The 12 contributions in this book come from a conference of the same title held at the Joukowsky Institute for Archaeology and the Ancient World on the campus of Brown University on 1–3 December 2017. Although the conference was held in the United States, none of the contributors are from North America. The plan of the book moves from west to east: Mallorca, Corsica, Sardinia, Sicily, Adriatic islands off Croatia, Crete (two contributions), Cyclades, Naxos, southern Aegean, and Cyprus, to which a summary chapter is added. One major omission is the islands in the northern Aegean. Although they do not participate in the publication, comments by the session responders (P. Van Dommelen, J. Cherry, S. Alcock, and M. McCormick), and their publications, are everywhere present in the individual contributions. All contributors to this volume are active in fieldwork, in many instances reporting on their own excavations.
The last chapter, a summation by D. Abulafia (“Islands in context, A.D. 400–1000,” 285–96), should be read first since it ties together the common threads of the papers. The quote from Donne at the top (“No man is an island…,” 285) was, perhaps, inevitable but apt, since isolation and insularity are increasingly contested spaces and not accepted. The perception of islands as suffering and remote, places of punishment, is acknowledged in the first paragraph of the foreword by the editors, while the first sentence of A.'s chapter claims that the image of islands as self-sufficient, autonomous, and isolated is “by and large a fantasy” (285). His view is that the islands of the ancient Mediterranean fall into two classes: those that “stand apart physically” (285) from the mainland, that is, Balearics, Sardinia, Crete, and Cyprus; and the rest, namely Corsica, Sicily, Adriatic islands, Cyclades, Naxos, and islands of the southern Aegean. The number and kinds of influences thus differ between the first group, which are largely “stopping points” (286), and those which are open to influences from the mainland. A. finds it significant that none of the islands within the period 400–1000 CE could be construed as the capital of a thalassocracy (286). The one city for which he thinks such a claim could be made is Carthage under the Vandals (286), a city on the shore of Tunisia. The islands, rather, and Crete in particular, became boundaries between the navies of competing imperial powers and not bases for the ambitions of imperial fleets.
A. is correct to see the importance of Horden and Purcell in understanding the fragmentation of Late Antique society (286).Footnote 1 The provincial reorganization of Diocletian, laws of Constantine tying people to the land, and overhaul of the tax code in the indiction system would all have accelerated the fragmentation – true even for land-locked provinces – both administratively and in the restriction of free movement. A. also recognizes that this process would have been intensified on the islands (286), particularly the ones in the Aegean (Chapters 6–10). Much is made of the founding of Constantinople (324 CE), and certainly this is tied to what A. sees as the case for change being greater in the Western Empire, with its serial invasions, and the case for resilience being greater in the Eastern Empire, where, even when there were invasions, they were of lesser intensity and duration (287) and were closer, physically, to the seat of power and so a matter of more immediate concern.
Islands are sometimes thought resistant to change, but A. (287, citing the Cyclades, Chapter 8, and Naxos, Chapter 9) observes that islands as closed systems can make changes decisively, quickly and en masse, such as in the adoption of Christianity.Footnote 2 As he states, “this serves as a reminder that it is important to insert within this framework the role of religious change” (287), particularly since “Late Antiquity” is more or less, and most often viewed, as the period from the legalization of Christianity to the thoroughness of its triumph. He is quick to note that the response is not uniform, with rates and processes on different islands hostage to local traditions, and that the supposition that coastal areas converted more quickly but interior places held on to paganism longer cannot be maintained; elevation is not a form of insularity (288).
The second section (288–95) shows that A.'s vision of antiquity is post-Pirenne, a view shared by all the papers in this volume, whose authors he cites in support (291). For A. the defining decades and events that shifted the Mediterranean are not the period of Charlemagne and Muslim control of southern Spain but the arid period that might have contributed to the Icelandic volcanic eruption of 536 CE (290–91), which led to crop failures throughout Europe; famine was followed by the great Justinianic plague (starting 541 CE). Until then Justinian could field an army that aimed at reassembling the Roman Empire at its greatest extent. In the wake of the disasters, military initiatives had to be abandoned and social pressures on a reduced population, especially in taxes, greatly abetted the Muslim sweep through the Near East, culminating in the Battle of Yarmuk (636 CE). One cannot dispute the importance of these events but they raise two issues that are largely unaddressed. First, if climatic events and natural disasters were responsible for the change, the role of conversion to Christianity, beyond the indisputable construction of churches, needs more examination. Second, if the changes that affected the islands were pan-Mediterranean, then there must be an argument for the islands as special, or at least telling us something about the shift to medieval society that cannot be traced or demonstrated as easily elsewhere.
