The fall of the Roman Empire, its causes and course, has long fascinated researchers, with generations of scholars at least as far back as Edward Gibbon continually trying to reinterpret this phenomenon. A. Gandila's study, published in 2018 and based upon his doctoral dissertation defended in 2013, is well embedded within this debate. His 376-page book is complemented by a separate digital appendix, available to download as a PDF file, containing detailed numismatic data. The book's seven chapters are dedicated to the following: Roman frontiers in Late Antiquity; a cultural background of divisions in the Danube area and deep Barbaricum, along with analysis of chosen categories of Byzantine/Late Roman imports north of the Danube; Christianization of the area in question; a recap of the author's foregoing observations; and three final chapters focusing on coins. In my opinion, allocating three chapters to the discussion of coins was the correct decision, as I share both the author's view that “In many ways coins are the most complex and intriguing Byzantine objects” (153), and his justification that
Unlike the bewildering variety of artefacts ordered by archaeologists according to somewhat artificially defined criteria, coinage needs no such arrangements. Byzantine money has already been classified by the issuing authority into different denominations, mints, and dates and the same coins circulating in the Empire can be found outside the frontier. (154)
Focusing upon the history of the Lower Danube from the 5th to the 7th c. CE, G. primarily draws upon material evidence for changes that took place during this time, as opposed to literary evidence which plays an unquestionably minor role in the narrative. He rightly observes the uneven development of studies regarding the fall and transformation of the Roman World, where “The Western provinces enjoy the most privileged position” (1), but North Africa, the Middle East, and the Middle and Lower Danube basin have received much less attention.Footnote 1 Consequently, G.'s work is of particular interest for the broad comparative background he provides for the Lower Danube foreland, including the Middle Danube territories, Black Sea Steppes, and Transcaucasia.
In the following review I intend to address two questions relating to interpretations within Migration Period studies drawn from the analysis of material evidence. The first is whether finds relating to the barbarians known, for example, from Gaul and the Balkans support the interpretation that the fate of the Empire was determined solely by the great mass of traveling barbarians, or whether the movement of the small groups of barbarian elites contributed to the transformation of the Roman world, termed by G. Halsall the “movers and shakers.”Footnote 2 The second question is whether the transition recorded in finds from the barbarian realm are a result of conscious choices and actions of the barbarians or simply reflective of general changes in the world of Late Antiquity. For example, are the large quantities of 6th-c. bronze coins in the Balkans indicative of “invasion” by the Avars and Slavs, or “inflation” within the Empire, as phrased by F. Curta?Footnote 3
Databases
Numismatic evidence
A catalog covering areas “from the Ore Mountains (separating Saxony from Bohemia) to the Caucasus … from eighteen modern countries” (Appendix A, 1) provides the background for further considerations. The Carpathian Basin, Lower Danube, and Black Sea coast mark the southern border of the territory in question and the Baltic Sea coast marks the northern border. The author includes finds from the 6th–7th c.: in the case of coins, from the issuances of Anastasius (491–518) to those of Justinian II (685–95/705–11).
The majority of work on the catalog came to a close in 2014 (Appendix A, 4 n. 12), although data continued to be added (see, for example, cat. nos. 360a and 411a). It should be emphasized that the catalog does reflect data collected by other researchers, and there is clear evidence for the verification of earlier information by G. and repeated corrections to outdated coin terminology (Appendix A, 7 n.17; 13 n.27; 13 n.29; 24 n.49; 42 n.88), including my own work.
It is not my intention to point out the omission of one coin or another, which is unavoidable in this type of study.Footnote 4 Instead, I would rather concentrate on several more general problems, especially since the comparison of particular regions is fundamental to G.'s final conclusions in which he defines the “Land of Gold” (the Carpathian Basin), the “Land of Bronze” (the Lower Danube), and the “Land of Silver” (Transcaucasia) (see Chapters 5 and 6).
