Justin McDaniel, already a winner of the prestigious Harry Bender Prize for Best First Book in Southeast Asian Studies (see Gathering leaves and lifting words; Histories of monastic education in Laos and Thailand, University of Washington Press, 2008), has now produced a second very different kind of book that clearly solidifies his position at the forefront of Thai and Lao Buddhist studies.
This new book includes seven distinct but well-integrated components. The first is McDaniel's story of his own personal ethnographic practice and discovery (a story which he describes as one of surprising experiences leading to ‘unexpected consequences’).
The second component is his focus on aspects of the history and character of ‘modern Thai Buddhism’ that have been largely either ignored or disparaged by Western-trained scholars. He makes a convincing case that these aspects of Thai Buddhist life have been and remain ‘mainstream’ phenomena that involve rich and poor, urbanites and villagers, the highly educated and the less educated, monks and the laity.
The third is his astute decision to focus attention on two closely interacting ‘figures’ who have played/are playing crucial roles in the religious life of modern Thai Buddhists — one a mid-nineteenth-century ‘magical monk’ (Somdet To), whom he identifies as a (perhaps the) dominant locus of Buddhist interest in modern Thailand; the other a closely related ‘lovelorn ghost’ whose very traditional story has become a framework for important components in contemporary Buddhist practice on the one hand and Buddhist-oriented popular cinema on the other.
The fourth component is his insistence on the importance of local Thai histories, traditions, and practices that need to be identified and interpreted in specifically local terms. In this connection he develops a strong critique of the kind of scholarship that interprets Thai Buddhism as a ‘syncretic’ amalgam that includes ‘Buddhist, Brahmanic, and indigenous components). And, especially in that context, he highlights the crucial importance of a growing corpus of excellent studies written in the Thai language by Thai scholars that have been (and are being) ignored by most scholars trained in the Western tradition of Buddhist scholarship.
The fifth component is his ongoing argument that the tradition of Buddhist practice on which he is focusing constitutes a ‘mainstream’ element that does not focus on ‘other worldly’ (lokottara) ideals or concerns. Rather it relies on texts, objects, and practices that are associated, in very pragmatic ways, with what are taken to be the most positive aspects of this-worldly life — notably (but by no means exclusively) ‘security, heritage, graciousness, and abundance’. (Here it is important to note the resonance with Steven Collins' Nirvana and other Buddhist felicities: Utopias of the Pali imaginaire (see my review in Journal of Religion, January 2000).
The sixth component (and in some ways the most important) is McDaniel's adaptation of an ethnographic ‘method’ (referenced in one strand of its early development as ‘ethnomethodology’) that has not — to my knowledge — been previously utilised, either in Southeast Asian studies or in Buddhist studies. This is a method that was originally generated within the discipline of sociology — but in the tradition of Emile Durkheim rather than that of Max Weber; and subsequently developed in a more anthropological vein by more recent scholars such as Max Garfinkle and Michael Carithers. In McDaniel's formulation this approach focuses on ‘individuals’ rather than cultural abstractions; on ‘actions’ these individuals perform rather than the ideas they hold; on the ‘technologies’ of action they develop rather than the values they honour; and (most important of all) on the complex of ‘repertoires’ that they construct and utilise in order to deal with the realities they face.
Finally, the seventh component is McDaniel's articulation of the importance and character of material culture (primarily of ‘objects’ and their involvements in social interactions). In this context he includes a radically innovative approach to the study of art objects and art history on the one hand and a related gloss on the construction of personal repertoires on the other. (In my reading the highpoint of this segment of the book is a 23-page discussion entitled ‘Beyond commercialism: Thinking about amulets historically and materially.’)
Quite clearly The lovelorn ghost and the magical monk is a major, multifaceted contribution to Southeast Asian Studies and Buddhist studies on the one hand; and to the disciplines of sociology, anthropology and history of religions on the other. However, it is important to note that the previously neglected phenomena on which McDaniel focuses, and the new insights that he provides, are a complement to previous studies of modern Thai Buddhism rather than a substitute for them (as, at some points, McDaniel seems to imply).