These questions are answered in the last part of the second section and the third section (292–95), in which the islands are the Braudelian “many small seas” that create large scale socioeconomic forces that can be understood only by “taking into account what was happening further along the maritime trade routes” (295). Venice is an island, toughened by Carolingian and Slavic attacks, that controlled trade routes (293–94) through controlling other islands, significantly Crete and Cyprus. What Venice shares with Amalfi, “a virtual island” (294),Footnote 3 and other prosperous centers in the Western half of the Mediterranean is their close connection to Constantinople; the bishops of Venice and Amalfi were under the authority of Byzantium, not Rome. It gave an advantage in long-distance trading over other islands and places on the mainland.Footnote 4 A.'s final analysis deserves quotation: “the individual islands engaged in a much larger world, even if at other times depopulation, ruralization, and desiccation led to their relative isolation. The history of the islands is, by and large, a history of variety” (295).
The foreword by the coeditors makes clear the scope and self-imposed limitations of the conference, and of this volume, noting that island archaeology, at least initially, was mainly devoted to prehistory and to the study of “socio-cultural transformation and cross-cultural interaction” (xxi). The three recent decades have seen not just an enlargement in periods studied but the application of new and more challenging theoretical approaches. Attempts to understand the Mediterranean as a whole and to pay the most attention to periods and processes of transformation have privileged the contribution of islands, particularly the transition from the Later Roman period to the Middle Ages. Pages xxii–xxiii give a list of some of the most important and influential books in the last 30 years on Late Antiquity, both those mainly concerned with economic and military history and those examining the divergent rates of adoption of Christianity.
By “change,” the editors and papers in this volume seek to understand “how and to what extent islands were transformed” (xxiii); that is, they realize that change is as often, or more often, imposed by new ideas and circumstances as by the actions of the population. A preference is given to “episodes of change” rather than simply “change.” What this means, as the papers individually reveal, is that it is less productive to think of change as a continuum or a single major event but as a spate of smaller, disconnected transformations; history, in essence, occurs in hiccups.
“Resilience” (xxiv–xxv) is not the opposite of change but après change. If the engines of change can be pan-Mediterranean, the response is often individual, which makes the nine islands or groups of islands in this volume, in essence, nine different histories, even if the commonalities are many and obvious. The editors are at pains to note that “resilience” is not the same as “resilience theory,”Footnote 5 but rather, following Folke, that “in periods of crisis, societies, like ecosystems, adapt” because resilience “incorporates the capacity of socio-ecological systems to cope with, adapt to, and shape change and learn to live with uncertainty and surprise” (xxiv).Footnote 6 The point of the book is therefore to map those changes in individual case studies, “nurturing a comparative overview of islands across the Mediterranean.”
The first contribution is by the editors of the volume on “The occupation of Mallorca (Balearic Islands, Spain) in Late Antiquity: Tracing change and resilience” (1–24), in which they try to outline the transformation from Late Roman to Medieval society on that island, with a special emphasis on changes in the countryside and rural churches. First and foremost is how, in the 5th and 6th c., the occupants came to terms with a countryside that became largely unoccupied through depopulation. Of the 13 sites on Mallorca they investigate, they note that there seems to be a movement away from Roman-era foundations to pre-Roman indigenous sites. Given the dearth of ancient sources and modern scholarship, most of what is known is through excavation and survey. Roman presence on the islands, though they were conquered in 123 BCE, only takes off from about 70 BCE. Most of what is known is from the excavation of Pollentia on the coast on the north tip of Mallorca, a town site with expected amenities. However, on the basis of physical remains, nothing can be said for certain about its Christianization.
Survey archaeology, which started on Mallorca in 1988, has indicated centuriation in the earliest phase of Roman rule, and site constriction in the 3rd c. CE. The 5th and 6th c. saw the development of the manor system in rural areas in response to Vandal incursions when Mallorca remained a Byzantine possession. Byzantine-style churches and coins persist into the first half of the 8th c., which witnessed the collapse of the manor system. There is great variety in the form of early basilicas (11 fig. 1.5): the authors assert that the churches could have functioned as “poles of attractions for other settlements” (10) and raise the possibility that the clergy exerted central authority in their regions. Monasticism is largely absent from Mallorca, monks more often settling on the smaller islands of the Balearics. The floral and faunal remains suggest a return to a pre-Roman subsistence economy. The bibliography is impressive (19–24) and up to date.