The author openly admits that his database is to some extent reflective of the state of research in the given countries (Appendix A, 1). While research on Byzantine coins in Poland, the Czech Republic, Slovakia, Hungary, and Romania is acknowledged as good (or even very good), that in the former Soviet Union territories poses a real challenge:
The finds from southern Ukraine have been thoroughly published or republished by Elena Stolyarik, although here as well it turned out to be a compilation based on the previous works of P. O. Karyshkovskii, A. A. Nudel'man, and V. V. Kropotkin. To be sure, any study of the Byzantine numismatic material from the former Soviet Union still has to rely heavily on Kropotkin's corpus, which is now over half a century old, although it undoubtedly was an impressive tour de force at that time. (Appendix A, 3)
Armenia and Georgia are also lacking up-to-date corpora of finds, and therefore materials republished in the MONETA series served as a starting point for the author.Footnote 5 Notably, as highlighted by G., in the case of Georgia this reflects the state of knowledge before the era of metal detecting (Appendix A, 4). Similarly, in Armenia there is a noticeable lack of data concerning stray finds, with evidence concentrated upon the fortresses in Duin and Ani (Appendix A, 4).
I do not dispute differences in the appearance of Byzantine coins in the 5th–7th c. between, for example, the “Land of Gold” and the “Land of Bronze.” I am, however, convinced that differences in data acquisition strategies among researchers from Poland, Hungary, Slovakia, and Georgia are crucial to our current knowledge concerning types of coins occurring in particular regions of east-central and eastern Europe, as highlighted in my proceeding discussion.
Large-scale metal detecting has radically changed our knowledge of material evidence for early European history. Since it is impossible to stop the spread of metal detecting, it is important to consider its impact upon our knowledge of the past. Inevitably, however, this varies between countries, as a consequence of the lack of uniform regulations concerning metal detecting both in EU countries and across Europe as a whole.
For instance, Scandinavian countries, particularly Denmark, and Great Britain have instituted significant regulations permitting metal detecting. However, this liberalism has been met with rising opposition from other European countries, where “the freedom with which metal detectorists operate … has been characterised as the ‘English disease.’”Footnote 6 In other European countries, including east-central and eastern Europe, the attitude is far less liberal, where enforced legal regulations restrict the activities of metal detectorists.
It should be stressed that metal detecting has an impact not only upon the quantity of coins recovered, which seems obvious, but also upon the types of coins. Sustained observations, for example from Denmark (Gudme, Sorte Muld), show beyond doubt that the large-scale use of metal detectors has led to a radical increase in the number of less attractive metal finds overlooked during traditional archaeological explorations (i.e., those without a metal detector).Footnote 7
Therefore, I am deeply convinced that studies compiling numismatic data from multiple countries should include a brief explanation of the different legal regulations regarding the use of metal detectors in these countries, as well as the availability of data from detectorists’ surveys and whether the study incorporates this category of finds into its catalog. Significantly, G. did not include metal detector finds from the territory of the former Soviet Union in his study, despite having the right and being in a position to do so, and it is important to highlight the consequences of this.
The evidence from Denmark and that collected by K. Myzgin on Roman coins from eastern Europe unequivocally illustrates discoveries of huge numbers of coins, including bronze ones. Myzgin's study on provincial (and therefore bronze) coins should be cited here:
Until recently, finds of Roman provincial coins in the territory of Ukraine were rare (no more than thirty coins). But in recent years, the situation has radically changed, due to the active use of metal detectors. Today, we can talk about several hundred, or even thousands, of finds of Roman provincial coins, most dating to the 3rd century AD and minted in the cities of the Balkan provinces.Footnote 8
Coins, as we know, were already objects of interest in Antiquity, thus both individual coin finds and collections can be much older than archaeological ones. Such finds, lacking location and contextual information, present an issue for researchers: nobody, for example, considers the Ashmolean Museum's collection a source to study coin circulation in the British Isles. But how should researchers deal with coins from Budapest, Bucharest, or even smaller towns such as Pécs or Cluj Napoca?
To put it simply: there is no single correct answer to this question. A few years ago, a bronze issue of Justinian II (685–95) was found during regular excavations at Tałty in the Mazurian Lake District.Footnote 9 Had this coin been discovered in a museum in Białystok or Olsztyn, an original Polish provenance would have been considered impossible; early Byzantine coins are virtually absent in the Baltic territories and there is no evidence of coin finds from the second half of the 7th c. in the entirety of Poland. It is more than likely that it would have been assumed that the coin perhaps originated from a collection scattered during World War II, possibly purchased by a local Prussian history enthusiast in the Balkans or the Near East. Nevertheless, this Justinian II coin was recovered during regular excavations at Tałty.
