The heroine of the Rāmāyaṇa, Sita, has been given a lot of attention in recent years (Chakravarti: 1983, Kishwar: 2001, Pauwels: 2008, Gokhale & Lal: 2009, et. al.). The result of a conference organised by Mandakranta Bose at the Oxford Centre for Hindu Studies in 2014, The Other Rāmāyaṇa Women: Regional Rejection and Response goes further to uncover the neglected, reviled, and silenced “other” women of the Rāmāyaṇa. To uncover and amplify their voices, the collaborators in this volume have consulted an impressively diverse set of sources, from Vālmīki's Rāmāyaṇa, to Jain interpretations, to visual representations from South India, to Tibetan poems of the 20th century. This important volume contributes to both comparative Rāmāyaṇa scholarship and gender studies. Readers interested in literary history, art history, and the diversity of the tellings and retellings of the Rāmāyaṇa will all find something of interest here.
How does one interpret a history of gender in the post-Vālmīki Rāmāyaṇa tradition(s), when the various texts and sources of the tradition itself are so overtly male-centric? The editors and contributing authors conclude that textual and artistic adaptations are most easily carried out in contained episodes, often featuring these “other women”. Consequently, these pliable episodes reveal a great deal about the authors, artists, and audiences of the various versions of the Rāmāyaṇa. Women of the epic often govern or create certain “moments of crisis” that alter the presentation of the epic itself. Mandakranta Bose argues that although women feature in the various Rāmāyaṇas as mere helpers or stumbling-blocks for the male heroes, these “hindrances” often propel the narrative in the most substantial ways. The women at the centre of these instances of narrative manipulation are considered from different social and methodological perspectives in each chapter. As Bose tells us in the last chapter, we must look beyond the classical, national, and sometimes even the textual to find these marginal voices, even if they do not universally agree with each other.
In the introductory chapter, John Brockington frames the central argument. Specifically, what do structural and textual features reveal about these women? How do they mirror an ever-changing audience for the Rāmāyaṇa tradition across language, gender, and geography? In what way do these adaptations contribute to a long history of challenging the authoritative Rāmāyaṇa? Brockington's chapter leads us up to the non-Sanskrit expressions of the Rāmāyaṇa tradition as presented in later chapters.
Eva de Clercq and Mary Brockington introduce us to the way the Jains reframed the Rāmāyaṇa, and particularly the auxiliary women, to suit their cosmological and ethical world view. Vimalasūri's Paümacariyaṃ (c. 5th century), Raviṣeṇa's Padmapurāṇa (c. 7th century), and Svayambhūdeva's Paümacariu (c. 9th-10th century), amongst others, refute the overtly divine or demonic characters of the Hindu Rāmāyaṇas. All the characters are humanised and fall to the vices and social restrictions of ordinary humans. Even the demoness Śūrpaṇakhā is transformed into a regular person. The very human framing of women as mothers or as beings susceptible to lust and envy, reflectively emphasizes the internal conflicts of the heroes and villains and the ambiguity of Rāma and Rāvaṇa's supposed ethics.
Ulrike Roesler takes us to the Tibetan Plateau and to a lesser extent Central Asia and Mongolia, where readers might be surprised to learn of continued engagement in the Rāmāyaṇa tradition up to the 20th century. While this chapter gives an engrossing window into the diversity of the Rāmāyaṇa tradition, it diverges from the central purpose of the book. This was probably unavoidable owing to disparate nature of the Rāmāyaṇa tradition and the difficulty of coordinating an edited volume of this kind.
A middle portion of the book is devoted to the visual artistic renderings of the Rāmāyaṇa. John and Mary Brockington, and Rachel Loizeau-Pajaniradja discuss the role of visual narratives in the arts across South Asia, in both paintings and textiles, while Anna Dallapiccola argues for an “artists Rāmāyaṇa” through the consideration of South Indian mural and textile traditions. They argue that visual arts play an important role in determining which episodes of any regional tradition gain popularity and how limitations of artistic media (sculpture, etc.) might determine the narrative features. Because the episodes concerning these “minor” female characters are self-contained and transferable, they became favoured subjects for artists limited to a single panel of cloth or a solitary tableau to convey an enclosed narrative. Dallapiccola's analysis emphasizes mural paintings (c. 16th-19th century) and temple cloth ‘kalāmkari’ (pictorial embroidery) in South India. The famous disfigurements of Mantharā, Ayomukhī, and Śūrpaṇakhā at the hands of male heroes become favoured themes for representation in these traditions, revealing attitudes towards transgressive women of medieval South India.
We hear about the narrative voice of women in the Bengali and Braj Bhāṣā traditions from Mandakranta Bose and Imre Bangha, respectively. Bose discusses the Bengali Rāmāyaṇa of Candrāvatī (c. 16th century), one of the few Rāmāyaṇas written by a woman. Despite focusing on Sītā’s story, Bose argues that Candrāvatī’s Rāmāyaṇa is a bleak and pessimistic narrative in which both virtuous and malicious women suffer in a man's world, subjects of social constraint and fate. Imre Bangha, presents a very different kind of argument than the rest of the book. By carefully considering the editing choices and contested passages of Tulsīdās’ Kavitāvali (c. 17th century), he argues for reading in the presence of “other” women, beyond the narrative, as narrators and onlookers. He considers the disposition towards women of the male compilers of the various Kavitāvali manuscripts and their choices of whether to include these voices. This chapter is rigorous in its textual analysis and offers a different perspective on the reception and motivations for certain vernacular textual traditions to adapt their language and narratives.
In the concluding chapters, Mary Brockington and Mandakranta Bose assist the reader in grappling with the sheer volume of information about these “other women” from a variety of regional and temporal perspectives. Brockington focuses on a British fairy-tale retelling of the Rāmāyaṇa epic collected by Susette Taylor in Bhopal (c. 1895/6). She argues that the only consistent element of the Rāmāyaṇa tradition is inconsistency. The secondary women characters are manipulated so differently in various sources because of their disposability. They can change as the context of the adaptation required, entailing an element of challenge to the tradition itself. Bose concludes by defining the role of these “other women” as propelling the action and functioning as catalysts to the larger male narrative. This perspective is an exciting addition to scholarship which has sought to tease out the diversity of the “Other Rāmāyaṇas” and challenges to the tradition (Richman, 1991 & 2001). For this review alone, it is exceedingly difficult to do justice to the disciplinary and geographic breadth of coverage that this intriguing volume provides. Despite the surface-level disparateness of the sources, the contributing authors, and especially the editors, must be commended for their intrepid effort to bring the “other women” of the Rāmāyaṇa to the forefront.
