I thank Professor Amin for his comments. In response, first, I would like to point out that, in fact, I do cite Professor Amin's writings (as well as the works of others) on the subject of beauty in my article “The Politics of Reproduction: Maternalism and Women's Hygiene in Iran, 1896–1941” (IJMES 38 [2006]: 29, Note 157). However, I should emphasize that I had presented a version of my IJMES paper at the Biennial Conference of Iranian Studies (2002), where it was read and discussed publicly well before the publication of Professor Amin's recent article (2004). Like him, I recognize that “it is inevitable that our published work will lag behind the latest research or appearance of fresh sources.” Thus, it is not surprising to me that Professor Amin did not know about this piece.
Regarding my review, it would behoove Professor Amin to remember that I used the following adjectives to discuss his work: “rich,” “engaging,” “persuasive,” “valuable,” “thought-provoking,” “useful,” “judicious,” “carefully researched,” “noteworthy,” “well-written,” and “enlightening”—even as I highlighted some points of contention. Unfortunately, none of us is lucky enough to produce a work as flawless as the Qurءan.
I will leave it up to the readers of IJMES and his book to reach their conclusions about Professor Amin's specific objections. I wish Professor Amin well with his future research, and I look forward to his forthcoming publications.