The Biesenbrow hoard represents one of the most important coin finds from eastern Germany. Originally discovered in the mid-19th c., the composition of the assemblage has raised serious doubts as to its origins and whether all of the coins genuinely belong to such a big hoard. For instance, a metal detector survey carried out in 2011 recovered 10 more coins pertaining to the hoard, dating from the 5th–6th c. and struck in Constantinople, Ravenna, and Rome.Footnote 10 Ordinarily, a museum would question the reported location of their discovery, but they really were recovered in Biesenbrow.
Standing in contrast to these two case studies is that of Carnuntum in Lower Austria. This site has produced a considerable volume of early Byzantine coins, yet none of them – despite many decades of archaeological activity – have been discovered during systematic excavation.Footnote 11 We largely owe the information we have on these coins to the passion of Odhin Lerner, a local social and political activist (in the Austrian People's Party), and his friend Adolf Nedelik.Footnote 12 The work of Lerner and Nedelik, published after Lerner's death in 2009, describes their novel approach to recording the activities relating to the discovery of Byzantine coins in Carnuntum from local collectors themselves, characterized as “a new way of numismatic research: coin-hunting by door-knocking.”Footnote 13
It should be stressed that, thanks to the study of Lerner and Nedelik, we know about more than 30 Byzantine and 5 Ostrogothic coins from Carnuntum, a Roman site located at the periphery of the Avar Khaganate.Footnote 14 Notably, coins represent the only category of finds from the 6th–7th c. at Carnuntum. Moreover, this volume of coins is particularly puzzling in light of the evidence from Keszthely, where only a single coin from the era of Justinian has been recorded, despite substantial evidence for Roman settlement in the 6th–7th c.Footnote 15 Consequently, this raises questions regarding the credibility of the information relating to these coin finds from Carnuntum.
Coins from museum collections create a substantially larger problem.Footnote 16 A list of Byzantine gold coins from the Hungarian National Museum in Budapest has been published by A. Kiss. K. notes that finds from outside the Hungarian Carpathian Basin in Hungarian collections are extremely rare, due to the political situation of Hungary in the 19th c. (“wie ein weisser Rabe”).Footnote 17 Nevertheless, he is inclined to suggest that they are of local origin from within the Carpathian Basin. Similarly, E. Oberländer-Târnoveanu argues that coin collections in Romanian museums also reflect local coin circulation.Footnote 18
In contrast, P. Somogyi is more skeptical when assessing the reliability of coins from museum collections, an issue he discussed extensively in a chapter published in 1997. In this study, he divided the Byzantine gold coins kept at the National Museum in Budapest into five classes (I–V): class I are coins discovered in burials; class II are stray finds with an unquestionable provenance within the Avaria territory; class III includes coins from the museum with some data regarding the place of purchase, owner residence, etc.; classes IV–V encompass coins from former private collections, currently belonging to the museum (IV), or coins known from the museum's Revisionsinventarbuch (V), both with unknown provenance.Footnote 19
Inevitably, the credibility of the resolution of data pertaining to classes III–V is in question. S. concludes that the class III coins originate from the area of Avar settlement, albeit with some reservations.Footnote 20 The evaluation of classes IV–V is more difficult, but the data collected by S. does not support his conclusion that these finds have no relation to the circulation of coins in the Khaganate. He is aware of this, even in reflections on the reliability of finds from the collections in Győr and Pannonhalma.Footnote 21 In a 2014 study, S. generally maintained his stance on the low credibility of coins from the collection, despite reservations formulated by, among others, me and P. Prohászka.Footnote 22 I wish to stress that, although in my opinion S.'s skepticism seems too far-reaching, I do respect such an attitude, as it has the indisputable advantage of forcing all numismatic studies of the Carpathian Basin to present the circumstances of the discovery of every published coin in as much detail as possible.
Among the gold coins of Heraclius (r. 610–41) undeniably discovered in the Avarian context – classes I and II according to S. – those dated before 626 predominate. To some extent, this helps facilitate the assessment of the reliability of museum collections consisting of gold coins: if coins minted between 626 and 641 prevail, they probably do not come from the Carpathian Basin. In the case of bronze coins – far more numerous in east-central and eastern European museums than issues of precious metals – we lack such a criterion.
