Sacred Spaces and Religious Traditions in Oriente Cuba is certainly a contribution to the limited repertoire of modern Afro-Cuban religious studies, mostly due to its ethnographic focus on practitioners in the oriental provinces of the island, not infrequently overlooked in favour of Eastern-centred forms of religiosity such as santería. Indeed, this work is explicit in its exclusion of Yoruba-based practices such as the well-known reglas de ocha and reglas de Ifá, upon which most scholarship of Afro-Cuban religion has been based, and this may be one of its strengths. Resulting from almost ten years of field research led by the author, and conducted by her graduate students from the African Atlantic Research Team of Michigan State University, in collaboration with the Casa del Caribe in Santiago de Cuba, this book is an exploration of four types of Afro-Cuban religious practices or ‘sacred lifestyles’ (p. 15) that have a visible following and thus arguably impact an understanding of the ‘Oriente’ as a distinct spiritual domain. These are palo monte/palo mayombe, vodú, espiritismo, and perhaps most enigmatically, muertéra bembé de sao, a set of ritual activities Dodson claims shares important characteristics with the first three, but which she speculates may also stand on its own as a separate religious tradition. Given that no ethnographic account of this last practice has ever been produced, Dodson's descriptions of muertéra bembé de sao, as admittedly inconclusive as they may be, constitute a potentially exciting basis for further research.
On a general level this work is commendable for its attention to the particularities of colonialism and slavery, especially for apprehending the Oriente's religious processes as continuous with and embedded in these histories (rather than as disembodied cosmologies). One concern, however, is that Dodson's over-reliance on notions such as the survival of an Africa-based ‘cosmic orientation’ (p. 14, for example) in Cuba's Oriente not only risks presenting too neat a process of ‘transculturation’ from Africa to the New World, but also underestimates the ritual and cosmological fluidity that underpins Afro-Cuban religiosity more broadly. Religion does not just position the individual cosmically and existentially, providing the believer with corresponding ideas of time, space and spirits. It instrumentally ‘resolves’ social and material quandaries of the everyday sort, to which those spirits are summoned to respond. It does so precisely because the individual is his own ‘sacred space’, often occupying multiple ritual and religious roles – paths that are stipulated by the dead, among other beings. A consideration of such problematics is for the most part absent, and the reader is left with the desire to read less about history and more about situated religious engagement and habitus. Overall, however, the text is informative and lucid. Most of all it is sincere in its aspirations, and its focus on the phenomenology of space does seem to avoid some of the pitfalls of more sociologising stances.
The book is divided into three sections, the last two of which deal with the author's and her team's ethnographic findings. In the first part, composed of three chapters, Dodson explains why and how an attention to the spaces constructed by practitioners is insightful. Furnishing the reader with a basic history of Cuban colonisation and creolisation, especially with a view to underlining the cultural importance of the Bakongo (Bantu-speaking) slave populations in the Oriente, Dodson articulates what she sees as the central commonalities between an ‘African cosmic orientation’ (p. 39) and contemporary practices, in Chapter 2. Her thesis is that many of the elements of ‘Africa-based understandings’ (p. 47), which mostly arrived with slaves in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, remain not just relevant but constitutive of Oriente practitioners' religious spaces and experiences. An interesting if problematic issue is the author's concern with time and memory, where the Oriente's sacred spaces are seen to communicate, ‘present, express, and embody a special appreciation of Africa-based orientation and its accompanying understandings of past time’ (pp. 50–1). Another crucial domain is that of ancestors and the spirits of the deceased, and of the naturalness of possession as a form of revelation.
So, Dodson asks in the final chapter of Part I, what do sacred spaces do? They set community boundaries, she argues, and they serve to ‘re-member’ (p. 63) participants of a tradition, to define the aesthetic foundations of these traditions, and to inspire creative and meaningful acts. Sacred spaces are also sites of spirit manifestation and materialisation, and here the author could have given us more on the kind of ‘work’ involved in achieving these presences. Rather, she posits sacred spaces as ‘visual representations of a common, collective body of knowledge’ (p. 62).
Part II deals more specifically with religious practice – namely, palo monte/palo mayombe, vodú and espiritismo. The historical formation of each of these is examined, particularly the role of palenques (zones of liberation) and cofradías (brotherhoods) in sedimenting Haitian and Congolese cosmic heritages, as well as the influence of American and European spiritualist movements on the development of espiritismo, whose characteristically ‘oriental’ version, espiritismo de cordón, Dodson expands on. While the significance of altars, water and spirit representations are examined in relation to this latter practice, Dodson mainly does justice to her concern with sacred spaces in her analysis of palo monte/palo mayombe, whose practitioners work the spirits of the dead in often grotesque-looking ngangas (recipients), and also in her analysis of models of the cosmos, of nature and micro-universes, all of which could point to a different conceptualisation of ‘space’. Not much has been written on Haitian communities and their descendents in Cuba – Dodson ties in the chapter on vodú quite nicely with some valuable ethnographic and historical data. Finally, in Part III she grapples with the project's wildcard: muertéra bembé de sao. At the end of the book one is left with the impression of having been introduced to some vital religious spaces and wonderful people, but all of this without having been told of the relationship between these spaces, nor about how these practices are rendered meaningful and consequent in contemporary Cuban society.
