Until 1927, the contents of Augustus’ Res gestae, the inscribed record of his life and accomplishments, were only known through the bilingual inscription of Ancyra. As happens occasionally with inscriptions, the Latin text was damaged at one of the most important points: when Augustus described the nature of his supremacy. The Greek translation described his supremacy as stemming from his ἀξἰωμα, which Mommsen translated as dignitas. However, the discovery of new fragments of the Latin version in Antioch in Pisidia revealed that Augustus had used a different word: auctoritas (Res Gestae 34.3). It is understandable that this discovery opened up new avenues of research regarding not only the powers of Augustus, but also the importance of auctoritas in Roman political culture.
The volume edited by Jean-Michel David and Frédéric Hurlet offers a fresh window on the importance of this concept in the Roman Republic and the Augustan period. It gathers eighteen specialists (with a nice variety of senior and junior scholars, but including very few women) who have focused on painting a picture (or, rather, many different and complementary pictures) of auctoritas.
This volume is to be commended for several reasons, the first of which is the variety of perspectives on the topic. There are obviously chapters which deal with auctoritas in Roman politics or political culture (discussed further below), but others study the auctoritas of writers (Le Doze), of witnesses in courts of justice (Guérin), of the jurists (Mantovani). Others address the Greek versions of auctoritas (Famerie), auctoritas in personal relationships and recommendations (Deniaux), auctoritas and possession in the Twelve Tables (Lanfranchi), and paternal control on marriage and the transmission of family fortunes (Dubouloz). This diversity allows the reader to develop a nuanced and complete perspective of the role of auctoritas in both public and private life in Rome.
Several chapters deal with the role of auctoritas in the political culture of the Roman Republic. Pina Polo analyses the uses of auctoritas in the works of Livy, who, interestingly, reserved such term for the senate and foreign individuals and peoples, applying it to just three individual Romans (Scipio Africanus, Cato the Elder and Aemilius Paullus). In contrast, auctoritas was a favourite term of Cicero, who attributed it to a vast number of senators, equites and even foreign aristocrats, as David shows. For Bur, auctoritas is linked to the mos maiorum and the virtues of previous generations. Berthelet argues for a difference between the auctoritas of the magistrates and the priests; while for the former auctoritas was secondary to potestas, the auctoritas of the priests was life-long and based on their religious expertise. The Senate and the senators were the main repositories of auctoritas; Hölkeskamp places the leges Publilia et Maenia and the plebiscitum Ovinium in the heart of the formalisation of the decision-making process in the Senate and, thus, the construction of the patrum auctoritas. Baudry studies the role of auctoritas throughout the dynamics of senatorial decision-making, from the giving of opinions to the vote on the senatus consultum.
Other papers address questions of auctoritas in the Caesarean, triumviral and early Augustan periods. Zecchini analyses Caesar's claim of auctoritas Italiae as a way of undermining the legitimacy of the Senate. Van Haeperen studies the inaugural auspicia taken by Octavian at the date of his first grant of imperium and his first consulship in 43, to show how the prodigies attested, and thus the auctoritas of Jupiter, increased his own. Schiavone debates the control that the princeps imposed on jurisprudence (and thus on the aristocracy) through the establishment of his ius respondendi, becoming thus the first of the jurists. In a clear taxonomy, Jehne establishes a distinction between individual auctoritas (either as a consul qua consul, or personal, due to one's character or virtues) and collective auctoritas (which could be cumulative, such as the authority of the individual senators, or integral, like that of the populus Romanus). He uses this distinction to illuminate convincingly Augustus’ claim to auctoritas. Finally, Hurlet deals with the debate about the lack of further contemporary sources on the auctoritas of Augustus, by reviewing the epigraphic evidence and studying the interaction between the auctoritas of the Senate and that of Augustus, and its evolution during the first century c.e.
Auctoritas was an element at the heart of a complex system. Acts of potestas and imperium had to be obeyed; however, acts of auctoritas had to be respected and negotiated. In fact, auctoritas needed an audience to be actualised and acknowledged, and thus was closely linked to speeches in public. At the same time, auctoritas was also founded on the latent possibility of resorting to violence. As with many other concepts of Roman political culture, auctoritas is best understood as a myriad of acts in practice, rather than a strictly legal concept. Augustus’ claim to surpass everyone in auctoritas has necessarily been the focus of scholarly attention, but, as this volume proposes, there is much to it than just a part of the powers of the princeps. And, as Van Haeperen recalls (148), we should keep in mind Cicero's description of the young Octavian in November 44: he had character, yes, but not much auctoritas (‘quamquam animi satis, auctoritatis parum est’: Cic., Att. 16.14.2).
There are a few topics that are absent from the book. The question of the auctoritas populi Romani is briefly mentioned by both Jehne and Zecchini, but only as a secondary concern and assuming a passive view of the populus. It is true that Cicero's De Legibus 3.28 attributed auctoritas to the Senate and potestas to the populus, but his treatise is occasionally normative rather than descriptive. It would have been valuable to have more thorough analysis of this topic, starting from a less Senate-centric perspective and using especially the De Lege Manilia (mentioned by Jehne, 331) or Cic., Phil. 6.18 (just mentioned en passant by Zecchini, 343, n. 15). A close analysis of the extremely frequent use of auctoritas in Cicero's Philippics (and its shifting meanings) might also have provided a nice bridge into the triumviral period. This reader also wonders what happened when auctoritas failed to communicate itself or the audience did not accept it. Which strategies and dynamics could a senator or a commander employ when his auctoritas was fragile?
These comments should not be seen as criticism of the book. David and Hurlet have gathered a multi-faceted perspective on a topic which was relevant in the Republic and in the Principate. The book is very affordable and very well produced. It has a useful joint bibliography at the end (quoting major and not so major works in all academic languages), together with a helpful summary of all papers in English and in their original language (French, German, Italian, Spanish). It is a necessary read for anyone working on Roman political culture in the Republic or in Augustan times.
