioned himself “at the threshold of multiple disciplines and currents of thought.” This in-between vantage point allowed him to venture “outside the mainline currents, raiding archives of knowledge in order to see how he could reinforce the positive aspects of the traditions he had inherited” (p. 267). Third, naturally flowing from the idea of the intellectual threshold is Moosa's vision of al-Ghazali as a “stranger” (gharīb) whose voluntarily chosen exile (a physical “removal from one's ancestral land, place of birth, kinship, or nationality,” p. 275) allowed him to step back and see the entire Islamic intellectual edifice of his age in a new light. In the same way as the Prophet's hijra led to the creation of a new, buoyant religion and polity, al-Ghazali's withdrawal to Syria and Palestine resulted in the articulation of an original ethical, moral, and spiritual teaching aimed at reviving Sunni Islam.
Resting his narrative on these three methodological premises and availing himself of the latest analytical tools of postcolonial and subaltern studies, Moosa provides a sophisticated and nuanced examination of al-Ghazali's thought. He is particularly fascinated with al-Ghazali's painstaking effort to spiritualize law and to make it an internalized conviction of the believer rather than something mechanically imposed on him/her and thus equally mechanically performed. Apart from giving the medieval thinker his due, Moosa explicitly invites contemporary Muslim intellectuals to make creative use of what he calls al-Ghazali's “heterology” (multiple and often contradictory ways of thinking) with a view to “negotiating and struggling with the hegemonic and colonial knowledge traditions.” Moosa identifies these traditions as authoritarian Islamic “maximalism”/fundamentalism and rootless modernizing “Westoxication” (pp. 62–63) on the one hand, and “the tenacious legacy of Orientalism” (p. 61) on the other hand. He holds their proponents responsible for the closure and subsequent “mummification” of the originally dynamic and flexible Islamic intellectual discourse as represented by al-Ghazali and a few other thinkers, such as ʿAyn al-Qudat al-Hamadhani (d. 1131). The goal of creatively appropriating al-Ghazali's legacy is, in Moosa's words, “to discover a subjectivity that is competent to will a paradigmatic transition within Islam” (p. 40). This is a noble goal indeed. Whether it is achievable and whether it holds out “the hope of a future marked by friendship and just coexistence—as a real possibility among the plurality of discursive communities” (p. 44) is a different matter.
In general, this reviewer finds Moosa's analysis of al-Ghazali's legacy persuasive and sophisticated. He is less convinced by the second aspect of this intellectual project, namely, an attempt by the author to modernize al-Ghazali's thought and to bring it in line with postmodern expectations and sensitivities. This attempt is evident in his painstaking efforts to make sense out of al-Ghazali's vociferous condemnation and excommunication (takfīr) of Ismaʿili philosophers and antinomian Sufis (some of whom, in his view, also deserved capital punishment, pp. 204–5). In fact, as the author himself has demonstrated, hardly any class of Muslim intellectuals has escaped al-Ghazali's opprobrium—a fact that puts him in the same camp with his Hanbali critics, Ibn al-Jawzi (d. 1201) and Ibn Taymiyya (d. 1328), whom Moosa considers to be typical representatives of a pedestrian, stick in the mud nomocentrism and scholasticism. Seen in the context of his epoch and intellectual culture, al-Ghazali's anathematization of his political and intellectual opponents is quite natural; he has no need of Moosa's absolution. However, it is hardly appropriate for the individual whom Moosa sees as a model and inspiration for “a paradigmatic transition” within postcolonial Islamic intellectual discourse, hence the author's predicament. His desire to make al-Ghazali a man of and for our age finds a vivid expression in his choice of images and terminology. Thus, in discussing God's plan in regard to creation, al-Ghazali, in Moosa's words, “had in mind a score, an orchestra, and a conductor”—an image that no medieval Muslim thinker could have possibly entertained. In many instances (e.g., p. 255) in which al-Ghazali addresses competition among various theological and juridical madhāhib (schools of law), Moosa translates this medieval term as “discursive tradition,” which makes al-Ghazali's deliberations sound more modern than they are. Examples of this tendency to “modernize” al-Ghazali are quite numerous.
Now a couple of minor quibbles. In a book that has the word “imagination” in its title, one expects to find at least a passing reference to Henry Corbin's seminal Creative Imagination in the Sufism of Ibn ʿArabi and to a detailed discussion of the role of imagination in Ibn ʿArabi's epistemology by William Chittick in his monumental studies Sufi Path of Knowledge and Self-Disclosure of God. Neither is mentioned in the main text or the bibliography, which is unfortunate. In general, a comparison between these two great thinkers would be very illuminating. However, this is a project for the future. In the meantime, Moosa should be thanked for his highly erudite and imaginative reexamination of al-Ghazali's thought world.