Clearly, in his study G. is aware of unprovenanced coins, yet in the case of collections from Belgrade and Zagreb he concludes that they represent local finds (Appendix A, 50 n. 101). Overall, I believe the question remains unresolved of how credible numismatic material from museum collections is, and it is likely that no singular solution to this problem will be found. Collections from large centers, such as Budapest, should undoubtedly be perceived differently from those of small towns, and it is clear that attempts to record in detail the history of collections are vitally important.Footnote 23 The preceding remarks on the veracity of coins obtained from detectorists and museum collections aimed to draw attention to the fundamental issue regarding the circulation of coins in east-central and eastern Europe in the 5th–7th c. and have highlighted the continuing questionable credibility of coin finds other than those discovered by archaeologists.
Consequently, doubt is cast upon the feasibility of the zones defined by G., who writes that “At least three major patterns of distribution can be distinguished: Transcaucasia, dominated by regular and ceremonial silver coinage, the Lower Danube region where copper coin finds are overwhelming, and the Carpathian Basin where gold issues predominate” (285), and, moreover, that
Copper coins did not play a significant social function in the Carpathian Basin, where the legacy of the Huns had engendered a strong preference for gold. The Lower Danube region remains alone in its emphasis on bronze coinage. For all intents and purposes the Middle Danube, the Drava, and the Sava rivers flowing from the Alps were lost to the Empire and no coherent system of fortification can be found there to help distribute Byzantine copper coins in the Carpathian Basin. Such coins are rare and were mostly brought from Italy, rather than the Balkans. (286–7)
According to G., “Four-to-five times more Byzantine gold is to be found in Central Europe than in the Lower Danube region, at the expense of the base metal coinage whose influx always depended on a permanent Byzantine presence” (220).
One should ask the following: Did silver really dominate in the “Land of Silver?” And do we really not know of any bronze coins from the “Land of Gold?” Above, I showed that the widespread use of metal detectors (and the possibility of publishing detectorists’ finds) increases the volume of information on coins of smaller value – in our case, bronze coins. Nevertheless, G. only includes data from older studies pertaining to the area of the former USSR and does not include data from metal detecting. Therefore, the number of bronze coins from modern-day Ukraine, Armenia, and Georgia may be underestimated, and should be borne in mind, for example, when reading his remarks on the bronze coin hoard from Ochamchire (Abkhazia):
This is in fact one of the rare copper coin hoards found in Transcaucasia where we do not see the hoarding frenzy that characterizes the last decades of the sixth century in the Balkans. In Lazica and Armenia most hoards are of gold or silver which tell us that soldiers on the Eastern front were detailed to a higher pay grade. (210)
Furthermore, when comparing data on coins from the Middle and Lower Danube area, specifically in the case of lands inhabited by Avars, G. draws upon information collected by Somogyi. In my opinion, the latter's skepticism with regards to finds other than those discovered in archaeological contexts has led to an underestimation of the number of bronze coins in circulation in the Avar Khaganate.
I do not know what type of Byzantine coins entered the huge areas between Wienerwald, the west of Bohemia, and the east of the Caucasus in the 5th–7th c. I also do not know who is right: Somogyi with his distrust of the old collections or the more optimistic researchers. I do, however, believe that comparison of such huge areas requires both the comprehensive and exhaustive presentation of the database, and detailed consideration of the representativeness of the data collected.
In my personal opinion, a scenario where bronze coins, mass-minted from the end of the 5th c., dominate the areas from eastern Austria and western Bohemia through southern Poland, Slovakia, Hungary, Romania, Moldavia, and Ukraine to Georgia and Armenia seems highly possible. Two areas included in this “Land of Bronze” stand out: Transcaucasia – or the “Island of Silver” – exhibiting a mass influx of silver coins alongside bronze coins, and Avaria – the “Island of Gold” – with numerous finds of golden coins also alongside bronze coins.
