Proponents of human rights in Latin America have observed the rise of punitive populism with alarm. Tough-on-crime or mano dura rhetoric has become a prominent feature of political campaigns in a way that hearkens back to the worst abuses of the Cold War dictatorships. Although there is little evidence that heavy-handed approaches reduce crime and much to suggest that they exacerbate the problems, the appeal of punitive populism makes a certain amount of sense in a region with high crime rates. Its success in Argentina and Chile, however – two countries with comparatively low crime indexes – is puzzling, and for that reason these two case studies stand to tell us quite a bit about punitive populism more broadly.
Tough on Crime: The Rise of Punitive Populism in Latin America by Michelle Bonner is a comparative study of the media ecology that feeds punitive populism in Argentina and Chile. Bonner's work draws on almost 200 in-depth interviews with media producers, civil society groups and state officials. Based on these interviews and the author's previous fieldwork on human rights and policing in Argentina and Chile, Bonner builds a compelling argument about how the application of neoliberal market rationality to the journalistic field favours punitive voices and encourages the perception that tough-on-crime policies enjoy widespread support. In this respect, the book is reminiscent of observations that Stuart Hall and his colleagues made in Policing the Crisis: Mugging, the State, and Law and Order (Macmillan, 1978) about how the media created a moral panic over street crime that was out of proportion to actual crime rates.
What distinguishes Bonner's book from previous research on punitive populism is its media systems approach, which stresses how political and economic structures shape the practices of reporting as well as the content of crime news. Adapting a comparative framework created by Daniel Hallin and Paolo Mancini (Comparing Media Systems, Cambridge, 2004), Bonner describes Latin America as a ‘captured (neo)liberal media system’ (pp. 57–64) that blends the free-market rationality of neoliberal media systems (e.g. the United States) with the sharp polarisation and political capture of news organisations (e.g. southern Europe). Bonner argues that this mode of news production ends up fuelling punitive populism, which makes sense at face value. It is not hard to imagine how single-minded emphasis on profits combined with networks of public–private patronage can promote a media culture that serves the interests of the powerful. That said, Tough on Crime does not attempt to prove underlying intent. Instead, it shows how the captured neoliberal media system shapes the practices of journalists and how these practices, in turn, end up favouring punitive voices.
By examining the impact of a captured neoliberal media system on journalistic practices, Tough on Crime offers answers to a deceptively simple question. Why do news outlets favour tough-on-crime narratives? Bonner's introduction provides a clear picture of the argument, a state-of-the art review of where research on punitive populism currently stands, and a comparative frame for thinking about where Latin America fits within the global rise of punitive populism. Chapter 1 describes the statistical gulf between crime and perceptions of insecurity, and why we might be sceptical about the public's supposed desire for mano dura. Chapter 2 provides much of the book's conceptual framing on media systems and public opinion. Chapter 3 is a comparative analysis of the history of news media in Argentina and Chile and a good starting point for media research in either country.
The bulk of the evidence for Bonner's argument is presented in Chapters 4–6, which show how market forces lead to a concentration of media ownership and an emphasis on profit-making over public good. Journalists working under these conditions reproduce a kind of tabloid-style reporting that's cheap, fast and uncritical of dominant frames; there is little time for investigative reporting or self-reflective pushback against tough-on-crime sentiment. These chapters also show how two constituencies come to dominate crime news: 1) state security forces, namely the police and their public relations teams, and 2) civil society groups that claim to speak in the name of crime victims. Both of these sources are well funded, have open access to media organisations, and are far more likely to promote a tough-on-crime narrative. Finally, these chapters show the importance of political capture; they suggest that crime is a framing captured by the Right. In Chile, control of the media was effectively handed over to Augusto Pinochet's sympathisers and gave them a competitive advantage that has been difficult to overcome. In Argentina, things are more complicated. Like everything else, the politics of crime are polarised along historically constructed lines. Although the government of Cristina Kirchner clearly recognised crime as a political threat, its main response was to shift culpability rather than challenge the narrative of punitive populism.
Bonner concludes with suggestions about how news organisations can avoid tough-on-crime boosterism. These include more resources for investigative reporting, less reliance on public relations materials, better representation of a diversity of perspectives, healthy scepticism about public opinion polls, and sources of crime news other than victims or the police. The aim of these recommendations is to better fulfil the democratic ideals of a transparent, accurate and accountable press. These are laudable goals; however, communicational practices alone would not be enough to forestall the punitive turn in Latin American countries with higher rates of violent crime than Argentina or Chile (e.g. Venezuela). The recommendations also give the impression that punitive populism is a negative externality of neoliberal capitalism rather than part of its design. That might have been a credible stance a decade ago, but the political weaponisation of policing that we are currently witnessing suggests otherwise. As Bonner shows, punitive populism stands democracy on its head. It emerges within democracy but does not answer to its ideals. Tough on Crime looks closely at the journalistic practices that unwittingly perpetuate the myth of punitive populism, in the hopes that media organisations can reverse course. It is an excellent introduction to one of Latin America's most intransigent problems and one that provides an invaluable touchstone for future researchers.
