Why in the world would anyone care a wit about the farmer in England between 1650 and 1980? Richard Hoyle, this volume's editor, does not directly address this question in his rich and insightful introduction. But the remaining 11 essays in this surprisingly wide-ranging volume provide 11 different answers. Their one clear common theme is that the study of farmers in England during the three and a half centuries covered is, to slightly paraphrase Alfred Marshall's famous definition of economics, “a study of men [and women] as they live and move and think in the ordinary business of life.”
Hoyle's introductory essay is subtitled, “recovering the farmer” and is in part a call for closer study of the farmer as an agent in British economic and social life. He cogently discusses problems of terminology in labeling the farmer and he clearly overviews the range of sources available for studying the history of farmers. However, he does not provide any sort of systematic or overarching agenda of issues for developing or filling in the historiography of the English farmer. This decision may be related to the apparent “let a hundred flowers bloom” approach to English agricultural history evident in the diverse essays of this volume.
The volume is arranged chronologically, with two to three essays for each of the four centuries given coverage. All but two of the 11 studies focus on specific farms or farmers. Concerns about representativeness in these nine studies are more than offset by their careful attention to context and the rich detail they offer about motives and decision making which is not usually feasible in studies based on more aggregate evidence.
Hoyle makes a reasonable plea for a focus on the farmer as an occupational category. But the subsequent contributions often show that those who were centrally involved in farm decision making had other key life and occupational identities. Thus, Jennifer Holt's study of Sarah Fell, a member of a Lancashire family with farming interests in late seventeenth century Lancashire, uses Fell's cashbook to study the rhythms of the rural economy and how it interacted with broader trading networks. As Holt acknowledges, Sarah Fell maintained this valuable source because she was a cashier rather than someone directly engaged in farming (p. 66). John Broad's account of John Mastin's career in late eighteenth and early nineteenth century Northamptonshire focuses on his farming activity and interest in agricultural improvement. Mastin himself, however, was a self-identified clergyman. Peter Dewey's account of James Mason as scientific farmer acknowledges that Mason's wealth and primary activity was in mining.
The studies offer contrasting perspectives on the process of agricultural improvement. A.J. Gritt's study of a mid-eighteenth century Lancashire small holder, and John Broad's study of three farmers from diverse parts of the midlands in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries emphasize the mix of pragmatism and ingenuity behind their efforts at improvement. In contrast, Peter Dewey's study of James Mason and his Eynsham Hall Estate in the later nineteenth century, John Martin's study of Rex Paterson's promotion of grassland dairy farming in the mid-twentieth century, and Philip Conford's study of Robert Stuart efforts to promote organic farming in the later twentieth century focus on their subjects’ leadership roles.
Susanna Wade Martins’ chapter considers farmers with varying tenancy arrangements on the enormous and legendary Holkham Estate in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. It illustrates the varying degrees of control and autonomy to which tenants were subject from estate agents and landowners. The tensions between landlord and tenant are even more evident in Nicola Verdon's narrative of how the independent minded Louse Cresswell clashed with her landlord at Sandringham, the Prince of Wales.
A number of the essays discuss the determinants of crop mix and allocation of land between livestock and arable. Richard Hoyle employs a 22 year run of accounts from a Cambridgeshire farmer in the late seventeenth century to argue that redeployment of land towards oats was a risk reducing strategy during the agrarian crisis of the 1690s, thus challenging Appleby's narrative based on price information alone for various grains. Turning to the twentieth century, Hilary Crowe takes up efforts of the government to directly redeploy pastureland to arable to increase food supplies during World War I while John Martin considers Rex Paterson's encounters with similar policies during World War II.
One of the exceptions to the focus on particular farmers and farms is Crowe's study of Westmoreland farmers. The other exception is Joyce Burnette's study of the seasonality of labor demand in farming between 1740 and 1850 based on a national sample of some 65 farms. Burnette deftly deals with challenges of the lack of randomness in her sample and the unbalanced nature of her observations as a panel. She finds far more seasonality in men's employment than boys but even greater seasonality for women. Her direct measures of labor employment challenge previous accounts of regional differences in seasonal employment based primarily on wage data.
This volume is dedicated to the distinguished agricultural historian, E.J.T. (Ted) Collins. Those wishing to pursue a more systematic approach to the history of the farmer in England would, I expect, acknowledge that each of the essays in this volume vindicates Collins’ advocacy of the fruits to be gleaned from intensive use of primary source materials in agricultural history.