Literary evidence
Although G. does not provide a thorough analysis of the written sources, he often refers to them, so I briefly wish to address some selected problems. Considering it to be an important source for the 6th c. too, G. recalls Priscus of Panium's 5th-c. tale of a Byzantine merchant living among the Huns.Footnote 24 Nevertheless, a more critical approach should emphasize that the literary figures in Priscus's account reflect the situation of the Empire in the 5th c.Footnote 25
The fate of Roman prisoners who came into the hands of Avars or Slavs plays a pivotal role in G.'s considerations. When referring to details concerning the avarice of Emperor Maurice, who hesitated to redeem his subjects from the Khagan's hands (264), the legend of the bad emperor who was severely punished by Phokas soon afterwards, for his parsimony among other things, should not be forgotten.Footnote 26
Christianity
The issue of the Christianization of the Middle and Lower Danube territory, or more specifically archaeological finds possibly associated with the Christianization of this region, is inevitably one of the most crucial research questions. In my opinion, work on this subject should be preceded by a methodological chapter.Footnote 27 G., when reflecting upon the appearance of Christian elements, despite the lack of formal Christianization, refers to colonial motivations for the adoption of Christianity, specifically those evident from Australia (117), as a potential explanation, although one could also point, for example, to Pomerania in the 10th–12th c.Footnote 28 When discussing signs of the cross on early Slavic pottery (126), the work of M. Parczewski is also worth referring to.Footnote 29
The most important issue, however, is the need for a more comprehensive account of the phenomenon of the Keszthely settlement complex. Although G. mentions the site name in his book (117 n. 59), recent progress in the study of this phenomenon deserves further attention, especially because in the Lake Balaton area there is much more explicit evidence for the persistence of Christianity compared to the region north of the Danube.Footnote 30
Interpretations
Certainly, many of the comments made by G. are correct. For example, it is difficult to disagree with the declaration that: “The main purpose is not to attach new ethnic labels to archaeological finds or to perpetuate a time-honored debate – which in my view needs to be shelved – but to understand the nature of cultural contact in its real complexity” (45). His remark that non-Roman finds on the outskirts of the Empire testify not only to barbarian invasions/settlement, but possibly also to the decreasing lure of Romanitas, is also pertinent: “As the Empire was losing ground in this space of cultural negotiation, the prestige of non-Roman objects increased. Being Roman was falling out of fashion” (93).Footnote 31
Chronology of the inflow of Byzantine coins
In his 1997 study, Somogyi unambiguously demonstrated that the influx of gold coins into the Khaganate lasted until 626, when the Avars’ defeat at Constantinople resulted in termination of tributes from the imperial treasury. G.'s work confirms this general notion, and furthermore contributes valuable information about the inflow of coins into the Barbaricum in the 7th c.
I do not deny that the failed Avar siege of Constantinople brought a definitive end to tributes, but it did not necessarily mark the end of all payments by the Empire to the Avars during the reign of Heraclius. In 623, for instance, it is known that, alongside a huge tribute of 200,000 solidi, Heraclius was also forced to send several people from his entourage as hostages, among them his illegitimate son, John, his nephew Stephen, and John, son of the patrician Bonos. These hostages were released between 626 and 636, although regrettably we do not know the ransom price. Surviving written sources relating to similar ransoms paid for members of the imperial family may help to shed some light: for example, in 512, 64,800 solidi were paid for the release of Emperor Anastasius's nephew, and in 532, 144,000 solidi were paid for the release of one of Emperor Justinian's relatives.Footnote 32 Evidence for lower ransoms also survives, but, given the political instability in the Khaganate after 626, it seems likely that a higher ransom would have been demanded.
I would also like to draw attention to G.'s remarks on the events that took place a hundred years earlier. He writes:
The terms most frequently associated with the Hunnic storm in the Balkans and the Carpathian Basin are devastation, collapse, social, economic, and demographic decline. Indeed, there is a sharp decline in the flow of Roman coins to Barbaricum in the first half of the fifth century, but this also coincides with a more general decline of the Late Roman monetary system, reflecting a deeper internal weakness of the Empire at the turn of the fifth century. (161)
The statement that fluctuations in the number of coins known from the Barbaricum “reflect monetary policies in the Empire and not military events on the Danube frontier” (175) appears to be among the most interesting issues analyzed by G.
This observation is of key importance not only for studies on the Balkans in the 5th–7th c., but also for research on distant regions from the Danube, including Polish lands. In the 5th c., the number of coins known from Poland decreases significantly; in the early 6th c. the last wave – Justinian's issues – appears.Footnote 33 In general, we assume that the “decline of coin inflow” in the 5th c. stems from the depopulation of modern-day Polish territory, mostly as the result of migrations. However, using G.'s observations, it is worth considering whether the evolution of the post-classical/early Byzantine coinage is among the prominent factors of change discussed above. Bronze and silver coins were rarely minted in the 5th c. and are therefore absent in Polish lands. However, the reforms of Anastasius followed by those of Justinian revived bronze coinage, and therefore Justinian issues appear in Poland in the 6th c. and not because Slavs arrived there at this time. In my opinion, this issue deserves further consideration in a broader geographical context.Footnote 34
As previously stated, taking into account finds from both the Barbaricum and the Empire increases the value of G.'s work. This double perspective is useful, for example, when he seeks to understand the lack of Maurice coin finds from the last years of this emperor's reign (600–2) on both sides of the border. The view that the phenomenon should be interpreted as “a problem of mint output during these years, rather than a result of successful Byzantine campaigning north of the Danube” (180), deserves particular attention.
