In this study, Daniel Gitterman considers the implications of US tax and minimum wage policies on poverty rates among the working poor. Arguing that US policy aimed at addressing state support to the working poor must include analyses of such policies, and not only social welfare policy, he seeks to bridge political and policy analyses through a consideration of the politics involved in the construction of tax and minimum wage policies. He finds that the distributional goals of the Democratic and Republican Parties have shaped policy not simply for ideological reasons, but on the basis of partisan considerations regarding the benefits to constituencies and interest groups. Such considerations have shaped the political coalitions responsible for the development of policy and have led moderates within each party to be critical of both partisan negotiations and the eventual content of policy.
Gitterman offers a concise and impressively clear political history of the development of both tax and minimum wage policies in the United States. More importantly, his analysis effectively demonstrates how the policies must be understood in relation to each other in order to grasp their independent effectiveness as antipoverty tools. Reflecting his focus on the political process behind each policy's formation and implementation, Boosting Paychecks explains partisan positioning on proposed policies, internal divisions within parties, and the impact of partisan control in Congress and the White House on policy debate and formation. After introducing the reader to the origin and development of federal income tax and minimum wage policies through the 1960s in Chapters 2 and 3, Gitterman devotes single chapters to the policy particulars and political processes behind such policies during the Reagan/George H. W. Bush era (Chapter 4), the Clinton administration (Chapter 5), the George W. Bush administration (Chapter 6), and the first years of the Obama administration (Chapter 7).
The author's thoughtful and thorough analysis of the historical-political development of tax and wage policies is a unique contribution to analyses of antipoverty policy. As social welfare policy has become more politically contentious since the 1960s and the Great Society programs, income support for the working poor has increasingly been provided through policies such as the Earned Income Tax Credit (p. 87). Therefore, Gitterman's contribution to an understanding of federal antipoverty policy is clear: Tax and wage policy cannot be overlooked in discussions of aid to the working poor in the United States.
Gitterman might have made the book's contributions more explicit to readers by providing further discussion of the broader political and economic contexts in which these partisan policy debates occurred. Discussion of the public's views toward tax and wage policies, changes in the poverty rate, changes to social welfare programming, and the defunding of Great Society programs may have further contextualized the political nature of tax and wage policies for readers. For example, the author traces the political evolution of minimum wage policy beginning with the 1938 Fair Labor Standards Act, when it was presented as a mechanism for boosting pretax income for low-income workers. Even at its inception, the minimum wage was politically controversial and, in fact, did not include many low-wage workers. To pacify southern conservative Democrats, President Franklin D. Roosevelt included exemptions for agricultural and domestic industries from minimum wage coverage. Gitterman explains that these exemptions specifically excluded African Americans in the South, who were “politically weak” (p. 43). In fact, African Americans were explicitly disenfranchised politically in much of the South, and parts of the North, through the implementation and enforcement of Jim Crow voting laws. FDR's exemptions reflected a lack of accountability to the subset of constituents who would be disproportionally affected by the exemption—African Americans without citizenship rights living predominately in the South.
Though his analysis focuses on the partisan, and intraparty, divisions concerning tax and minimum wage policies, Gitterman makes reference to the relevance of other political actors in policy battles. For example, in Chapter 4, he explains that Democrats reached out to antipoverty groups during the Reagan administration to encourage them to focus on the implications of changing tax policies, not simply to focus their energies on resisting reductions in budgeting for cash assistance policies to the poor (p. 70). What was the relevance of organizations throughout the tax and minimum wage policy battles? What was the incentive for the Democrats to reach out to such groups? How did the groups respond? Such political questions are important and they unfortunately receive insufficient and undeveloped attention in the book.
In his concluding chapter, Gitterman summarizes his central finding—that since the 1980s, there has been a bipartisan consensus that working families should be the beneficiaries of aid (p. 141). However, he points to a consistent failure in attempts to increase the minimum wage. As he explains, since 1980, the minimum wage has “been below the federal poverty level for a full-time, full-year worker supporting a family of three” (p. 144). Although he convincingly explains the lack of political support for increasing the minimum wage, Boosting Paychecks pays little attention to the incentives that policymakers might have to increase the wage, or to pass tax policy, that benefits the working poor overall.
Such a discussion of incentives, including voting behavior among individuals at various income levels and shifts in public opinion concerning aid to the poor, might have strengthened the political analysis in the book. Who are the constituencies of Democrats and Republicans, in terms of income levels? Do low-wage earners vote at the same rates as their upper income counterparts who, as Gitterman explains, have been more likely to benefit from changes in tax policy? Are the interests of low-wage earners represented in policy debates as powerfully as those who benefit from tax incentives for businesses? Scholars have long established income-based biases in the US political system and it could have been helpful to discuss this literature. Additionally, such a discussion would have allowed Gitterman's analysis to contribute to a broader discussion of the implications of biased representation in the US political system.
Boosting Paychecks provides a clear and thorough analysis of tax and wage policies and the critical role such policies play in federal efforts to support the working poor. The book can thus serve as a useful launching point for scholars concerned with the multiple policy options, and political processes, geared toward decreasing income inequality in the United States.