“Between change and resilience: Urban and rural settlement patterns in Late Corsica,” by G. Castiglia and P. Pergola (25–49), considers the transformations of Mariana through excavation and letters of Pope Gregory the Great and through rural sites with cathedrals: Saona, Adiaticum, and Castellu. Since the excavation of late settlements on Corsica is limited, the authors draw their conclusions partially through comparison with Sardinia and Sicily. A complicating factor is that several of the key excavations in the countryside remain unpublished. Site habitation is unbroken at the sites they investigate from the Roman period through the Vandal, Byzantine, and Lombard periods, dated by pottery from Spain, North Africa, and the eastern Mediterranean, which also indicates a continuing robust trade. From 227 BCE Corsica was jointly governed with Sardinia but for the period of this book, as part of the reforms of Diocletian, it was its own province. Although the period of Vandal domination was short (455–532 CE) it was a time of intense prosperity between two troughs.
As one of the first Roman provinces, and one proximate to Italy, Corsica is mentioned in several geographies and itineraries. The letters of Pope Gregory belong to 591–601 CE and were addressed to multiple correspondents and, not surprisingly, were about founding monasteries and churches and finding suitable monks and clerics for them. Byzantine control of Corsica is excoriated in a letter complaining about excessive taxation. One letter urges extension of Christianity aggressively into rural areas. What this means is that we should expect some churches to be tied to the Eastern rite and others to the Western rite, and that church foundations away from the coast should belong mainly to the 7th c. or later. The episcopal complex at Mariana belongs to the 5th and 6th c., has been well excavated, and has yielded mosaics with Christian topoi popular in that period. Not surprisingly, it was built on top of the Mithraeum. Significant features include an elevated choir in the presbyterium and a circular, external baptismal font that was later significantly altered. A similar topography and situation holds for Ajaccio, which was founded probably in the early 6th c. on a small commercial site, evidenced by large buried dolia, and was classed as episcopal by Gregory, who was concerned that the cathedral was understaffed.
Smaller churches were under the control of a Western bishop in Aleria, such as Bravona on the coast, and a Western bishop at Mariana, such as Rescamone, well in the interior. As also with the inland Cellae Cupiae cathedral close to the settlement of Castellu, the emphasis on baptistries indicates concern that the locals should be baptized and then kept from returning to the worship of adorning “stumps and stones” (40, ligna et lapides, Gregory, Ep. 8.1). An unusual feature at Rescamone is a double concentric apse; the smaller apse served as a circular baptismal font. Castellu, on the other hand, does not have a church but does have a rich stratigraphic sequence. Its large number of African imports correlates with the African origin of numerous of the bishops on Corsica. The authors conclude that Corsica had a “double soul” (46): as it came late to Christianity compared to other nearby places, Gregory was right to be worried that paganism, especially outside the main civic areas, had not lost its attraction, even after the adoption of Christianity.
“Procopius’ Barbarikinoi and Gregory the Great's Barbaricini: Mauri and Sardinians in the sixth and seventh centuries A.D.” (51–85), by P. G. Spanu, argues that Barbarikinoi/Barbaricini should be identified with the Mauri during the period of Vandal domination of Sardinia. That Vandals in Africa deported restive elements of the local Mauri population, and that they emerge as “barbarians” in the writing of Procopius and of Gregory the Great is uncontested, as is their settlement in mountainous areas suitable only for pastoralism. The puzzle S. seeks to solve is whether, as first believed, they were settled in indigenous areas in the southwestern corner of the island (but perhaps in the noncontiguous mountainous areas in both the southwest and the southeast) or in the central highlands (fig. 3.2 is extremely useful).
Studies of Late Roman Sardinia are aided by the Cosmographia of the Anonymous Ravennate, a contemporary geography of the first half of the 7th c. What emerges is a system of villages, almost entirely coastal, whose settlement history is on the whole persistent from Punic times. Forum Traiani, a spa center on the central west side of the mountains, is the only interior settlement with civitas status. Where the soil could be cultivated it was and remained a grain monoculture characterized by latifundia. The wealth was sufficient to support villas with baths and extensive mosaic programs, which were converted, typically, to local industrial use during the Vandal period, and eventually abandoned in the late 6th c. or early 7th c., when it was part of the Byzantine Diocese of Africa.
It is Procopius in the de bello Vandalico who notes that the Mauri exiles were offloaded at Carales, a port city on the extreme south, for internal exile in the mountains to the east and west, which they used more as bases for raids than as a new homeland, yet in other places they seem to have been settled in the central mountains, for which Justinian's foundation of the garrison town Forum Traiani was meant to keep them under observation. Extensive epigraphical evidence (63–65) would seem to confirm this nexus of villages.