The function of bronze coins in Barbaricum
I followed G.'s considerations on the function of bronze coins found north of the Empire with growing interest. Undoubtedly, G. is right when he writes that “Artifacts and copper coins provide a window into the untold story of cultural interaction of a more mundane but durable nature that transcends the high levels of diplomacy and military campaigning illustrated by gold and silver coinage” (241). The issue in question is whether the presumed monetary functions of bronze coins from the lands on the Lower Danube can prove the duration of Romanitas in Dacia into the Justinianic era. Earlier studies on Avar bronze coins also interpreted them as “Zeichen echten Handelsverkehrs, bzw. der Anwesenheit von Händlern.”Footnote 35
Somogyi was (and is) much more skeptical. In his opinion: “Sie [i.e., bronze coins] bei den Awaren eine ähnliche Rolle spielten, wie die aufgelesenen Römischen Bronzemünzen … die byzantinische Herkunft dieser Kupfermünzen vielen awarenzeitlichen ‘Münzsammlern’ nicht bewusst war.”Footnote 36 G. is similarly distrustful: “The theory that they primarily reflect trade between the Empire and communities beyond the frontier or even transactions between communities in the Barbaricum is untenable” (271). When deliberating on how and why bronze coins found their way north of the Danube, he proposes a possible association with the presence of Byzantine soldiers/prisoners: “Displaced Romans dropping low-value coins from their pockets are a good alternative to the multitude of traders envisaged in previous scholarship, for which we lack any information in the sources” (269). First and foremost, however, he strives to collect evidence that would allow us “to believe that coins were a constant and reliable source of copper” (274).
G. argues for the symbolic meaning of coins, with regard primarily to cultural anthropological analyses (specifically in relation to Africa):
In societies where prestige depended largely on access to Roman goods, coins were yet another type of import, to be worn as jewelry, to be given away as gifts, or to be used in ceremonies and rituals. To be sure, Byzantine merchants may have used coins to pay for various products bought from the region close to the Danube, but similar to the Merina from Madagascar, communities in Barbaricum treated coins like any other Byzantine commodity. (273)
One cannot ignore the possibility that the prestige associated with a coin of Roman origin would have maintained its market value. The importance of Roman medallions for barbarian communities can be highlighted.Footnote 37
When considering the function of a bronze coin in Barbaricum, it is worth referring to the example of the Baltic territories, rich in such Roman period finds.Footnote 38 Bronze Byzantine coins, including those from the 6th–7th c., recovered from the early urban center of Gnezdovo are particularly intriguing in the given context.Footnote 39
Discussion of the chronology of the inflow of bronze coins is exceptionally interesting. G. presents evidence for probable changes in the volume of coins minted by different rulers. Remarks on the distribution of individual types of coins are also noteworthy – for example, the lack of semi-folles from Thessaloniki in Barbaricum: “explanation lies in the preference for higher denominations in barbaricum, folles of Nicomedia and Constantinople being favored against half-folles of Thessalonica on account of their size” (177).
A coin from Szadzko
The hexagram from Szadzko in West Pomerania is among the most interesting early Byzantine coins from Poland (MIB 140, Constantinople 625/629).Footnote 40 It is one of the northernmost examples of this type of coin to have been found. Although it cannot be ruled out that this coin arrived on the coast of the Baltic Sea via the Middle Danube in the mid-7th c. – as proposed by G. (Appendix A, cat. no. 403) – I suggest another scenario to be more probable.
The coin in question could have appeared in the Baltic Sea region much later, along with Arabian silver flowing to east-central, eastern, and northern Europe from the second half of the 8th c., together also with other known, older, silver coins of the ancient world: for example, Greek tetradrachms accompanied Arabian dirhams into northern Europe. A decade ago, I pointed to the Persian coin of Chosroes II found in Menzlin (burial no. 32, 8th c. [?]),Footnote 41 as evidence for a circular route, via Rus’ and Scandinavia, by which the coin discussed here reached Pomerania, an argument which was accepted by Somogyi.Footnote 42
The hoard discovered in Anklam in 2009 consisting of Persian and Arabian coins hidden in the early 9th c. argues for the withdrawal of the coin from Szadko from the list of material evidence for Byzantine and East-Central European interrelations in the 7th c.Footnote 43
The issue of the inflow of African and Italian coins to East-Central Europe in the 6th–7th c.
