Lawrence Davidson's America's Palestine examines the important British Mandate (1917–48) period in the history of the conflict between Jews and Arabs in Palestine. The book covers a range of topics that bear directly on official and popular American positions on Palestine, including American Protestant missionary interest in the region, the rise of a politically influential American Zionist movement; and the rise of a less politically influential, although by no means absent, Arab American organizational network. One of the main themes the work traces is the differing positions taken by American presidents and the State Department. The author outlines the ways in which American Jews ingratiated themselves with American politicians, both at the executive and legislative levels, pushing forward the Zionist project in Palestine. In the early part of the 20th century, according to Davidson, members of these two branches of government became, and remained, beholden to the well-funded and influential American Jewish Zionist organization, thereby making the Palestine conflict a local domestic political issue. Conversely, career diplomats in the State Department had no constituency to cater to for votes and thus viewed the conflict as a matter of foreign affairs.
Davidson supports his argument that the media of the day channeled American popular and official opinion to support Zionism in Palestine at the expense of the Palestinian Arabs through an examination of four American newspapers—the New York Times, the Washington Post, the Los Angeles Times, and the Chicago Tribune. Prevailing racial and cultural stereotypes at the time, along with a different set of journalistic standards from today, Davidson notes briefly, allowed reporters to editorialize and opine in their stories and thus shape public opinion according to their own perspective. Joseph Levy, for example, the New York Times Palestine correspondent and an American Jew, consistently covered Jewish events in Palestine and therefore presented a one-sided view of the emerging Arab–Jewish conflict. Davidson frames his analysis by showing how the politics of this period remained guided by the 19th-century European imperialistic worldview, which divided the world into colonizers and colonized, superior and inferior races, good and bad, right and wrong. This worldview gave justification to British rule in Palestine and, according to Davidson, pervaded American newspaper writing in this period. Although the book is quite successful in offering a view of public opinion during a time for which we have no polls on a subject for which no oral history has been done, one might still ask whether newspapers were the source of information for all social classes in American society or only for members of the educated elite, who ran for Congress and for the presidency.
Separate from the newspaper analysis, Davidson analyzes State Department records, which provide, in tantalizing detail, the ways in which the American government competed among its branches for control in forming policy and playing politics over the Palestine issue. The records are instructive in tracing American governmental involvement in the issue and provide the background to the question of why successive presidential administrations have supported the Israeli state, regardless of its actions, over the principles of self-determination and human rights for Palestinians. The president, who is beholden to election cycles and the politics of vote getting, binds the State Department, an executive agency, in its policies and actions. Quite simply, as the author demonstrates from the State Department records, the American political will to solve this conflict has not been evident historically. Although the records provide wonderful detail in historical hindsight, they were unseen by the public at that time, leaving readers perplexed by the fact that the book's two main sources, newspapers and State Department records, are so seamlessly tied together in the author's narrative as shaping American public opinion on the Palestine conflict.
Although his analysis of newspapers is replete with evidence suggesting how Americans' positive opinions toward Jews and negative opinions toward Arabs/Muslims took shape during this period, the reasons he chose this research topic are absent, as is a discussion of his methodology. That America had no controlling political position in Palestine at the time and that America's real Middle East interests lay in the Arab oil-producing regions on which America's domestic political economy depended are facts the author mentions cursorily, yet he does not offer them as his reason for writing the book. The book is clearly critical of the influence that American Zionists had on successive administrations and on Congress, leading to unquestioned American support for Zionist Jews in Palestine and a lack of support for the indigenous Palestinian Arabs. The result of the latter partly led, Davidson surmises, to the ultimate destruction of Palestinian society in Palestine in 1948, yet the author never informs the reader that this might explain his need to write this book. One can only speculate that Davidson might be compelled by more recent American political history, in which American presidents have backed the Zionist Israelis with little to no thought to the indigenous Arab population of Palestine or to the positions of the oil-producing Arab states, and thus set out to examine the roots of this support.
Davidson's America's Palestine comes as part of a group of books published recently—Obenzinger (1999), Christison (2000), and Little (2002), which have considered American literature, presidential administrations, and U.S. Middle East foreign policy, respectively—examining American attitudes toward Palestine during the last 100 years. It seems clear that there is rising interest in the role that America has played in this conflict. Scholars examining both the official and popular records on the subject of Palestine perceive deception and injustice in the ways that successive administrations and popular writers, among others, have presented and represented the conflict and its primary opponents. Although methodologically problematic, readers will welcome the archival material that Davidson has uncovered and perhaps turn to it to substantiate their own arguments, positions, and scholarship on the question of Palestine.