Resilience is an interesting question and hinges in part on a nostalgia for Sardo-related names (65–69) from the 7th c. through the 10th c., when there is little evidence to link them to descendants of the pre-Roman population. The same is true of neo-nuraghi, reuse of old nuraghi, and reoccupation around nuraghi (69–74). The process had already begun during the Roman Empire but is more visible in the 6th c. In general, the pattern that S. sees is that return to Nuragic sites often occurred in tandem with a return to subsistence agriculture (70) and that some of the nuraghi were opened and cleared to be used as granaries or warehouses (70) and even mausolea (73). Such sites usually have local production of ceramic wares, generally hand-thrown or slow wheel and bisque fired. What emerges is an interesting, and important, meld of new technologies and traditions imported by new peoples that honored, or at the least used, the onomastic and architectural traditions they inherited from a civilization long dead before their arrival.Footnote 7
In “Sicily from Late Antiquity to the Early Middle Ages: Resilience and disruption” (87–110), A. Molinari looks at exchange networks, settlements, and the agricultural economy, seeking an explanation for why some parts of the economy and society functioned as before, while other parts survived by transformation. Sicily is different from other islands in that the economic and social systems of Late Antiquity stayed in place longer than on other islands – that is, until the 7th c. The 8th c. was a period of rapid, visible change, followed quickly by Muslim invasion starting in 827 CE.
The amount of research on Sicily in Late Antiquity and the Early Middle Ages is staggering. M.'s map (fig. 4.1) lists 30 sites, about half of which are on the south coast. Archaeobotanical and geomorphological studies add to the picture brought together from excavation and survey. The ceramic catalog for the island by Malfitana and Bonifay has few parallels in other islands and is crucial for dating and establishing connections.Footnote 8 It allows M. (89) to speak of two Sicilies: southern and eastern Sicily, which traded directly with North Africa, exporting primarily sulfur, and northern Sicily, which got North African products via the port of Rome. Southeastern Sicily would have received imports both directly and through Ostia as a redistribution center. For Late Antiquity, the necessity of this network was due to the diversion of Egyptian grain to the new imperial capital at Constantinople. What was different in the 7th c. was that the amount of commerce fell off significantly and by the 8th c. many of the ceramics were local imitation wares based on types from the eastern Mediterranean.
Late Roman Sicily (from the 5th c.) is the post-villa period. Instead of places like the Piazza Armerina, there was growth in small villages dedicated to agriculture (“agro-towns,” 91). Over time even these declined in number. The constriction was greater in the western part of the island, but everywhere some agro-towns grew in size and importance. The firmness of the Islamic hold on the island in the 10th c. consolidated this process. The Muslim conquest should be viewed in tandem with an arid period in Sicily starting about 720 CE: collapse of cereal production, sharp decline of population, and appearance of pestilence are all emblematic of the period. The overall picture is confirmed by the work of the author and her collaborators in the Castronovo region, where six sites have been identified and are being investigated (93–100). Her conclusion is that terms such as “resilience” and “continuity” are difficult to apply to the situation in Sicily.
In terms of the landscape, the big break is not the Islamic period but Norman Sicily (from 1070 but organized as a kingdom in 1130). M.'s main conclusion is that “We must probably imagine that there was strong social cohesion within the peasant communities … [and t]he crisis and abandonment of many of these settlements in the Norman age could therefore be linked to the agency of new elite and social groups that broke the system of solidarity” (101). What she envisions before is a latifundia system that became large imperial estates, which at some point before Gregory the Great were taken over by the church, and eventually the Islamic invaders. That is, there was superstratal change of the ruling, wealthy elite, with limited effect on other registers of society. What was devastating to Sicily was that the produce and taxation during the Byzantine period did not circulate around the island but was channeled into churches and the superstratal elite, or left the island entirely. The process was exacerbated by the split between the Bishop of Rome and the Eastern church: the Pope was the major landowner in Sicily but he was, technically, the tenant of the emperor in Constantinople. The history of Byzantium in Sicily was one of impoverishment in the midst of great wealth.
“The transformation of the Adriatic Islands from Antiquity to the Early Middle Ages” (111–37), by M. Jurkovic, is at its best in tracing the 6th- and 9th-c. changes to the landscape. The coast of modern Croatia has 1,187 islands, of which about 100 were inhabited in antiquity (111). The three northernmost (Rab, Cres-Losinj [with St. Peter and Ilovik islets],Footnote 9 and Krk) are the most important since they are safely tucked inside a bay, Quarnero Bay, for which Pola stands sentry at the headland on the west and not too far south from Trieste. This area was crucial at several periods, but most especially in Late Antiquity since it had the geographical misfortune to be at the seam between East and West. A better job of editing would have made the information much more immediate. Two (crucial) examples stand for all. First, the modern and ancient names are given for most sites; unfortunately, one name is generally given in the text and the other on the map. Several sites, and most significantly the important sites of Barbat (124) and Kanajt (133), are not listed at all. To have used Apsorus and not its modern name Osor would have avoided confusion with an 8th-c. bishop of the same name who appears often.Footnote 10 Secondly, the maps could be more informative: fig. 5.1 (113) gives a coastal route for cabotage and two open-sea routes for shipping, depending on the direction of the prevailing wind. The map is referenced twice (130, 135), but cursorily and far away from the discussion.
