Pompeii never loses its capacity to enthrall and excite everyone: from academics to the general public, few are wholly immune to the potent mix of death, destruction, domesticity, and decadence on offer at the site. Over two million visit each year, but many more gain access to this slice of Roman history through other means, and in equally large numbers. A Day in the Life of Pompeii, an exhibition touring the southern hemisphere at the time of writing, was lauded as the most popular museum exhibit ever held in Australia (http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/a-day-in-pompeii-australias-most-popular-museum-exhibition/story-e6frg6of-1225791161563); it coincided with another large-scale North American travelling exhibition on Pompeii and the Roman Villa. Publications aimed at the popular market have also reached wide audiences, such as Alex Butterworth and Ray Laurence's Pompeii: The Living City (2005) and Joanne Berry's The Complete Pompeii (2007) — not to mention the bestselling novel, Pompeii, by Robert Harris (2003). Mary Beard, then, rides the crest of this wave, an eager audience safely assured; indeed, the book met with widespread acclaim among reviewers in the popular press. But while we might assume that this is another venture into an overcrowded field, Pompeii: the Life of a Roman Town distinguishes itself through a critical and lively approach, which will be of interest to students and professionals as much as to the interested amateur.
The tone is set by the introductory chapter. After accounting for the ‘power of the Pompeian dead’ (7) as one of the most ghoulishly fascinating elements of the site, B. sets out her methodological approach to the city. ‘“Our” Pompeii is not a Roman city going about its everyday business, then simply “frozen in time”, as so many guidebooks and tourist brochures claim. It is a much more challenging and intriguing place’ (15). Pompeii is frequently referred to as if it were a time capsule of Roman life that enables direct and unmediated access to the past, an idea that must be exposed for the seductive myth that it is. Moreover, she argues, we are confronted with a ‘Pompeii paradox’: ‘we simultaneously know a huge amount and very little about ancient life there’ (15).
What follows is a detailed but always engaging demonstration of what this really means, showing how the minutiae of the evidence unearthed at Pompeii can lead us into all sorts of misguided assumptions about daily life there, whilst simultaneously offering unique insights. The discussion proceeds literally from the ground up: after surveying the city's pre-79 history, successive chapters explore street life, domestic space and its decoration, trade and industry, politics, eating and drinking, leisure activities such as baths, brothels and theatre, religion, and finally death and burial. There is much that will enlighten popular audiences (such as the use of a series of frescoes to recreate ‘the colour, clutter and bric-a-brac of urban life’ (77), or the inventory of the assorted contents of a cupboard — from bits of jewellery to broken household utensils (90) — which will be familiar to anyone with similarly chaotic kitchen drawers). The book is rounded off with a brief but useful guide to visiting the site, as well as suggestions for further reading. Scholarly audiences, too, are likely to stumble across interesting snippets of new information, such as the fact that the cuirass on the statue of M. Holconius Rufus copies that of Mars in the Forum Augustum in Rome (209).
Throughout, B. adeptly shows how our investment in the idea of ‘Pompeii as time capsule’, along with a general unwillingness to acknowledge the gaps in our knowledge, has led to a proliferation of misunderstandings and exaggerations, particularly relating to the ‘hedonistic, excessive and raunchy stereotype’ (217) of the city, but also practices like the morning salutatio ritual, which she argues would have been a good deal more informal than is usually assumed (103). This ‘myth-busting’ approach has become something of a trademark, advertised on the jacket blurb, and fostered by B. herself in her popular Times blog (recently published as It's A Don's Life (2009); see e.g. 139 for ‘10 myths about the Romans exploded!’). Whilst not everyone can be expected to agree with the new interpretations offered, the value of this approach is that it points out to those most likely to believe in the myths the dangers of doing so. The non-specialist audience thereby has a valuable insight into the difficulties and dangers of interpreting ancient evidence, and into the fluctuating history of those interpretations. In this regard, both the archaeological history of the site and what we might call Pompeii's reception history are employed lightly but effectively as further examples of how contingent and mediated our approach to the city must be. (Particular emphasis is given to nineteenth-century interpretations of the site, especially the broad reach of Bulwer-Lytton's 1834 novel, The Last Days of Pompeii. By using the House of the Tragic Poet as the representative example of a Pompeian house (81f.) — as Bulwer-Lytton does — B. is able to point out how thoroughly the novel shaped subsequent ideas about the site and its inhabitants.) By encouraging a critical approach to the site, at the same time as gathering all the entertainingly juicy information that Pompeii has to offer, this book is sure to appeal to a wide audience.
