The study of the role of politics in Walt Whitman's writings has come a very long way in a very short time. As recently as 1989 critics like Betsy Erkkila actually had to make a case for Whitman's engagement with and relevance to political discourse. Up to that point, “The Good Gray Poet” was still being read largely in terms of transcendence and transhistorical spiritual yearning. But over the past twenty years Whitman's politics have taken center stage in the academy. Heeding the barbaric yawps of Erkkila, George Kateb, Martha C. Nussbaum, and Richard Rorty, among others, recent scholars have shown how urgently Whitman felt the politics of his day – and how urgent his writings can be for our own. A Political Companion to Walt Whitman casts its titular subject in a role he long coveted and claimed: the poet of democracy. The volume draws together a distinguished group of political theorists, all of whom take seriously the contributions Whitman's work might make to our understanding of democratic culture and the politics of identity. The collection is part of a new series from the University Press of Kentucky, Political Companions to Great American Authors, which posits canonical American literature as “one of the greatest repositories of the nation's political thought and teachings” (vii). Other collections in the series treat Henry Adams, Ralph Waldo Emerson, and Henry David Thoreau. (Here's hoping that volumes on Margaret Fuller and Frederick Douglass aren't far behind. Surely they, too, are “Great American Authors.”)
This is an unusual volume, in no small part because it considers an interdisciplinary object (i.e. Whitman's diverse writings) from a decidedly disciplinary perspective (i.e. political theory). In its opening pages, John E. Seery identifies the collection's central provocation: “What claim – what authority, what expertise, what insight, what right – might the scholarly subfield known as political theory have on poetry?” (5). I am pleased to report that, on the basis of these essays, political theory can lay a strong claim on Whitman's poetry. Largely eschewing the age-old “philosophy-versus-poetry” debate, these theorists engage Whitman's verse – and a good bit of his prose – with verve.
Not surprisingly, then, A Political Companion to Walt Whitman has many strengths. Chief among these is its disciplinary focus, which results in a number of novel readings of Whitman's works. (To no one's surprise, political theorists read poetry differently than do literary critics.) Indeed, the Whitman that emerges from these pages is at times strikingly unfamiliar, and the strongest essays put him into strange new conversations with thinkers like Plato, Edmund Burke, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Thomas Paine, Alexis de Tocqueville, John Dewey, Richard Rorty, Gloria Anzaldúa, and Barack Obama. By approaching Whitman from new angles, essays like Cristina Beltrán's “Mestiza Poetics: Walt Whitman, Barack Obama, and the Question of Union” make a vital, because idiosyncratic, contribution to Whitman studies. For instance, Jane Bennett's “The Solar Judgment of Walt Whitman,” which offers a luminous reading of a single, sunny image in Whitman's poetry and prose, opens up his political project in dramatic ways. Equally welcome here are essays on Whitman's relationship with the city by Jason Frank and Michael J. Shapiro, both of which are engaging, wide-ranging, and insightful. Finally, Morton Schoolman's feverish run through Democratic Vistas (1870) is exceedingly helpful. Few recent critics have tackled Whitman's prose magnum opus, and Schoolman is an apt, if breathless, guide.
The signal weakness of this companion is the uneven quality of its essays. Three of the chapters are reprinted from earlier sources: George Kateb's justly famous 1990 essay “Walt Whitman and the Culture of Democracy,” which is a lodestar for many of the other essays; a contemporary response to Kateb by Nancy L. Rosenblum; and Martha C. Nussbaum's “Democratic Desire: Walt Whitman.” While it is handy to have these three fine pieces in the same place, they set up undue expectations for the rest of the volume. The ten original essays vary greatly in length, tone, and ambition. (In truth, a couple feel like slightly expanded conference papers or invited lectures.) Although Seery has done an admirable job of rationalizing the essays into thematic units, the collection never really comes together – a fact its editor readily admits in his rather anxious introduction: “The individual essays, however, really ought to be read on their own, in their own right, rather than as contributions mainly to a whole” (10). So it goes, I suppose, with collections of scholarly essays in the twenty-first century. Nonetheless, scholars working in a range of modes and disciplines will find much of interest and use in this productive companion. If nothing else, it will go a long way to ensuring that we never return to the apolitical, mystical Walt Whitman of yore.