J. chooses two political events for his terminus post quem and terminus ante quem for the Late Antique period in this region: the retirement of Diocletian to Split, well south of the islands in this report, in 305 CE, and the Treaty of Aachen (812 CE), which apportioned the mainland to the Franks and the islands to Byzantium. The three-island region has been subjected to intensive survey, with some spot excavation of areas, much of it by J. himself. Rab/Arba quickly became preeminent and so has a history distinct to itself,Footnote 11 but the general pattern is a scattering of villas of the 2nd and 3rd c. CE (121, 122, 127–28, 129, 132), many repurposed into churches/church property or fortifications (124, 132–33). The adoption of Christianity in the 4th c. CE (113) was quick and thorough: the greatest number of church foundations belong to the late 5th or 6th c. CE. Some of these must predate the Gothic Wars (535–54 CE; 119, 121); some, close to fortifications associated with the Gothic Wars, belong to the middle of the 6th c. (119, 129, 131, and esp. 134); and a few are securely dated to the last half of the 6th c. (119, 132).Footnote 12 Establishment of monasteries occurred largely in the 11th c. (119, 120, and 121 [nunnery]) and without exception are in proximity to a 6th-c. church foundation.
Two important points emerge. The first concerns apses of 6th-c. churches and in some cases early 9th-c. modification. Sometimes a double concentric apse, like the one at Banjol (118), seems to be like the one in Corsica (43), and is earlier in the sequence of churches. The church at Kalifront (not pictured, 121–22) has the same modification as at Kanajt (fig. 5.10, 132–33), where in the 6th c. a large, deep apse was subdivided into two smaller apses, with a wall in front of the modified double apse and an altar in front of the wall. J. indicates that the change was to facilitate the Western liturgy (133).
These modifications look to the second point: there would seem to be clear evidence of renovations for liturgical reasons as these three islands were taken by the Franks in 803 and the Western rite was established. When the Treaty of Aachen (812) restored these islands to Byzantine control, the cross-wall behind the altar became an icon screen; otherwise, Western rite modifications were left untouched. The Franks had been pushing into Byzantine Dalmatia from the buffer state of Lombardy from 780,Footnote 13 and the Second Council of Nicaea (İznik, 787) was the last council to be signed by both the Bishop of Rome (Adrian I, 792–95) and the archbishop in Constantinople.Footnote 14 The Quarnero Workshop (116, 130) and the workshop of the Master of the Zadar Ambos (116, 126) are references to changes made in churches during the Frankish domination of the islands (803–12 CE; 122, 124). J. interprets some spot abandonment of these islands as pro-Frankish factions leaving for the mainland (125).
“Macro-economy, micro-ecology, and the fate of urbanized landscape in Late Antique and Early Byzantine Crete” (139–62), by E. Zanini, examines the transformation of Gortyn, capital of the Roman province, in the “framework of a dialogue between micro-ecological and macro-economic factors” (xxv), and is intriguing because it posits that the case for resilience is always stronger for micro-ecologies because a polis (in its widest territorial sense) will always have more impact over its immediate area than it can control, and so will react in an organized manner to large forces beyond its control. He examines particularly the response in Crete to the devastating earthquake of 365 CE that tilted the island, raising the west part by as much as 9 m and lowering the eastern end about as much. He sees the micro-level (the earthquake) in light of larger shifts: that is, the shift of the attention of the eastern half of the empire toward the new capital at Constantinople and the involvement of the emperors in conflicts in the east, not the west.
Z. attempts to have it both ways. In one sense, Crete is special because it is the only island not visible from any point on any mainland and so more remote and protected but was devastated by the earthquake that left the rest of the Mediterranean untouched (140). On the other hand, Crete is “at the intersection point of the Roman and Byzantine large Mediterranean macro-economic systems” (141). In Gortyn and Crete, Z. finds confirmation of the Mediterranean as a continuum of interlocking and overlapping systems that were social and political as well as physical:Footnote 15 it is confirmation of Arnaud's paradox that Crete, by being a very remote island, was at the center of things.Footnote 16 It also confirms the coexistence of opposites in that Crete was a contact point with a stable local situation in the midst of an empire shaking apart (141). The number of multi-period surveys honeycombing the island reveal a pattern of persistence and wealth of the countryside greater than on other islands (143).