One of the most fascinating questions is the presence of coins minted in northern Africa and Italy in east-central Europe, a phenomenon which the author examines within a broader context that includes finds from the Caucasus.Footnote 44 It should be stressed once again that, for the skeptic Somogyi, such an exotic provenance is a primary reason for distrusting the authenticity of the finds. On the contrary, G. trusts their authenticity, arguing that the presence of these coins in the Barbaricum reflects either barbarian service in the Byzantine army or the transferal of Byzantine troops. This pertains not only to the Middle Danube Basin but also to Poland:
Gepids, Herules, and Lombards served in the Roman armies of Belisarius and Narses in Italy and some crumbs of wealth accumulated in the service of the Empire are reflected in coin finds from their homeland. One method of tracing their movement is by looking at the mints issuing the coins found in the Carpathian Basin. Finds of coins from the Italian mints of Rome and Ravenna are recorded as far north as Poland. … Regardless of their ethnic background, men from central European lands were attracted by warfare in Italy. (226)
In a similar way, G. assesses estimated finds not only from Transylvania (225), but also from the Caucasus (201). Importantly, he interprets finds from the 7th c.: “The hoard from Obârşeni in Moldavia was concealed in the late 650s and included issues of Alexandria, Carthage, and Syracuse. … This suggests that Constans II was already making efforts to reestablish a foothold in the northern Balkans by transferring troops and resources from the west” (189). It should also be highlighted that G.'s footnote (189 n. 124) to this last sentence includes information on the Syracuse follis found in Pinsk, Belarus.Footnote 45
Did Byzantium recruit soldiers from Pripyat in the second half of the 7th c.? I rather doubt it. In this case, the chronology of influx of bronze coins into Barbaricum, including eastern Europe, deserves reconsideration. Does the bronze coin of Heraclius found in Gnezdovo on the Upper Dnieper prove that the area was in the field of interest of the founder of the Heraklid dynasty, or did the coin appear here several centuries later, with the Vikings?Footnote 46 I would be more inclined to agree with either of the latter two points.
Christianity
Chapter 3 of G.'s book, discussing religious life north of the Danube, is of significant value (101–30). I share the author's skepticism that “As far as the sixth century is concerned, we can only conclude that Christianity was hardly an unequivocal phenomenon in the lands north of the Danube and it will take more solid archaeological evidence to change this conviction” (130). In support of this, G. interestingly cites the political fragmentation of the Slavs as one of the reasons for the lack of success of the new faith:
In reality, the diffusion of Christian values in the sixth-century Barbaricum has more to do with the absence of a central power beyond the frontier to oppose Roman leaders in the manner of fourth-century Thervingian leaders. Slavic society was a lot more decentralized, adaptable, and generally tolerant if we accept the statements made in the Strategikon. (116)
Returning to the questions outlined at the beginning of this review, the arguments presented by G. support shakers rather than movers. Interestingly, the study also highlights how the influx of coins into the Barbaricum reflected the monetary situation in the Empire, and not simply the wars waged with the barbarians; thus, inflation was more important than invasion.
Above, I have focused on the disputable moments and weaknesses of G.'s study. Significantly, it should be realized that a thorough study on the history of the region “from the Ore Mountains (separating Saxony from Bohemia) to the Caucasus” (Appendix A, 1) in the 5th–7th c. would require the employment of an entire research group.
The latest studies dedicated to the Migration Period tend to take into consideration not only European history but also that of Africa and regions such as the Middle East or the Caucasus.Footnote 47 G.'s comparative book subscribes to this research trend. Notably, it is a trend which deserves attention, constituting an important source of information on a part of the world which is less known than western Europe.
Overcoming this division is important not only with regard to the Polish and Romanian “defensive obsession with the nation's role as a ‘Latin island’ in Eastern Europe” (42–43), but also for European Medieval Studies in general. As O. G. Oexle noted: “Die Zukunft der Mittelalterforschung … liegt in einer europäischen Komparistik.”Footnote 48
Acknowledgments
I am grateful to M. Trzeciecki (Warsaw) for translation of my remarks, and to E. March (Exeter) for careful proofreading.
