It is no surprise that Adger Pace and Walter Seale's 1921 “Wake up, America and Kluck, Kluck, Kluck” never made it into the great American songbook: “If you want to be happy, just sing a little song, and join the mighty army of the K. K. throng,” the first verse crowed.Footnote 1 Written for a music publisher in Tennessee, the song's swingy syncopation evoked Tin-Pan Alley and Ragtime rhythms, even as it invited consumers to play along in their parlors. Produced outside of the Ku Klux Klan Inc.’s official channels, “Wake up, America” exemplifies the surprising range of 1920s cultural artifacts that depicted the Klan for commercial profit. These cultural artifacts pose thorny questions about audience and ideology that can shed light both on popular perceptions of the Klan and habits of cultural consumption in the 1920s.
With this impressively researched monograph, historian Felix Harcourt works to dislodge a stubborn myth about the 1920s Ku Klux Klan: that the self-proclaimed Invisible Empire operated at the margins of American life. Since the 1960s, social historians have argued that the Klan operated alongside more respectable lodges, and church societies; many members understood Klan participation in those terms.Footnote 2 Simultaneously, the Klan's dramatization of secrecy included the enforcement of strict moralism and the political exclusion of certain citizens on local, state, and national levels.Footnote 3 Even within the Klan's own contradictory propaganda, its leaders preached their organization's respectability while threatening violent action. Understanding how early twentieth-century Americans conceptualized the Ku Klux Klan has long required scholars to navigate pairs of opposites. The Klan was either respectable or violent, local or national, modern or anti-modern. Harcourt's contribution to these debates is a change in perspective. Rather than choosing sides, Harcourt shows how the accumulation of these contradictory viewpoints may have strengthened popular perceptions of the Klan.
Harcourt challenges readers to move beyond an organizational model of the Klan, seeing it instead as a broad “cultural movement” that staged contests over the group's meaning and significance. This discourse implicated Klan leaders, members, those who informally “bound themselves to an imagined cultural community” through appreciative consumption of Klan representations, cultural producers who incorporated “a dash of Ku Klux Klan for spice” (117), avowed critics, and even ambivalent consumers of cultural media. This uncomfortable collaboration worked in both directions, as the Klan's identity was crafted in forms that challenged the moral rules that leaders claimed to uphold. Rather than determining who was and who was not a member of the Klan, Harcourt's approach suggests that a vast swath of the American public participated in the formation of a “Klannish cultural Identity” (9), whether or not they claimed affiliation with or officially joined the organization.
If “identity formation” evokes abstraction, Harcourt offers an array of material sites in which this diverse cast of historical actors expressed and contested characterizations of the Klan. Harcourt looks for Klannish identity in an unlikely assemblage of texts. Through chapters devoted to various arenas of meaning-making—from newspapers to sporting events, Harcourt examines the idea of the Klan's travels through popular media, as the Klan's self-representations were consumed and then appropriated by an increasing national public. Because his focus is on the formation of a shared identity, Harcourt resists letting any singular text take too much focus. Even The Birth of a Nation, “the urtext of the revived Klan” (105) makes only a cameo halfway through the book. Rather than performing extensive readings of individual works, Harcourt focuses on the production and circulation of texts within each medium, a strategy that suggests the parallel but distinct development of ideas about the Klan within the formal conventions, business models, and social contexts of each culture industry. This structure sometimes seems far too neat for the kind of cultural foment being evoked. But the accumulation of chapters blurs these divisions into a traffic of images, historical actors, and profits, across media-based genealogies. The resulting portrait is a composite, strengthened by both the repeated refrains and contradictory perspectives that it encompassed.
The downside of this approach is that readers become so embedded in the world of cultural production that we could miss the real threat of violence lodged under the Klan's eye-rolling puns and salacious self-representation. Harcourt is working against lingering popular perceptions of the Klan as a terrorist organization—again challenging attempts to view the organization in opposition to mainstream American culture. While successfully tracing the Klan's travels through middlebrow cultural institutions, Harcourt could have spent more time on the ways that these accessible representations of the Klan normalized the violent exclusion of a range of Americans from political and social spaces alongside the formation of Klannish identity. How did the Klan's place in the cultural mainstream shape the range of identities that Americans saw as part of that national culture?Footnote 4 Questions may also emerge from the pace of Harcourt's book, which covers such impressive ground that his careful research can get overwhelmed by the overarching portrayal of a commodified Klan.
What are the stakes of recognizing that the Ku Klux Klan not only emerged within mainstream American culture, but that the production of Klannish identity implicated far more Americans than those who formally pledged their affiliation? Harcourt's study suggests a useful model of how historical actors navigated their own changing world. The contradictory dualisms used to define the Klan also defined the 1920s as an era. “Wake up, America” commodified social hierarchies for easy consumption; it made profits for cultural producers outside of the Klan while bringing possible members into the organization. As with the hundreds of other texts Harcourt examines, it also provides an unsettling point of departure for a journey into the construction of a national expressive culture that can help historicize our current moment. Calling attention to the broader cast of characters who helped to invent and normalize the early twentieth-century Ku Klux Klan may leave readers considering how their own media consumption shapes the characterization of violent cultures at the apparent margins of contemporary American life.