Crete is particularly revealing because much of the abandonment of pagan structures and constriction in the size of cities was taking place before the earthquake. Z. makes sense of this through a declining labor force: the 4th c. could not build because there were not the hands to do it. The recovery of the 5th c. represented not just an increase in population but infrastructure repair, part of which was funded by proceeds of the monopoly in water granted to the church (148). The aqueduct system at Gortyn is civic and religious, an index to the size of the population but also to where people were building homes. The amount of construction was massive: no fewer than 50 neighborhood fountains are known (150). But even in this, Crete reflects larger trends, the “macro” of macro-economics (153–56): the kinds of buildings (private over civic; church over civic) reflect the general trends elsewhere, as do choices in building materials and clusters of neighborhoods. By simultaneous micro-ecologies Z. means that, in the difficult times after Justinian, Cretan cities (as elsewhere) made choices about which buildings to maintain and which to abandon (156–59). Each region made its own choices, and sometimes those choices were different from one place to another. Of the four main cities in Crete, at this same period one remained vibrant, one was abandoned, and two hung on but by different strategies.
The two best excavated and reported Late Antique cities in Crete are Gortyn and Eleutherna. Z. looks at the former and C. Tsigonaki, in “Crete, a border at the sea: Defensive works and landscape-mindscape changes, seventh–eighth centuries A.D.” (163–92), considers mainly the latter, an entrepot of the interior, but also Gortyn and Polyrrhenia, whose defensive works contributed to the creation of a “powerscape” (xxv). The series of walls and towers defended the cities against Arab attacks, launched principally by the caliphates in Syria and Egypt, which eventually ruled Crete from 827 to 961 CE. T.'s exposition of the different invasions and incursions introduces her contribution (163–66). Crete, like Cyprus, was viewed as a buffer between Byzantines and Muslims, with both sides seeking the islands as advance naval bases and depriving their enemy of these footholds (166–68).
The next section of the chapter (168–79) presents T.'s three case studies: Gortyn (168–72), Eleutherna (172–75), and Polyrrhenia (175–79). What is known at Gortyn encircles the ancient acropolis and also protects the large Byzantine cisterns (169). The masonry is polygonal when necessary but ashlar when possible (fig. 7.5); mortar and rubble are visible. T.'s surmise that they seem to be mentioned in a text referring to an event in 740 is perhaps the most precise dating possible (171–72). The size and wealth of Eleutherna's Early Christian lower city is incontestable (173). The fortifications that survive, however, are clustered around a tower which has a Hellenistic foundation level (Pyrgi; figs. 7.5 and 7.6). As at Gortyn, the fortifications around the tower encircled the acropolis and included two rock-cut cisterns. Polyrrhenia, like Eleutherna, was a site facing north with protection from a mountain to its south, from which it was able to dominate whatever settlements were visible. The construction of the Byzantine walls (figs. 7.8 and 7.9, 176–78) are closely similar to the Justinianic ones outside Corinth, and also have a preliminary Hellenistic phase (177).
T. suggests that the walls purposely separated residences of local authorities from the rest of the citizens and that the towers, at least initially, if not primarily, protected leaders from riots by their own citizens (180). When the enemy was external, locals could flood inside the walls for protection (181). The extent of the walls at Polyrrhenia indicates that it provided shelter for neighboring communities as well as its own citizens (181). T. points out that many of these fortified places were visible to one another (182). There was thus a network, and for her this means central planning and organized construction, so that the greatest number of citizens could find shelter in a hurry.
“Islands and resilience: Christianization processes in the Cyclades” (193–216), by R. Sweetman, addresses the speed and thoroughness of conversion in the southern Aegean islands. The plural “processes” is intentional, as conversion was achieved in a number of ways. Her most important conclusion, though, is that the islands of the southern Aegean have so much “natural resilience … [it] meant that the impact of Christianity was minimal on daily life” (193). This follows from her other central observation, contrasting what archaeology finds on the ground in the Cyclades with the negative estimation of literary sources that “the lived experience is the resilient and dynamic one, while the notional one [i.e., literary] is conservative and isolated” (194).
S.'s instinct is to think of resilience in terms of ecology and not society: key to this view is Pelling on adaptation as a negotiation between what needs to be preserved as opposed to what is expendable, conceived in terms of what the soils and climate can bear,Footnote 17 as is also Rose on how and how fast the landscape deals with swift, short-lived disasters and long-term events.Footnote 18 S.'s observation that islands had a strong sense of community which allowed them to absorb changes and face climate change as a common threat (196) fits nicely with Petzold's argument that island response does not imply passivity but rather works because of flexibility enabling constant change and non-linear solutions.Footnote 19
For S., the Christianization of the Cyclades is intelligible through the joint application of complexity theory and resilience theory (196–201). Further, since the process of response is one of trying several solutions, sharing ideas/collaboration, rethinking and reshaping ideas and solutions, and moving with speed as much as is practicable, it also becomes clear that change among regional groups of islands, and Mediterranean-wide, was highly individualized. In light of the complexity of the circumstances on the ground, changing group dynamics, and some event that put the process in motion (197), it is easy to see how Christianity was a beneficiary and not a mover.
