Tracie Guzzio's All Stories Are True is the first integrated study of John Wideman, one of the major figures in contemporary American and African American writing. By “integrated,” I mean two things: first, looking at Wideman's forty-five-year career as a writer, and second, showing the connections among the novels, short stories, personal narratives, and essays written over that period. The first of these points reflects Guzzio's desire to be nearly encyclopedic; the bibliography lists forty-three items by Wideman, almost all of which are at least mentioned in the text. The idea is to see Wideman holistically. Within the discussion, references are made back and forth to works produced at different times. This point reinforces a key argument of the book: that there are no abrupt changes in Wideman's methods, themes, and style. The critical conventional wisdom, sometimes reinforced by the novelist himself, has been that his first three works – A Glance Away, Hurry Home, and The Lynchers – mark his modernist, Eurocentric phase and that later he moved toward an African American approach much more oriented toward history, family, and community. This critical narrative even has a specific biographical link: the change happened when he returned to Pittsburgh for the funeral of his grandmother, stayed to listen to family stories, and realized that this material was truly his. Then, after a period of what he called “woodshedding” (a term he borrowed from modern jazz), he was able to produce the Homewood trilogy – Damballah, Hiding Place, and Sent for You Yesterday – and other fictional and nonfictional work that made his reputation.
Guzzio, through her integrative method, demonstrates the limits of this narrative. It is clear, for example, that the early works include the same settings, some of the same characters, and many of the same concerns as later works. The pessimism that pervades these novels (one element that led critics to label them modernist) comes from an inability of characters to value community and family; the same point is seen in work produced over thirty years later. The twin themes of lost children and absent fathers are found in both fiction and nonfiction. Moreover, Wideman's experiments with voice, with narrative structure, and with the blending of fact and fiction persist throughout his career. What Guzzio demonstrates is that he creates a rough equivalent of Faulkner's Yoknapatawpha County in his renderings of Pittsburgh and Philadelphia.
Like Faulkner, he is profoundly concerned with history, but, as Guzzio makes clear, this is history told from the view of the oppressed, not the privileged. Even those who have relative advantage, such as Wideman himself and the doubles of him found throughout his writing, can and do suffer. His status as an Ivy League graduate, a Rhodes scholar, and a distinguished writer did not save him or his family. Both his brother and his son were involved in killings that led to life sentences in prison, events that haunt his writing. Part of what disturbs him is his own efforts to escape the world of Homewood, a world of poverty and lost lives. One pattern of doubles is the alienated intellectual, a character who leaves the community but then is lost without it. The alternative is what Guzzio calls the blues hero, the figure who takes the pain of experience and turns it into a positive expression for the community by voicing its despair and possibilities.
A striking aspect of this book is its limited use of theory. While Guzzio is clearly well read in autobiographical studies, critical race theory, music history, postmodernism, trauma theory, and historiography, she wears the burden of theory lightly. For example, though “trauma” appears in her subtitle, she offers no detailed definition of it or discussion of what version of it she uses. It is as though we have reached a point in critical analysis where we can assume what it is and how it works. In many ways, this is a traditional literary analysis; the author effectively uses concepts such as the double, the palimpsest, and the hero myth to show how a body of literature works and how even a postmodern writer such as Wideman comes back to these well-established elements.
Guzzio's title comes from an African phrase that Wideman uses repeatedly. It means that we need to challenge the idea that there is a valid master narrative, especially about race. She has questioned the narrative about him and in the process produced the best work on him yet to be published.