Christianization came early to the Cyclades; catacombs are known from the 2nd c. CE. When churches came to be constructed, their builders took pains to make them visible in the landscape and from the sea, in essence becoming advertising for themselves (204). In other places and circumstances, such as Delos and Andros, Christianity eased itself into areas and communities that already had a rich and extensive religious fabric (205–6). At least initially, churches were likely to be built close to pagan monuments instead of on top of them (209). In S.'s view, because the islands were used to change, it was easy for Christianity to insert itself (207–9). The abundance of early churches in ports shows both visibility and non-threatening presence in the social fabric. The location of the churches also suggests continuity of habitation (209–11); again, the conclusion that S. draws from this is that churches are but one facet among many of resilience.
“The Christianization of island landscapes in Late Antiquity and the Early Middle Ages: New perspectives from Naxos in the Aegean” (217–34), by S. Turner and J. Crow, focuses on the island of Naxos in the Cyclades and attempts to assess the impact of conversion to Christianity on the landscape from 600 to 900 CE. Their outlook is post-conversion in that they are interested in the period in which the Church became the major landowner in many communities – a temporal as well as religious power. They are aware that dating is a problem because the evidence is sparse and not always easy to identify but argue that “the majority of the 11 early Christian basilicas … [belong] to the sixth century” (222).
T. and C. suggest that once a church was founded the local impulse was to repair, reshape, and renovate rather than build a new church in a different location. The 7th c. through the 9th c. should, in their view, be seen as persistence, rather than poverty (223). Perhaps their most important contribution to understanding the changeover to Christianity is that they see most church foundations as having been political in nature and not religious. For T. and C., founding a church was the marker of a local grandee establishing his area of influence. So more churches, for which they cite the parallel of Ireland, meant smaller regions, which in turn meant decentralization (223); the 150 Early Medieval churches on Naxos is thus administratively significant, not religiously.
The problem they try to assess is the relation of churches to settlements and to the land (224–29). Here the information is not decisive, as churches can be in settlements, near to settlements, or in remote locations, and as likely on arable land as in less productive terrain. By the medieval period a decision to found a church and the choice of site was more likely to be a local decision and not that of the clergy or local potentate. The preliminary results of T. and C.'s survey region are hardly surprising: the size of Byzantine churches tends to shrink over time; structural members supporting domes tend to be spolia; small churches tend to be near small settlements; and there are more churches in the countryside than in settlements. What is interesting in this pattern are a number of churches that can be associated with the period of iconoclasm.
“The islands of the southern Aegean from Late Antiquity to the Early Middle Ages: The archaeological evidence” (235–56), by N. Poulou, encompasses the Cyclades, Kea off the coast of Attica, Kythera south of Sparta, Rhodes and its neighboring islands off the coast of Turkey (the Dodecanese), and Crete. The project that P. sets for herself is to address “changes in human activity and settlement patterns, contacts with neighboring and distant areas, and sea routes and trade networks during a period of transformation leading from the Late Roman period to the Early Middle Ages” (235). The coming of Islam to the shores of the Aegean is her particular focus, as it was at the time, since the Aegean is the gateway to Constantinople and the link of the capital city to the Mediterranean. The appearance of Muslims on the coast of Turkey had wide implications for administration, commerce, defense, and communications. Her examples, then, consider the extent and effect of the changes in numerous places.
Rhodes and Cos represent the Dodecanese (236–43). By the 7th c. Rhodes had constructed imposing defenses which it strengthened continually over the next two centuries. For Cos, an earthquake in the mid-6th c. required complete rebuilding of the harbor. At this time basilicas appeared and pagans moved statues of Aesculapius (fig. 10.4) to an underground worship space. The case for continuity and resilience in Cos even in the face of Arab raids is credited to the commercial standing of the island and the persistence of its social elite (240). Rural settlements continued to be close to the sea and near to or on settlements of earlier periods (241–42). Warehouses needed to be close to the sea and remained so (Agathonisi, fig. 10.6), and pottery production could use salt water rather than the more scarce fresh water (Mastichari, fig. 10.5). P. is able to link the Hayes Sarachane type 45 amphora (9th c.) to the Yenikapı shipwrecks, known from the Istanbul tunnel excavations, which grounds the chronology.
“Economic landscapes and transformed mindscapes in Cyprus from Roman times to the Early Middle Ages” (257–84), by A. Vionis and G. Papantoniou, interprets isolation and integration on Cyprus in terms of interregional and intercultural contacts. The authors’ view is Braudelian but reconciled to Horden and Purcell with their emphasis on globalism, regionalism, and localism that are concentric and overlapping bubbles of influence. Perhaps their greatest contribution to the volume is to remind us that administration during the Late Antique and Early Medieval period was a pendulum that swung back and forth from administrative segmentation to unification (257). Within this, they see a constant dialogue between the landscape and the attitudes and needs of those who depend on it. Following Broodbank, they consider the key feature of any island to be diversity and so a “plurality of interpretative approaches” will always be required (258).Footnote 20 Where V. and P. strike interesting new ground is in their view that Cyprus, particularly in Late Antiquity, like Crete, was self-sufficient. Its contact with other islands and the mainland was significant and unbroken, but it was a contact that Cypriots deemed useful or advantageous, rather than necessary (258). Because of their belief in environmental determinism, the authors consider that landscape archaeology offers the best chance to “contextualize settlement change and evaluate it within a multi-layered explanatory framework … environmental, politico-economic, ideational, and computational” (259).
The Roman period on Cyprus (259–65) was one of abandonment of traditional local shrines and one in which Romans invested heavily in construction in the cities and the traditional pagan cults. By the Council of Ephesus (431) there were 15 bishops on Cyprus who were given wide autonomy in their actions on the island. At the same time there was a sustained explosion in rural settlement, industrial activity, and commercial expansion that lasted until the 7th c. (263). To this period belong numerous private and public structures that combined pagan iconography in a Christian setting and also the establishment of more than 60 basilicas (263). Here, as opposed to elsewhere, the size of the basilica was tied to wealth and pride. Having no martyrs of their own to promote, the founders of some basilicas dedicated them to saints who would attract pilgrims to their churches and thus money to local coffers (264).
The Xeros Valley settlement region is discussed as an example of “community area theory” (265) in which there is continuity of location with the prior phase of the town but construction is moved to the side of the older phase and not on top of it. Church location, though, is persistent, as in the 11th-c. church at Kofinou on the footprint of the much larger and earlier triple-aisled basilica. What the authors find particularly striking is the high proportion of local fabrics in ceramics: about one-fourth of the sherds were from transport amphorae. With about 250–300 families, the settlement, in their analysis, qualifies as an “agro-town” (269). The much smaller settlement at Kalavasos-Koperta, about 100 families, is classed as a “market village.” Further up the register (as an emporion, 269) would be Pyla-Koutsopetria, not necessarily larger than Kofinou but with houses with opus sectile pavements, and a harbor, as well as agriculture and mining. V. and P.'s concentric circle analysis (270–73) attempts to connect the centers one to another in a hierarchy in which any node produces all of what is necessary.
The authors see this pattern being modified in the mid-7th to 9th c., in which period the nodes dissolve and the different communities of whatever size become “peer villages” (274), that is, subsistence communities. Rather than class the period as one of decline (“downward city-curve”), V. and P. stress instead “an optimistic steady countryside-curve” (274). Their rationale is that, while the city centers had suffered more when they had less, the countryside, which had comparatively less, kept a steady rate. The decline in import wares is thus not because they could no longer afford the items but because the centers that produced them declined (275). There was not an absolute end to imports: Hayes Sarachane type 36 wares are found on Cyprus (276) and they are still found in coastal areas. Cyprus was positioned to profit from both powers: numismatic evidence indicates the presence of the Byzantine military on Cyprus, and Arab and Byzantine communities existed side by side in Paphos in the 8th c. (the “condominium years,” 276). What emerges is a Cyprus that is a “zone of cross-imperial interaction, rather than a cultural barrier between antagonistic empires” (277). What V. and P. think ended this period in which Cyprus sold to both sides was not military or political or religious but the onset of a cold period when climate change wrecked Cypriot means of production (278).
The interaction of “change” and “resilience” in the book's overall title is one that should be asked of the recent stream of conference volumes and plethora of articles on insularity. This volume does much to establish a special place for islands in studies of the transition from Late Antiquity to the Middle Ages. “Change,” impossible to resist, was inevitable with the changeover of empires and religions (here, as much the jockeying between Christian creeds as the fight against followers of Muhammad) and the reorganization of taxation and merchant activities and routes, but no two of the islands in this book felt the changes equally. The same applies to “resilience,” which meant different things to each island and even within an island or island group. Cities were not uniformly abandoned and the countryside cannot simply be compared to towns because, depending on geography and topography, rural areas carved out or walled up their own response.
